William Hoffman Criticism
William Hoffman, an American novelist and short story writer born in 1925, is renowned for his gritty realism and exploration of transcendent values, self-discovery, and personal sacrifice leading to spiritual redemption in a tumultuous world. Although often considered a regional writer anchored in the American South, Hoffman's work transcends local concerns, capturing universal themes through the lives of characters that reflect the social and moral upheavals of the 20th century. His novels, such as The Trumpet Unblown, The Dark Mountains, and Tidewater Blood, showcase his narrative strengths and philosophical depth, delving into the impacts of war, economic conditions, and moral decay.
Biographically, Hoffman was deeply influenced by his West Virginian upbringing and Presbyterian roots. His military service during World War II informed several of his novels, while his subsequent academic pursuits nurtured his writing career. Hoffman's disciplined writing routine and preference for agrarian life in Virginia are reflected in his stories' settings and themes. His literary journey includes accolades such as the John Dos Passos Prize for Literature and the O. Henry Prize, highlighting his prowess as a storyteller.
Hoffman's major works are often categorized into themes of war, Virginia/West Virginia culture, and spirituality. His characters frequently grapple with identity, familial relationships, violence, and materialism. Works like The Land That Drank the Rain and Furors Die further emphasize themes of spiritual and moral redemption. His short story collections, including By Land, By Sea and Follow Me Home, showcase his meticulous attention to Southern life and the human condition.
Despite critical acclaim, particularly from publications like the Sewanee Review, Hoffman's readership has historically remained limited. Critics have praised his ability to convey profound themes in a concise narrative style, drawing comparisons to Hemingway and Crane. While some find his diction overly simplistic, his recent ventures into mystery novels with Tidewater Blood and Blood and Guile have broadened his audience. Hoffman's thematic depth and stylistic contributions place him within the esteemed tradition of Southern literature alongside figures like Robert Penn Warren and Flannery O'Connor, as noted by critics such as William Frank and Gordon Van Ness.
Contents
- Principal Works
-
Essays
-
Author First Wrote Love Letters for a Fee
(summary)
In the following essay, Galloway traces Hoffman's early experiences as a writer, his relationship with his wife, and discusses with the author aspects of Hoffman's house in the town of Charlotte Court House, Virginia.
-
The Intolerable Wrestle
(summary)
In the following review of A Walk to the River, Buffington discusses Hoffman's Southern concerns and prose style, finding shortcomings in the novel's dramatization.
-
The Fugitive Hero in New Southern Fiction
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Davenport offers a positive assessment of The Land That Drank the Rain.
-
About Any Kind of Meanness You Can Name
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Sullivan commends Hoffman's prose style but finds Godfires to be a reprise of well-worn views and attitudes about the contemporary American South.
-
Spirit Prevails in Well-Crafted Tales
(summary)
In the following review of By Land, By Sea, Merritt praises Hoffman's abilities as a literary craftsman and poignant storyteller.
-
Southside Life Inspires Author
(summary)
In the following review, Neuberger relates how Hoffman enjoys living in a small, agrarian community in Virginia, and discusses the inspiration Hoffman draws from the landscape and the people around him.
-
Wonderful Geographies
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Johnson offers a favorable evaluation of By Land, By Sea, though arguing that some of the stories “lapse into melodrama.”
-
Hoffman Doesn't Dodge Life
(summary)
The following review of Furors Die provides a plot summary of the novel and lauds Hoffman's abilities as a skilled writer, praising his proficiency with symbolism, language, satire, and setting.
-
Old-Fashioned Values
(summary)
In the following brief review of Furors Die, Merritt praises Hoffman's talent for describing character and place, but denounces the novel for its old-fashioned attitudes, particularly in regard to its portrayal of sexual relations.
-
The Fiction of William Hoffman: An Introduction
(summary)
In the following essay, Frank provides an overview of the central themes, regional settings and motifs, prose style, and narrative presentation in Hoffman's fiction. Frank's analysis, which aims to enlarge Hoffman's readership, focuses on several representative works—the novels The Trumpet Unblown, The Land That Drank the Rain, and Godfires, and the short story collection By Land, By Sea.
