Critical Overview
Guy de Maupassant's novel A Woman’s Life is a masterful exploration of the trials and tribulations of women in the early 19th century. Maupassant, influenced by his mentor Gustave Flaubert, crafted a narrative that, while not matching the profound subtlety of Madame Bovary, remains an important literary work in its own right. This novel paints a stark, unsentimental portrait of a woman’s journey through life, weighed down by societal expectations and personal sorrows, yet ultimately finding resilience in her struggles.
Maupassant and His Literary Influences
Guy de Maupassant, a prominent French writer, published A Woman's Life in 1883, a few years after the passing of his influential mentor, Gustave Flaubert. Maupassant had long aspired to excel as a poet and playwright, yet he found his true calling in prose, particularly in short stories. Though often regarded as cynical and mechanical by Flaubert's standards, his stories gained popularity for their realism and keen character observation. This transition from poetry to prose is evident in A Woman’s Life, where he delves deep into the psychological landscape of his protagonist, Jeanne de Lamare.
Comparison with Contemporary Works
Maupassant’s debut novel has often been juxtaposed with Flaubert’s Madame Bovary and Arnold Bennett’s The Old Wives’ Tale. While A Woman’s Life lacks the rich characterization and stylistic elegance of Madame Bovary, and does not delve as deeply into social history as Bennett's work, it possesses a unique compactness and emotional honesty. Maupassant's portrayal of Jeanne offers an affectionate, albeit disturbing, exploration of the challenges faced by women entangled in the expectations of a patriarchal society. The novel draws inspiration from Maupassant's own life, particularly his relationship with his mother, and the setting mirrors his childhood home in Normandy.
The Lives of Disenchanted Women
While Jeanne de Lamare's narrative is at the heart of the book, her experiences parallel those of other women in her life, who also endure quiet despair and disillusionment. Her mother, the Baroness Adelaide, leads a sheltered life, turning a blind eye to her husband’s infidelity while seeking solace in her own clandestine revenge. Jeanne’s foster sister, Rosalie, and Aunt Lison each represent different facets of feminine suffering and marginalization. Rosalie's seduction by her brother-in-law underscores the vulnerability and powerlessness women often face. Aunt Lison’s outcry at never having received affection highlights the quiet agony of unrequited desire and social neglect. These narratives collectively reflect the broader experience of women in Maupassant’s time, where genuine affection is overshadowed by social constraints and inequities.
Retrospective on a Bygone Era
The novel begins in the spring of 1819 and spans over three decades, offering a retrospective lens on a society seemingly tranquil but fraught with underlying hypocrisy. Maupassant contrasts the perceived stability of Jeanne’s era with the turbulent times of the Third Republic. The societal calm is portrayed as illusory, upheld by outdated traditions and superficial morality. Jeanne's interactions with figures like the Abbé Picot and his successor, Abbé Tolbiac, reveal a community tethered to rigid conventions and moral pretenses, limiting her ability to forge a new path in life.
Jeanne’s Resilience and Stoicism
Despite numerous setbacks, Jeanne’s story is ultimately one of resilience. She confronts a series of personal betrayals and disappointments, from her husband’s neglect and infidelities to her son’s waywardness, with a quietly enduring strength. Throughout these challenges, she maintains her dignity and courage, embodying a stoic acceptance of life’s unpredictability. Her decision to care for her granddaughter at the novel’s close symbolizes her unwavering commitment to life’s continuation, even if it means revisiting past mistakes. Maupassant's stoic philosophy finds voice in Rosalie’s closing reflection, "You see, life is never as good or as bad as one thinks," encapsulating the novel's central theme of enduring life's ebb and flow with grace.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.