Analysis
William Makepeace Thackeray stands as a monumental figure in the evolution of the novel, celebrated for his pioneering narrative techniques and insightful depictions of Victorian society. His work peels back layers of social pretense, exposing the intricate dance of personal relationships and moral ambiguities woven into the human experience. Thackeray's literary journey—from biting satire to nuanced character studies—challenges readers to confront the stark realities and hypocrisies of their own lives.
Early Works and Satirical Beginnings
The character of Yellowplush, introduced in Thackeray’s early writings, captivated Victorian audiences with his intriguing perspective and sharp satirical wit. Emerging in the late 1830s with tales like "Miss Shum’s Husband," Yellowplush—a footman with a penchant for gentlemanly tastes—delivered narratives that dissected the ironies and vanities of the society he served. His master, Frederic Altamont, is trapped in a web of societal deceit and secrets, a recurring theme in Thackeray’s work.
"Yellowplush Papers" progresses with "Dimond Cut Dimond," where Yellowplush finds himself in the service of Algernon Percy Deuceace, a gambling aristocrat. This story continues Thackeray's exploration of the upper class's moral ambiguities, as Deuceace's interactions reveal a world where social status often masks true character. The humor and criticism blend seamlessly in "Foring Parts," as Yellowplush accompanies Deuceace to France, observing the stark contrasts between English and French social customs.
Thackeray's Narrative Style and Themes
Thackeray’s experimentation with narrative style reaches new heights in "Confessions of Fitz-Boodle" and "Men’s Wives." These works mark a transition from earlier satires to intricate narratives exploring the social and psychological complexities of his characters. "Confessions of Fitz-Boodle" uses its titular character’s reflections on aristocracy and romantic failings as a vehicle for commentary on class and vanity.
"Men’s Wives," particularly the tale of "Mr. and Mrs. Frank Berry," delves into domestic life and the oppressive nature of societal expectations. Through Frank Berry, Thackeray examines the transformation from a brave schoolboy to a henpecked husband, critiquing the rigid confines of Victorian marriage. Thackeray’s works, particularly those from 1843 to 1848 such as "The Luck of Barry Lyndon" and "The Book of Snobs," highlight his critique of social pretension and snobbery, urging readers to question the values underpinning their lives.
Vanity Fair: A Novel Without a Hero
"Vanity Fair" remains Thackeray’s most renowned work, celebrated for its sharp satire and complex narrative. The novel follows Becky Sharp, an ambitious and morally ambiguous woman, as she navigates themes of social mobility, hypocrisy, and the relentless pursuit of wealth and status. Her interactions with characters like the naive Amelia Sedley and self-centered George Osborne underscore Thackeray’s critique of societal moral failings.
Drawing from John Bunyan’s "The Pilgrim’s Progress," "Vanity Fair" signals Thackeray’s intent to craft a moralistic tale that transcends simple storytelling. The intrusive narrator distances readers from the characters, prompting them to examine their biases and assumptions. By intertwining personal and societal elements, Thackeray presents a world where social ascension often undermines personal integrity, leaving readers questioning the nature of ambition and the possibility of virtue.
The History of Henry Esmond, Esquire
Thackeray’s "The History of Henry Esmond, Esquire" stands as a significant contribution, blending historical fiction with a deeply personal narrative. Set against the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, the novel explores themes of love, identity, and familial duty. Henry Esmond’s complex relationships offer a nuanced exploration of love and duty, mirroring Thackeray’s unrequited affections for Jane Brookfield.
Thackeray’s personal experiences imbue "Henry Esmond" with emotional depth, crafting a tale that challenges conventional notions of romance and heroism. The narrative unravels themes of legitimacy and social status through Henry’s discovery of his true lineage and his consequent moral dilemmas, offering...
(This entire section contains 992 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
a meditation on identity and personal honor.
The Newcomes and The Virginians
"The Newcomes" and "The Virginians" expand Thackeray’s examination of social and familial dynamics. "The Newcomes" explores the world of the nouveau riche, weaving themes of wealth, respectability, and personal fulfillment. Through Colonel Thomas Newcome, Thackeray presents an embodiment of integrity and humility, contrasting with the ambition around him.
Ethel Newcome’s journey from coquetry to self-awareness reflects Thackeray’s nuanced understanding of human nature, highlighting the tension between personal desire and social obligation. "The Virginians," despite critiques of formlessness, offers a rich tapestry of characters and themes, continuing Thackeray’s exploration of family and identity against a historical backdrop.
Thackeray's Literary Significance
Thackeray’s significance lies in his contribution to the novel’s development, offering insights into Victorian England through the innovative use of intrusive narrators and psychological realism. His works mark a departure from conventional storytelling, paving the way for authors like Henry James and John Galsworthy. Thackeray’s narrative is characterized by a discursive style, blending humor and commentary to engage readers actively.
His writing, divided into distinct periods, reflects his evolving approach to social critique. From early satirical works to later narratives exploring social and psychological underpinnings, Thackeray consistently examined societal injustice and pretension. His personal involvement in his works, particularly evident in pieces like "Men’s Wives," illustrates his engagement with themes of marriage and fidelity, often reflecting his experiences and emotions.
Conclusion of "Vanity Fair" and "Henry Esmond"
In "Vanity Fair," Thackeray’s narrative complexity reaches its zenith, with Becky Sharp’s journey encapsulating a critique of society’s moral failings. The novel’s conclusion, with characters retreating to their "boxes" like puppets, leaves readers with a lingering question about ambition and virtue. "Henry Esmond," considered by Thackeray as his best work, integrates historical events with personal narratives, showcasing his mastery of blending fiction with historical context.
Thackeray’s works, from "Yellowplush Papers" to "The Virginians," offer a panoramic view of English society, capturing the intricacies of human behavior through humor and insight. His novels stand as a testament to his literary genius, inviting readers to reflect on their values and assumptions, offering a mirror to the complexities and contradictions of the human condition.
Discussion Topics
William Makepeace Thackeray, a prominent figure in 19th-century literature, often explored themes of snobbery in his works. This raises the question of whether he himself embodied the very traits he critiqued, particularly evident in his early fiction. His sharp satirical eye casts a critical light on the social hierarchies of his time.
The comparison between Thackeray’s The History of Pendennis and Charles Dickens’s David Copperfield is inevitable, as both novels were serialized concurrently. While Dickens's work is celebrated for its vivid characterizations and emotional depth, some argue that Thackeray's narrative lacks the same level of engagement and empathy, potentially falling short in capturing the intimate struggles of its characters.
Thackeray’s fascination with the past, particularly the eighteenth century, often overshadowed his views on his contemporary world. His reflective style and historic settings suggest a deep-seated nostalgia or perhaps a critical vantage point from which he viewed his own century’s flaws.
In describing Vanity Fair as “a novel without a hero,” Thackeray intentionally deviates from traditional heroic narratives, instead focusing on the flawed, often morally ambiguous nature of his characters. This complexity invites readers to question the very nature of heroism and morality in society.
The dual focus on Amelia Sedley and Becky Sharp in Vanity Fair invites debate on whether the novel features two heroines. Amelia's innocence contrasts sharply with Becky's cunning ambition, offering two distinct female perspectives and challenging conventional notions of heroism.
Finally, Thackeray’s character Henry Esmond is often cited as his portrayal of the ideal gentleman. Through Esmond's chivalrous demeanor and moral compass, Thackeray might have been attempting to convey his vision of integrity and honor, contrasting the prevailing social pretensions of his time.
