Wide Sargasso Sea

by Jean Rhys

Start Free Trial

Historical Context

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Wide Sargasso Sea, penned by Jean Rhys between 1945 and 1966, serves as an eloquent response to the fluctuating dynamics of the West Indies during the mid-20th century. The era was marked by a wave of nationalism and significant sociopolitical shifts, including Jamaica's independence from Britain in 1962 and a growing influx of West Indian immigrants to England. Against the backdrop of these changes, Rhys weaves a narrative set between 1839 and 1845, placing her characters in a period of immense transformation following the abolition of slavery in the British colonies.

Historical Context and Abolition

The abolition of slavery in 1833 stirred considerable unrest in the British West Indies, as former slave laborers were freed, leaving plantation owners struggling with plummeting property values and labor shortages. The landscape was tumultuous; white West Indian planters, who had once thrived on the sugar economy, faced financial ruin. They challenged British sovereignty, feeling betrayed by the abolition that threatened their way of life. Eric Williams, in his historical work Capitalism and Slavery, captures a planter's resentment: "We owe no more allegiance to the inhabitants of Great Britain than we owe our brother colonists in Canada." This sentiment reflects the planters’ resistance to British intervention and their desire for autonomy.

Shifting Social Dynamics

In her reinterpretation of Bertha Mason's story from Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre, Rhys addresses English stereotypes of the Caribbean and the complex relations between whites and blacks in the region. By setting her narrative in a volatile post-emancipation period, Rhys highlights the tensions and social upheavals between the entrenched colonial structures and the emergent new order. As the novel unfolds, we witness the intersection of English newcomers, impoverished white West Indians, and the newly freed black population, each group grappling with their place in the evolving society. The arrival of these new English colonists, who often viewed themselves as morally superior, added another layer of complexity, as they acquired devalued estates and sought to assert their dominance.

The New Colonial Order

Despite the abolition of slavery, true freedom eluded many black West Indians. Rhys illustrates this through the character of Christophine, who cynically remarks on the "Letter of the Law" replacing the old system of bondage with new forms of oppression, such as the apprenticeship system. Under this scheme, former slaves were coerced to remain with their previous masters at paltry wages, facing fines and imprisonment if they sought independence. This era also saw attempts by the new white colonists to deepen racial divisions, as evidenced in the novel when Mr. Mason tries to separate Antoinette and her part-black half-siblings, children of her father’s relationships with black women. Such interactions highlight the entrenched racial prejudices that persisted even after legal emancipation.

Rebellion and Controversy

Post-emancipation, the Caribbean islands simmered with unrest, as evidenced by frequent black rebellions and the notorious Governor Eyre controversy of 1865, where excessive force was used to suppress a Jamaican uprising. This event sparked fierce debates among prominent English figures regarding appropriate colonial governance and the treatment of black populations. While novelist Charles Dickens supported Eyre's brutal measures as necessary, scientist Charles Darwin condemned them. The controversy underscores the broader imperial discourse on race and power, framing how English society perceived its colonies.

Rhys's Narrative as Counter-Discourse

In rewriting Bertha Mason's story, Rhys engages with these historical debates, challenging the dominant narratives imposed by British colonial discourse. Her novel allows the colonized voices to "talk back," offering a more nuanced perspective of Creole identity and the complexities of colonial power dynamics. By bringing to light the multifaceted experiences of the Caribbean through the lens...

(This entire section contains 638 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

of a Creole subject, Rhys critiques the simplistic and often prejudicial views propagated by English literature and society. Her work not only reclaims a voice for the marginalized but also invites readers to reconsider preconceived notions of race, belonging, and history in the colonial Caribbean.

Style and Technique

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"Wide Sargasso Sea" by Jean Rhys is a novel rich in complexity and narrative technique, offering a profound exploration of identity, oppression, and cultural intersection. By employing varied perspectives, Rhys invites readers into the deeply subjective experiences of her characters, creating an intricate tapestry of emotion and perception. Through its evocative setting, symbolic elements, and diverse literary heritage, the novel intricately weaves together themes of colonialism, race, and gender.

Point of View

The narrative structure of "Wide Sargasso Sea" is multifaceted, with the novel unfolding in three distinct parts, each having its own narrative perspective. Initially, Antoinette is the sole narrator, allowing readers direct access to her inner world, characterized by her naivety and confusion. Her understanding of her surroundings is limited and subjective, revealing her ignorance of the societal forces that shape her life. For instance, she does not comprehend her mother's rejection, Tia's hostility, or Rochester's inability to accept her love. This limited perspective invites sympathy from the reader, as they witness Antoinette's struggles for acceptance and belonging.

