As we are limited in space, below are a few ideas to help get you
started.
The symbolism of the fisherman referred to in William
Butler Yeats's poem "The Fisherman" becomes evident in the
first stanza. In the first stanza, Yeats describes the fisherman as
"This wise and simple man," showing us that he is using the fisherman to
represent an ideal man or human being. It especially becomes
evident the fisherman symbolizes the ideal man/human being when Yeats starts
referring to "living men" he hates and the one and only "dead man" he loves.
Since Yeats hates many men and only loved one, these two lines are evidence
that he also sees men as flawed, except for the fisherman. We
see further evidence Yeats is using the fisherman to symbolize an ideal man
when he says of the fisherman in the second stanza, "A man who does not exist,
/ A man who is but a dream." In other words, if the "wise and simple" fisherman
doesn't truly exist, then he is clearly an idealized
state because the ideal doesn't truly exist. If we
can see that the fisherman symbolizes ideal humanity, then we can also
see how Yeats's other poems also reflect on ideal humanity,
even if the poems cover completely different subject matters.
More specifically, the poem "An Irish Airman foresees his Death" speaks of
military upheaval in Ireland, but it is difficult to speak of
upheaval without also comparing it to the ideal situation. So
even in that poem do we see references to ideal
humanity.
There is a great deal of evidence that the poem "An Irish Airman foresees his
Death" concerns military conflict or action in Ireland,
especially in the title, since the word airman is another name for a
pilot in the air force. Other than the title, we see further evidence of
military conflict being a theme when the speaker says in the opening two lines
that he knows he will "meet [his] fate / Somewhere among the clouds above,"
which is another way of saying he will die somewhere in the
clouds. If he predicts he will die in the clouds, then he is also
predicting he will die while in action. In addition, the words
"fight" and "guard" refer to the military actions of fighting
rebels and guarding citizens. It should also be noted that the poem is
very pessimistic with respect to speaking of military action,
because the speaker says that military action cannot do
anything to bring his countrymen more loss than they already have and
that military action cannot do anything to make his countrymen any
happier, as we see in the two lines, "No likely end could bring them loss
/ Or leave them happier than before." In other words, all action is
futile. However, behind the concept of a futile
situation will also lie its exact antithesis--the
ideal, positive situation, or idealism. Hence, even in this
poem, we see him reflecting on what his ideal situation would be
like, which also has to do with what his ideal countrymen
would be like. His ideal countrymen would be able to be rescued from
their situation and rendered happy. A reflection of his ideal
countrymen also serves as an example of a
reflection of an ideal man, for his countrymen must
both be "wise and simple" to achieve this ideal, peaceful, happy
political reality, just like the fisherman. While Yeats
does not use literal words to describe this ideal
state or his ideal countrymen, we see the
reflection conceptually hidden beneath the surface of the poem--we see
it between the lines.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References