Themes: The Victory of Evil
There is a moment in “Young Goodman Brown” which seems to provide hope for a happy ending, involving the redemption of the protagonist and his wife. It is a false hope, since this is a story by Hawthorne, but it is easy to see how the story might have taken a different turn in other hands. The moment comes when Brown and Faith are about to be baptized into the communion of evil by the devil himself:
“Faith! Faith!” cried the husband. “Look up to Heaven, and resist the Wicked One!”
At this crucial point, Young Goodman Brown rejects the devil and chooses salvation. This choice, however, makes no difference. It is not even important whether any of the events in the forest really took place or not. The devil prevails even if he does not exist, since the corrupt nature of humanity is enough to create hell on earth, even if there is none elsewhere.
Hawthorne is content to let the reader think that Brown might have been dreaming, and even to raise this possibility, because he knows how compelling his view of humanity really is. Once Brown has been introduced to the idea that the respectable, pious people around him are liars and hypocrites, this appears so plausible that he instantly accepts it for the rest of his life. Hawthorne has no interest in any cosmic battle between God and Satan for the souls of men. The story stops with death because the author does not need to go beyond the grave to make his point that, on earth, evil has already won.
Expert Q&A
Find a quote in "Young Goodman Brown" that illustrates his response to evil.
In "Young Goodman Brown," his response to evil is marked by initial bewilderment and later defiance. When learning of his ancestors' actions, he expresses disbelief, saying, "I marvel they never spoke of these matters... We are a people of prayer, and good works to boot, and abide no such wickedness." Later, he defiantly challenges evil, claiming, "You may as well fear him as he fear you." Ultimately, his experiences erode his faith in humanity and himself, leading to cynicism.
How is the Devil's service and congregation depicted in "Young Goodman Brown"?
The Devil's congregation in "Young Goodman Brown" includes all societal levels, from pious community leaders to known sinners, reflecting a pervasive hypocrisy. Goodman Brown is shocked to see respected figures, including religious leaders and the governor's wife, among the attendees. During the service, the Devil preaches, urging sin and corruption, while the converts, including Brown and his wife, are led to acknowledge universal guilt. The scene vanishes when Brown implores Faith to resist the Devil.
Who was corrupted in "Young Goodman Brown" and how is this evident?
Young Goodman Brown is corrupted through his encounter with the devil, which symbolizes a loss of faith in humanity and goodness. The realization that his townspeople, including his wife Faith, have engaged with evil leads him to despair. This experience taints his perception, making him view everyone as hypocrites. His rigid Puritan beliefs prevent him from accepting the duality of human nature, resulting in his complete corruption and loss of faith in the world, himself, and his wife.
Does Goodman Brown escape the devil's clutches? What are Hawthorne's views on human nature and evil?
Goodman Brown does not escape the devil's clutches as he becomes consumed by judgment and suspicion, leading to a life of misery and isolation. Nathaniel Hawthorne explores human nature as inherently containing both good and evil. Brown's failure to reconcile this duality results in his downfall. Hawthorne suggests that evil is present in humanity, but it is not the sole source of happiness, contrasting Brown's inability to accept the coexistence of good and evil.
Devil's Persuasion and Promised Sins in "Young Goodman Brown"
In Nathaniel Hawthorne's "Young Goodman Brown," the devil tempts Brown with the promise of insight into the secret sins of humanity, including heinous acts like murder and infanticide, symbolizing the pervasive nature of sin. Despite this allure, Brown ultimately rejects the devil's baptism, fearing to witness the evil in his wife Faith and himself. The devil persuades Brown by revealing respected townsfolk's complicity with evil and exploiting Brown's curiosity and doubt, leading to his eventual despair and loss of faith.
Evil and Sin in "Young Goodman Brown"
In Nathaniel Hawthorne's "Young Goodman Brown," evil is portrayed as both a personal and pervasive force. The story explores the hypocrisy and "secret sin" of Puritan society, suggesting that evil resides within individuals, as seen in Goodman Brown's journey with the devil. This encounter leads Brown to distrust his community and question his faith, highlighting the destructive impact of sin on his relationships. Hawthorne's work, while allegorical, critiques the Puritan belief in inherent wickedness and suggests that evil is a human trait rather than a supernatural force.
Symbols of good and evil and the gothic tone in "Young Goodman Brown."
In "Young Goodman Brown," symbols of good and evil include the forest, representing the unknown and evil, and Faith's pink ribbons, symbolizing innocence and purity. The gothic tone is established through the eerie, dark forest setting, the mysterious traveler, and the unsettling, dream-like journey that Goodman Brown undertakes, highlighting the pervasive presence of evil.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