-
Fiction and the Furniture of Consciousness
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Davenport praises Hoffman's skill as a novelist and offers a positive assessment of Furors Die.
-
Hoffman Energizes His Tales
(summary)
In the following brief review of the short stories in Follow Me Home, Carter deems the tales to be carefully constructed, humorous, and compelling, but denounces Hoffman for the fact that some of the stories and dialogue seem contrived.
-
Taking Measure: Violent Intruders in William Hoffman's Short Fiction
(summary)
In the following essay, Chappell draws attention to the recurring motif of an outsider entering into an insular community, or “pocket society,” in Hoffman's short fiction. As Chappell notes, this theme in Hoffman's stories is often dramatized by episodes of violence and menacing reversals that give depth, suspense, and resolution to his narratives.
-
Hoffman's Novel ‘Tight, Taut, Compelling …’
(summary)
In the following review, Frank enthusiastically praises the literary merits and compelling, thrilling story in Tidewater Blood.
-
Hoffman Turns to Suspense
(summary)
In the following review, Carter lauds Hoffman's characterization and sense of place in Tidewater Blood, but denounces the author for couching the deeper story about the conflict between Virginians and West Virginians within the trappings of a murder mystery.
-
Surprise Ending
(summary)
In the following review, McKelway extols the virtues of Tidewater Blood, noting that the book marks a departure for Hoffman due to its suspense thriller characteristics, whereas his other works typically feature philosophical examinations and deeper symbolic levels at their core.
-
His Novel's Success is ‘Thrilling’ News
(summary)
In the following review, Clark discusses the release of Tidewater Blood, noting Hoffman's easy-going affability and the author's venture into the suspense thriller market with the novel.
-
Hoffman Opens His Door: Author Discusses Writing, New Short Story Collection
(summary)
In the following interview, William L. Frank and William Hoffman discuss Hoffman's writing process, the thematic concerns of his fiction, particularly in his short story collection "Doors," including his reflections on tragedy, morality, and personal experiences influencing his work.
-
Hoffman's Doors Offers Look at Human Nature
(summary)
In the following review, Van Ness offers a positive assessment of Doors, highlighting the intense individualism of the characters who reject traditional social values and act on their personal beliefs.
-
Hoffman Evokes Sense of Place
(summary)
In the following brief review, Carter offers a positive evaluation of the stories in Doors. Few writers have an ear so finely attuned to the pulsebeat of a place as William Hoffman. In the 10 stories collected here, all of which appeared previously in prestigious literary quarterlies, Hoffman creates a rich and lovingly detailed tapestry that encapsulates the life of Southside Virginia from its fox-hunting elite to its harried tobacco farmers, confident “come-heres,” and watermen (or, in this case, waterwomen). In the spare, precise prose that is his hallmark, Hoffman accomplishes feats of storytelling legerdemain that might well serve as a textbook for aspiring writers.
-
The Novels of William Hoffman: One Writer's Spiritual Odyssey from World War II to the Twenty-First Century
(summary)
In the following essay, Frank provides an overview of Hoffman's novels, which he divides into “war novels,” “Virginia/West Virginia novels,” and “philosophical/spiritual novels,” and examines the recurring motif of spiritual longing, disillusionment, and redemption in these works. According to Frank, “Hoffman's real subject is not initiation, but his own spiritual odyssey.” A portion of this essay originally appeared as a review of Furors Die, in the Farmville Herald on March 21, 1990.
-
The American Adam in the Southern Wasteland: William Hoffman's Follow Me Home and the Ethics of Redemption
(summary)
In the following essay, Van Ness examines the theme of spiritual redemption in the short stories of Follow Me Home. Van Ness identifies Hoffman's protagonists as American incarnations of the biblical Adam, situated in a fallen “southern wasteland.” As such, Hoffman's protagonists are viewed as independent, self-reliant individuals whose rediscovery of old-fashioned morality and the virtues of the heart lead to renewal and “a spiritual wholeness.”
-
Bestseller Dreams
(summary)
In the following essay, Span surveys Hoffman's career as a writer who has been critically acclaimed but has yet to achieve the status of bestselling author, focusing upon the promotion of his novel Blood and Guile.
-
Author First Wrote Love Letters for a Fee
(summary)
- Further Reading