Themes: Romance and Disaster
In being heralded as the “laureate of the Jazz Age,” Fitzgerald struck in his very American writing a balance between romance and disaster, glitter and delusion. His characters include the petted and popular and rich, who both dream and live recklessly and who have as their biggest enemy time, the time that ages and changes. The aging process is signified by the word “winter” in the title, but “winter” also signifies a transition that is more tragic than physical deterioration; by the end of the story, Dexter’s emotions have become frozen. He has lost the ability to care or to feel. His “dream” of Judy had kept him energetic, passionate, and alive, and now the dream has been taken from him.
Expert Q&A
Why doesn't Dexter marry Judy Jones or Irene Sheerer in Winter Dreams?
Dexter doesn't marry Judy Jones or Irene Scheerer because he is infatuated with the ideal of love rather than genuinely understanding or loving either woman. He idolizes Judy, viewing her as an unattainable "glittering" object, and attempts to marry Irene as a safe, cultured choice. However, Judy's return prompts him to discard Irene, whom he never truly loves. Ultimately, Judy is uninterested in marriage, leaving Dexter alone and disillusioned with his "winter dreams."
In "Winter Dreams," what does Judy want and receive from Dexter?
Judy desires men who are wealthy, confident, and not emotionally dependent. She receives Dexter's infatuation and love but ultimately finds him lacking in the qualities she seeks. Dexter, despite his wealth and affection, cannot hold Judy's interest as she is drawn to a more elusive ideal. Ultimately, Judy marries someone who is not emotionally reliant on her, leading Dexter to realize that his feelings for her were based on illusions.
In Winter Dreams, what motivates Judy Jones to approach Dexter in her boat?
Judy Jones approaches Dexter in her boat primarily to gain his attention and adulation, driven by her need for validation through accumulating admirers. Her actions, such as asking Dexter to drive her motor-boat and sharing that a man is waiting for her, indicate her desire for excitement and self-validation. Despite her serial dating, Judy is never fully content, suggesting that male attention serves to boost her ego rather than fulfill her emotionally.
The impact of Judy Jones on Dexter's life and emotions in "Winter Dreams."
Judy Jones profoundly impacts Dexter's life and emotions in "Winter Dreams." Her beauty and charm captivate Dexter, driving his ambitions and shaping his desires. Despite her inconsistent affections, Dexter remains infatuated, experiencing both the heights of hope and the depths of despair. Ultimately, Judy symbolizes Dexter's unattainable dreams, leaving him disillusioned and emotionally scarred.
Dexter and Judy's motivations and philosophies on love in "Winter Dreams"
In "Winter Dreams," Dexter's motivation is driven by his idealistic aspirations and desire for a glamorous life, which he associates with Judy. Judy's philosophy on love is more pragmatic and self-centered; she seeks validation and excitement, often treating relationships as fleeting and superficial. Their differing views on love ultimately highlight the conflict between idealism and reality.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
