Winston Graham

Start Free Trial

Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Winston Graham’s most memorable suspense protagonists are women, particularly Marnie Elmer of Marnie, Deborah Dainton of The Walking Stick, and Norah Faulkner of Woman in the Mirror (1975), the plot of which recalls that of The Walking Stick and develops an even more highly concentrated mystery. However, two characters are notable exceptions to the generalization: Philip Turner of The Little Walls and David Abden of The Green Flash.

The Green Flash

In The Green Flash, David Abden is an amoral loner haunted by a terrible childhood tragedy. His father, an alcoholic who fancied motor racing, died of a fall when David was eleven years old. The boy was suspected of having pushed his father during a struggle, though his mother (in love with another man) most likely had done the deed and shifted the blame to her son. At the age of twenty-four, while working for a cosmetics firm, David is attracted to an older woman, a Russian émigré who hires him to help run her perfume business, though she knows of his prison record for robbery. He eventually becomes the key person in Mme Shona’s company and in her life; despite his continuing romantic involvement with her, however, he marries Erica, a wealthy fencer. Their marriage sours, however, and he kills her during a duel. In a kind of replay of his childhood crisis, David is absolved of responsibility for Erica’s death. The past intrudes on his present even more when he succeeds to a Scottish baronetcy as a result of a cousin’s death in a car crash and then falls in love with his cousin’s widow, Alison. Lacking family pride or interest in his heritage, he turns his back on the inheritance and on Alison, returning at the end to an aging and ailing Mme Shona. The mother he never really had, she is the sole stabilizing force in his life.

Among Graham’s previous thrillers, only Angell, Pearl, and Little God (1970) is longer than The Green Flash, but the earlier book is narrower in scope. The Green Flash covers many years and is a wide-ranging chronicle of an unpredictable life and a shady business world, in both of which David Abden seeks the best of everything. Its expansive plot introduces a wider range of characters and incidents than is the norm in earlier books, though the highly detailed portrait of the perfume-manufacturing industry is foreshadowed in Marnie, with its focus on a printing firm, and in The Walking Stick, with its art-auction milieu. Another distinguishing trait of The Green Flash is that though deaths and crimes occur early, the novel does not become a suspense novel until it is well under way. Further, despite the intrigues that are present throughout and the dangers that impulsive David constantly courts, The Green Flash lacks the tension that is central to so many of the earlier suspense novels. Graham may well have set out to depart from his familiar formula, not intending to produce merely another suspense story, but rather aiming to write a straight novel. Indeed, The Green Flash is as much a memorable psychological study of mature love as it is a crime novel.

The Little Walls

Though The Little Walls is one of Graham’s early thrillers, it is one of the best in the genre, mainly because of Philip Turner, the thirty-year-old narrator whose attempts to answer questions surrounding his elder brother’s apparent suicide lead him on an odyssey from England to the Netherlands and then to Italy. He is motivated by his love for the sibling he considered his...

(This entire section contains 1570 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

mentor and an unwillingness to believe that Grevil killed himself (as their father had done years earlier). A physicist turned archaeologist, Grevil had been en route to England from an expedition in Java when his body was found in an Amsterdam canal. Lacking evidence of foul play, the authorities assume suicide, particularly since a “Dear John” letter was in his jacket pocket. Philip’s only leads are the woman’s name on that note and the knowledge that Grevil arrived in the Netherlands with a man named Jack Buckingham, since vanished, whom he had befriended in Indonesia. The English police suggest to Philip that he seek the aid of a shady, erstwhile undercover agent whose international contacts could prove useful. In company with this man and alone, Philip confronts emotional and physical trials during his quest, which also becomes a journey of self-discovery. Eventually, he attains the answers he sought, the revelation coming in the course of a climactic confrontation with the elusive Buckingham, who admits that he abandoned Grevil to murderers. Philip’s odyssey ends with his respect for Grevil reinforced, and their father’s suicide is placed in the proper perspective: simply a long-ago tragedy with no bearing on the present.

Marnie

The protagonist-narrator of Marnie is a more typical Graham protagonist: a psychologically disturbed loner of ambivalent morality. Margaret “Marnie” Elmer is twenty-three years old and has lied and robbed for years. Every few months she sheds an identity with a hot bath and a stiff drink and then departs for a new city and a different life. Two stable elements in this fragmented existence of aliases are visits to her mother in Torquay and to a horse in Cirencester, the only living things with whom she has formed lasting relationships. Marnie cannot fall in love, and sex repels her, but under duress she marries Mark Rutland, her employer. When Mark discovers that she has stolen the firm’s payroll and has fled, he replaces the money, locates her, and insists on marriage, vowing not to betray her. Inevitably, Marnie’s carefully obscured past returns to haunt her, and Mark increases the pressure on her to allow him to orchestrate a long-term resolution. A conflict in the family business complicates matters, however, and the novel concludes with a series of unexpected twists that place Marnie, once the quintessential loner, firmly under the control of others.

In a tale filled with irony, the most poignant example is that Marnie, who had devoted herself to hiding her personality and past from others, was doing precisely what her mother had done (without her daughter’s knowledge) for years. Whereas Marnie rejected sex, however, her mother invited it, and then, in desperation, murdered an illegitimate son. Marnie’s warped psyche, then, had been shaped by dimly recalled childhood experiences that she futilely attempted to change or expunge from memory. Thus she realizes that her mother (whom she had supported with her ill-gotten money) had been deceiving her for years and also had hidden the facts of her life. The ultimate irony, though, comes at the end of the novel, when the men whom she reluctantly had come to trust betray her.

Graham combines—more successfully than in any of his other suspense novels—a graphic psychological portrait with a compelling narrative in Marnie. In large measure, the tension of the unfolding plot is increased by the reader’s developing empathy with the narrator. Marnie’s consciousness is the distorted prism through which everything is revealed. She is a free spirit who nevertheless is trapped; a calculating victimizer who herself becomes a victim; and an attractive, personable, and intelligent woman who, sadly, is unable to enjoy continuity and security. At the conclusion, however, while being deceived into a confrontation that may be her undoing, Marnie achieves a catharsis of sorts. In one sense, she is defeated; in a more important sense, however, she succeeds in overcoming a major obstacle to leading a normal life.

The Walking Stick

The Walking Stick also has a pretty young woman as its protagonist-narrator, and she too is a loner, an introvert whose personality has been determined in great measure by her childhood bout with polio. A cane has become the emblem of Deborah Dainton’s physical impairment, distinguishing her from everyone else and making her as fragile as the antiques about which she is an expert (she works in the porcelain department of a fashionable London auction house). When she finally is won over by the approaches of Leigh Hartly, a struggling artist, Deborah finds herself drawn into a netherworld of deceit and crime. Having fallen in love despite the defenses she had constructed around herself, she agrees to participate in a daring robbery of the auction house, playing a central insider’s role at critical stages of the complex intrigue. Deluded by love, she permits herself to be used by a calculating rogue and those in whose debt he labors.

What Deborah learns after the Whittington robbery, however, is that she had been set up from the very start. The initial meeting with Leigh, the requests for dates, the developing romantic involvement—all had been part of the grand scheme for a million-dollar theft that could have succeeded only with her assistance.

The lameness that Deborah regards as distinguishing herself from others is for the most part overcome when she and Leigh are living together, for the psychological and emotional benefits of the relationship apparently improve her physical well-being. In the aftermath of the robbery and the subsequent revelation of Leigh’s deceit, however, Deborah again seeks the support of her walking stick. Having experienced another way of life, without her cane, Deborah apparently cannot return to the former one. The work concludes with her plans for suicide and for betraying her accomplices to the police.

Loading...