In the second part, Rochester assumes the narrative role, exposing his own prejudices and internal conflicts. His account, though intended to justify his actions, inadvertently portrays his racism, greed, and lack of respect for Antoinette's culture. Sanford Sternlicht notes that Rochester's narrative serves as a self-incrimination, as he unwittingly reveals the complexities of his character and his role as the novel's "villain." Despite his faults, Rochester's narrative also unveils his deep-seated passions and the unhappiness that stems from his own prejudices.

The third part introduces Grace Poole as the narrator before Antoinette reclaims her voice. Grace's perspective is clouded by her own desires and inability to grasp the full tragedy of Antoinette's situation. When Antoinette resumes narration, Rhys presents a world seen through the eyes of madness, further complicating the narrative with a fragmented and surreal quality. Rhys’s choice to split the narrative illustrates the limitations inherent in all perspectives, whether marred by madness, prejudice, or self-interest.

Setting

The setting in "Wide Sargasso Sea" is pivotal, as it underscores the novel's themes and enriches the characters' experiences. The Sargasso Sea, from which the novel draws its name, embodies both beauty and danger, encapsulating the dual nature of the Caribbean itself. As Rachel Carson describes, the sea is both a place of "legendary terrors" and serene beauty, mirroring the paradise and peril of Antoinette's world. The Caribbean setting is lush and vibrant, akin to the Garden of Eden, yet wild and threatening, illustrating the encroaching chaos on the veneer of civilization.

Rochester perceives his environment as invasive, with the lush growth threatening to overtake the "honeymoon-house," symbolizing the tension between nature and the colonial order. This stark contrast is further highlighted by the juxtaposition of the warm, colorful Caribbean and the cold, gray England, emphasizing the cultural and environmental divide. The novel's temporal setting also plays a critical role, as Rhys situates the story in the volatile period of the 1840s, following the abolition of slavery in the Caribbean. This historical context reflects the societal upheaval and economic changes that impact the characters' lives, evident in the decay of Coulibri and the unrest among the black laborers.

Symbolism

Symbolism permeates "Wide Sargasso Sea," adding layers of meaning and depth to the narrative. The burning of Coulibri, Antoinette's childhood home, symbolizes the collapse of the oppressive systems of slavery and colonial rule. Thornfield Hall, Rochester's estate, represents another form of oppression, where Antoinette is confined and isolated, mirroring her loss of agency and identity. By burning Thornfield Hall, Antoinette not only acts in defiance of her captivity but also connects with the rebels who destroyed her past home.

Clothing serves as a potent symbol throughout the novel. When Antoinette dons Tia's dress, she momentarily experiences life from another perspective, highlighting themes of racial and cultural identity. Her white dress, chosen to please Rochester, underscores her futile attempts to conform to his expectations, while the ill-fitting garment signifies her inability to fully assimilate into his world. In her madness, Antoinette fixates on a red dress, a symbol of her passion and ties to the Caribbean. The dress evokes memories of her lover and the fiery spirit of her homeland, ultimately inspiring her to destroy Thornfield Hall and reclaim a semblance of freedom.

Literary Heritage

"Wide Sargasso Sea" draws from a rich literary heritage, merging Afro-Caribbean and European traditions in a unique blend. Scholars like Sandra Drake argue that Rhys infuses the novel with Afro-Caribbean elements, such as the presence of the zombi figure and African-derived beliefs, challenging Western conceptions of these traditions as "foolish." This Afro-Caribbean influence asserts a worldview that contrasts with and critiques European dominance.

Conversely, Rhys’s European Modernist connections are evident, given her engagement with "Jane Eyre," from which she derives her protagonist, Bertha Mason. Critics like Mary Lou Emery suggest that the interplay between Modernist, West Indian, and feminist perspectives enriches the novel's thematic complexity. Rhys, having been shaped by both European and Caribbean cultures, crafts a narrative that reflects the synthesis of these diverse influences, capturing the essence of the West Indies as a melting pot of cultural interactions.

In "Wide Sargasso Sea," Jean Rhys masterfully combines narrative technique, evocative settings, rich symbolism, and a diverse literary heritage to craft a poignant exploration of identity and belonging. Her work challenges readers to engage with the complexities of cultural intersections and the subjective nature of truth, leaving an indelible mark on modern literature.

Setting

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The novel "Wide Sargasso Sea" is steeped in the contrasting worlds of England and the Caribbean, where the vibrant and tumultuous landscapes serve as both backdrop and protagonist. The power dynamics and cultural intersections in these settings reveal the complexities of identity and belonging for the characters. Through these diverse locales, Jean Rhys explores themes of colonialism, alienation, and the search for personal freedom amidst societal constraints.

