A Woman on a Roof

by Doris Lessing

Start Free Trial

Gender Roles and Objectification

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"A Woman on a Roof" exposes the objectification of women through the interactions between the male workers and the woman sunbathing on the rooftop. The men's behavior exemplifies the rigid gender roles of the 1960s, where women were often viewed as objects of male desire rather than individuals of agency.

Throughout the story, women's physical attributes are the sole focus. Readers learn about her scarlet and white clothing and exposed skin but not her name or other details. This objectification sets the tone for the men's interactions with her. They whistle, yell, and make assumptions about her life based solely on her choice to sunbathe. Her indifference to their attention only fuels their frustration and emphasizes their sense of entitlement to her attention.

Stanley, in particular, embodies this aggressive objectification. His anger and rude comments stem from his inability to control the situation. The woman's autonomy, her right to sunbathe unbothered, disrupts the societal power dynamic he expects. He sees her not as a person but as a possession he cannot claim.

Tom, on the other hand, presents a different facet of objectification. He builds elaborate fantasies about the woman. He projects his desires for intimacy and connection onto her. While seemingly less aggressive than Stanley, he, too, fails to see her as a real person.

"A Woman on a Roof" reminds its audience that objectification can take many forms and can dehumanize both the objectified and the objectifier. By dissecting these male characters' behavior, Lessing forces readers to question societal expectations for both men and women.

Social Class and Disparity

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

This story exposes the stark contrast between the working class, represented by the three workmen, and the woman sunbathing on the rooftop. This social disparity partly fuels the men's frustration and resentment toward her, impacting their behavior and desires.

The heatwave acts as a microcosm of their unequal lives. Trapped on the scorching roof, sweating and exhausted from their manual labor, the men are acutely aware of the physical discomfort of their working-class existence. In contrast, the woman embodies leisure and freedom. Her ability to sunbathe during the day suggests she has no demanding job, highlighting a sense of privilege.

This disparity becomes a source of resentment, particularly for Stanley. He constantly complains about the heat. This contrasts with the woman's seemingly effortless enjoyment. His anger and aggression could be interpreted as a way of lashing out at the social hierarchy that keeps him in a lower position. He feels a sense of powerlessness and entitlement towards the woman, believing she should somehow cater to his discomfort.

Tom's fantasies about the woman also stem from this social divide. He imagines her luxurious apartment and a life of ease, far removed from his own reality. These fantasies function as a form of escapism. They offer him a temporary escape from the limitations of his social class. However, his romanticized view of the woman also reveals a misunderstanding of her life and experiences.

The story does not explore the woman's background, leaving her motivations and social status ambiguous. This allows the reader to focus on how the men perceive her based solely on their limited perspective. Her silence throughout the story can be seen as a way of resisting their attempts to define her based on their class assumptions.

The Power of Silence

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"A Woman on a Roof" utilizes the woman's silence as a powerful tool to challenge the narrative and expose the dynamics at play. While the men dominate the story verbally, her refusal to engage speaks volumes. This silence highlights both the unprovoked nature of the men's comments and catcalling and the communication limitations, ultimately leaving the...

(This entire section contains 264 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

reader with a sense of ambiguity.

The woman's silence is a form of resistance. The men objectify her, focusing solely on her physical attributes and making assumptions about her life. She reclaims some control over the situation by refusing to respond to their whistles, catcalls, and intrusive questions. Her silence denies them the validation they seek and prevents them from defining her on their terms.

Secondly, the silence exposes the limitations of communication.
The story is told entirely from the men's perspective, leaving the woman's thoughts and desires a mystery. Their attempts to connect are based on projections and assumptions. Their words fail to bridge the social and emotional divide between them. The woman's silence becomes a stark reminder that communication can sometimes be ineffective, especially when fueled by objectification and social biases.

Finally, the woman's silence adds a layer of mystery to the story. Readers never truly understand her motivations or reaction to the men's advances. Did she find their behavior amusing? Did it make her feel unsafe? Was she simply enjoying the sun and did not want to be bothered? This uncertainty prompts the reader to question the men's assumptions and consider the woman's perspective beyond the limitations of the narrative they have projected on her.

Previous

Summary

Next

Analysis

Loading...