Student Question
Did Mexico accept the Zimmerman Telegram? Why or why not?
Quick answer:
Mexico did not accept the Zimmerman Telegram, largely because accepting it would mean declaring war on the United States, straining diplomatic relations with countries like Argentina, Brazil, and Chile. Additionally, Mexico lacked the resources to reclaim the American Southwest, as Germany's offer was insufficient and logistical challenges, such as British control of sea routes, prevented weapon delivery. Also, a significant English-speaking population in the region posed control challenges for Mexico.
The Zimmerman telegram was a note sent from Germany to Mexico, offering money and weapons to help Mexico gain back control of the American Southwest. Mexico declined the Zimmerman telegram, for a number of reasons. A major reason would be that if Mexico accepted this help, it would mean declaring war on the United States. Previously, Mexico had cooperated with Argentina, Brazil, and Chile to prevent the declaration of war on the United States. Mexico knew that accepting the Zimmerman telegram would cause poor relationships with countries they had just repaired their relationship with.
Mexico also chose not to accept the Zimmerman telegream because the resources the Germans offered would not be enough the regain control of the American Northwest. The United States was the only nearby country where arms were manufactured and Mexico would not be able to purchase arms from them. Germany could also not send weapons because the British were in control of the English seaways and would prevent the weapons from arriving in Mexico. Finally, there was now a sizeable English population living in the American Northwest, which the Mexicans would not be able to control.
To summarize, Mexico declined the Zimmerman telegram because they did not want to create strained relationships with other countries, they did not have access to enough weapons to defeat the Americans, and they would not be able to control the English population currently living in the area.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.