What roles do Ka'tsina and Yellow Woman play in the narrator's decision to follow Silva in "Yellow Woman"?

Quick answer:

The narrator of the story is the woman who follows a strange man from another community into the hills and spends a few days and nights with him. She does not know him, yet she wanders away with him and is sexually intimate with him. The question the reader ponders throughout the story is why did she do that? The narrator tries to explain herself in terms of her own cultural mythology: "I must have been crazy to follow you." Yet, this explanation seems inadequate, as it doesn't explain why she stayed rather than escaping after having sex once or twice. The best explanation that the story provides is the link to her cultural mythology of her people: Pueblo Indian.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The narrator of the story is the woman who follows a strange man from another community into the hills and spends a few days and nights with him. She does not know him, yet she wanders away with him and is sexually intimate with him, even though she is a married woman with children and responsibilities at home. The question the reader ponders throughout the story is, why did she do that? The narrator is clearly wondering the same thing throughout.

The best explanation that the story provides is the link to the cultural mythology of her people (Pueblo Indian). The narrator herself seems to stay for reasons she doesn't fully understand, as she vacillates between knowing that this man is just a man and probably not a safe one to be with and, on the other hand, feeling drawn to stay with him, as though there is a greater meaning to their encounter.

This greater meaning comes from her cultural connection to the spirit world. In essence, her confusion represents the state of many North American Indian peoples whose cultural beliefs seem to be something lost in the past yet remain in their memory. She constantly refers to her grandfather, who was still connected to their cultural history and had no doubt about the truth and meaning of the stories of spirits like Ka'tsina ,who came and kidnapped women from the village. Unlike the narrator, her grandfather did not live between competing realities of Indian and European cultures.

The narrator is drawn by these stories, and this confusion about which world she is in is what draws her to stay longer, even when she feels the desire to escape and return home. The grey area of uncertainty she is in, torn between cultures, is revealed in a moment of dialogue between the two.

"I don't believe it. Those stories couldn't happen now." She tells him, when he insists he is a spirit. He replies, "but someday they will talk about us, and they will say, 'those two lived long ago when things like that happened.'"

The story reveals the experience of being pulled apart by competing cultural realities and perhaps the challenges of belonging to a culture that has almost disappeared. Yet, the meaning of this culture and its stories continues to impact the narrator, such that she is drawn to do something "irrational" to the modern world yet very logical in a sense to her own cultural past.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Yellow Woman went away with the spirit from the north and lived with him [Ka’tsina] and his relatives.  She was gone for a long time, but then one day she came back…”

This is the essence of the myth that the protagonist has been taught in the story “Yellow Woman” by Leslie Marmon Silko.  A ka’tsina in the Pueblo people’s mythology was a benevolent spirit associated with water.  He was often associated with abducting a woman from her community.

The nameless protagonist awakens to find herself not in a dream but in an relationship with a man called Silva.  He has indicated to her that he is a ka’tsina and she is Yellow Woman, another mythological character who represented female sexuality, power, and corn.

The narrator easily falls under the spell of Silva.  Named by Silva, Yellow Woman finds herself caught between two worlds—her everyday life that is unfulfilling to her; and the mythic history of her people as taught by her grandfather. 

Silva, the ka’tsina to her Yellow Woman, tells her that she is going with him to his cabin in the mountains.  Never hestitating, the speaker leaves behind the real world and travels under the spell of this exciting man.  When she goes into the mountains with Silva, time stands still. There is nothing to remind her of the twentieth century 

The sexuality is palpable as Silva constantly touches his modern day Yellow Woman.  The narrator is unsure who or what Silva is.  She begins to believe that she may actually be caught in some other worldly time. Despite this, occasionally she thinks back to her babies and other family that she left behind. 

When the speaker is in his cabin,  Silva pulls her into his world. He continues to intrigue her with his references to their living this mythical dream.

Throughout their time together, the young woman falls further under the influence of this exciting, free time.  Even though she questions Silva, he never admits that he is anything other than the mountain spirit.

After a night of love making, the narrator awakens in the morning. Silva is gone.  She begins to think that she will be with him forever, even making plans about who would take care of her family. The young woman goes for a walk through the pine trees.

When she returns to the cabin, Silva is there dressing a carcass.  He has stolen a cow from the nearby ranchers.  He wants the narrator to accompany him into a nearby town to sell the meat. 

The two ride off to sell the meat.  They run into a man who accuses Silva of rustling his cattle. Speaking the Indian language, Silva tells the narrator to return to the cabin. 

Turning her horse, she begins he ride back until she hears four shots. She aims toward the river where she first met Silva.  Leaving the horse behind, she runs the rest of the way.  It takes all of strength to keep from returning to Silva.

However, she walks back to her house and listens to the voices inside.  They would be glad to see her. She will tell them that she had been kidnapped.

Although she is a married woman with many responsibilities, the encounter with Silva  by the river leads her to leave her old life behind with scarcely asecond thought.  The narrator does not decide to go with Silva but goes because he tells her that she will go.

Realizing that Silva is not the good water spirit, she understands that he is a thief and probably a murderer; the narrator also knows that if Silva were to come for tomorrow that she would probably go.




See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Posted on