Themes: Mental Illness
"The Yellow Wallpaper" is often considered psychological fiction because it offers a first-person account of mental illness. Gilman explores themes such as madness, depression, despair, and self-worth by vividly portraying the stages of a mental breakdown. With nothing to occupy her time and no say in her treatment, the narrator projects her bottled-up emotions onto the yellow wallpaper in her room. She eventually envisions a woman trapped within the wallpaper's pattern, symbolizing her own emotional and intellectual confinement. Without any real outlet for expression or escape, the narrator suppresses her anger and frustration, ultimately spiraling into insanity. Greg Johnson discusses this theme in an essay for Studies in Short Fiction, noting that the story "traces the narrator's gradual identification with her own suppressed rage, figured as a woman grasping the bars of her prison and struggling frantically to get free."
The story also examines how doctors, especially the well-known neurologist S. Weir Mitchell, viewed mental illness in women during the late 1800s. Psychologists often dismissed serious conditions like depression, classifying them as simple hysteria or "a case of the nerves." Mitchell and his colleagues prescribed complete bed rest, believing that intellectual activities were detrimental to women's mental health. In 1935, Gilman emphasized the importance of this theme in her autobiography: "The real purpose of the story was to reach Dr. S. Weir Mitchell and convince him of the error of his ways. Many years later, I met someone who said he had told them that he had changed his treatment of nervous prostration since reading 'The Yellow Wallpaper.' If that is a fact, I have not lived in vain.”
Expert Q&A
In "The Yellow Wallpaper," what does the creeping figure in the wallpaper represent?
The creeping figure in the wallpaper represents the narrator's deteriorating mind and her feelings of being trapped and imprisoned by her family and circumstances. Initially, she does not see a woman in the wallpaper, but as she spends more time isolated in the room, the figure evolves into a woman behind bars, symbolizing her own mental and physical captivity.
How does the diction in "The Yellow Wallpaper" relate to the theme of forced confinement leading to insanity?
The diction in "The Yellow Wallpaper" underscores the theme of forced confinement leading to insanity through repeated imagery and language. The narrator describes her isolated surroundings, including barred windows and a bolted bed, symbolizing her physical and mental imprisonment. Her husband's dismissive language, calling her "little girl," further confines her mentally. The wallpaper's pattern, resembling bars and trapping a "creeping woman," emphasizes her growing madness, culminating in her complete breakdown.
What does the quote "John is a physician... perhaps that is one reason I do not get well faster" from "The Yellow Wallpaper" mean?
The quote highlights the oppressive dynamic in "The Yellow Wallpaper," where the narrator's husband, John, a physician, controls her life under the guise of medical care. His dismissal of her mental illness as mere hysteria and insistence on a "rest cure" worsen her condition. This reflects the broader theme of patriarchal dominance and the detrimental effects of male authority on women's autonomy and mental health, making the story a critical piece of feminist literature.
Has Jane prevailed at the end of the story when she says "I've got out at last," or has she not, considering her declined mental state?
In "The Yellow Wallpaper," which is more harmful to the narrator: psychological or societal demons?
How does the "temporary nervous depression—a slight hysterical tendency" relate to the setting in "The Yellow Wallpaper"?
The "temporary nervous depression" reflects the setting's impact on the narrator's mental state in "The Yellow Wallpaper." Her prescribed confinement in a decaying country house symbolizes her deteriorating condition. The room's barred windows and clamped bed represent her mental imprisonment, exacerbated by misguided medical advice. The yellow wallpaper becomes her obsession, symbolizing her struggle against mental and societal constraints, mirroring her need for stimulation and freedom from oppressive environments.
Mental Illness and Treatment in "The Yellow Wallpaper"
Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper" explores mental illness through the protagonist's descent into madness, exacerbated by the "rest cure" treatment prescribed by her physician husband. This treatment, reflecting 19th-century views on female hysteria, isolates her and forbids intellectual activity, worsening her postpartum depression. The narrator's fixation on the wallpaper symbolizes her entrapment and lack of agency, ultimately leading to her psychosis. The story critiques the medical and societal mistreatment of women's mental health, highlighting the need for patient involvement in treatment.
Characterization of Mental Decline in "The Yellow Wallpaper"
In "The Yellow Wallpaper," Charlotte Perkins Gilman uses syntax and diction to illustrate the narrator's mental decline. Initially, the narrator's complex sentences and sophisticated vocabulary reflect her intelligence and control. However, as her isolation and obsession with the wallpaper grow, her language becomes fragmented, reflecting her deteriorating sanity. The setting—a secluded house with a confining nursery—exacerbates her condition, symbolizing imprisonment. The narrator's fixation on the wallpaper culminates in her identifying with a woman trapped within it, embodying her descent into madness. Her mental breakdown is further depicted through her erratic behavior and hallucinations.
Factors leading to the protagonist's mental breakdown in "The Yellow Wallpaper"
The protagonist's mental breakdown in "The Yellow Wallpaper" is caused by the enforced "rest cure" prescribed by her husband, John, which includes isolation and prohibition of intellectual activities. This treatment leads to her sensory deprivation, frustration, and eventual hallucinations. Her lack of autonomy and being treated like a child exacerbate her condition, culminating in her obsession with the wallpaper as a symbol of her entrapment.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.