England: A Cold, Distant Reality

Though England physically appears only in the brief third section of "Wide Sargasso Sea," its influence is omnipresent. To Antoinette, England is more a myth than reality, a place embodied by the English people in her life who wield power, such as her father, stepfamily, and husband. Her imagination of England is shaped by an idealized painting, "The Miller’s Daughter," and the skepticism of Christophine, who labels it a "cold thief place." When Antoinette eventually visits England, its existence only becomes tangible during a glimpse of the countryside’s natural beauty, starkly contrasting her perception of a "cardboard" existence.

The West Indies: A Land of Enchantment and Doom

The West Indies serve as a counterpoint to England—warm, seductive, yet equally treacherous. Antoinette blames her fragmented identity on her upbringing in these islands, where her husband perceives her as foreign and untrustworthy. The islands’ allure and the irrationality they inspire become a catalyst for Antoinette’s tragic narrative, driving her in a desperate attempt to reclaim her home.

Jamaica: A Legacy of Tension and Resentment

Jamaica, with its colonial history, embodies a legacy of tension between former slaves and their erstwhile masters. Antoinette’s family history is scarred by this past, with her father’s English decadence and her mother’s Creole beauty drawing contempt from their community. Post-emancipation, the anger of the freed slaves manifests in acts of violence, turning their ire against Antoinette’s family, and leaving lasting impressions of bitterness and loss.

Colibri: The Lost Childhood Haven

Antoinette’s childhood at the Colibri estate is shadowed by isolation and emotional neglect. The estate, once proud like its royal palms, is a symbol of Antoinette’s own lost identity. Though she finds comfort in its familiar elements, her mother’s preoccupation with her brother leaves Antoinette feeling alienated, her sense of belonging as precarious as the estate's beauty, which ultimately succumbs to destruction.

Spanish Town: A Brief Refuge

Following the burning of Colibri, Antoinette finds temporary refuge in Spanish Town with Aunt Cora. The convent offers a semblance of safety amidst the gossip and societal disdain surrounding her family. Here, Antoinette's life is marked by a coerced marriage to an Englishman arranged by her stepfather, echoing her mother’s own troubled matrimonial fate.

Martinique: The Island of Contested Freedom

Martinique, with its air of mystery and defiance, represents a place of potential liberation. Antoinette’s maid, Christophine, offers this island of her ancestry as a sanctuary amidst Antoinette’s marital decline. However, her English husband’s rejection of this escape underscores his fear of losing control and his deep-seated prejudice against the perceived "wildness" and autonomy that Martinique symbolizes.

Granbois: The Wounded Heart

Granbois, inherited from Antoinette's mother, is the setting for her ill-fated honeymoon. Initially a place of joy and connection for Antoinette, her husband’s betrayal transforms it into a site of pain and resentment. The natural beauty of Granbois, with its vibrant colors and intoxicating scents, becomes a battleground for Antoinette’s sanity as her husband’s inability to master its essence mirrors his failure to understand and love her.

The Sargasso Sea: A Symbol of Entangled Souls

Though the Sargasso Sea is only mentioned in the title, it plays a metaphorical role in the narrative. Its warm, calm waters filled with floating seaweed become a symbol of Antoinette’s rootlessness and her husband’s feelings of entrapment. This sea is emblematic of the murky, indistinguishable boundaries between identity and otherness, freedom and confinement, which pervade the lives of the novel's characters.

Media Adaptations

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Wide Sargasso Sea was turned into a film in 1993 by Carol Angier, John Dugian, and Jan Sharpe. The Australian movie features Karina Lombard, Rachel Ward, Michael York, Nathaniel Parker, and Naomi Watts. Due to its explicit sexual content, the film received an NC-17 rating, but a censored R-rated version is also available from New Line Home Video.

In 1973, composer Gordon Crosse created a musical piece titled Memories of Morning: A Monodrama for Mezzo-soprano and Orchestra, which is loosely inspired by Rhys's novel. This score can be found through Oxford University Press.

In 1996, Australian composer Brian Howard transformed Wide Sargasso Sea into a chamber opera.

Bibliography and Further Reading

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Sources:

Allen, Walter, review, in New York Times Book Review, June 18, 1967, p. 5.

Alvarez, A., ‘‘The Best Living English Novelist,’’ in New York Times Book Review, March 17, 1974, pp. 6-7.

Bronte, Charlotte, Jane Eyre, Penguin Classics, 1985.

Carson, Rachel, ''The Sargasso Sea,'' in Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. 117-19.

Drake, Sandra, '''All that Foolishness/That All Foolishness': Race and Caribbean Culture as Themes of Liberation in Jean Rhys' Wide Sargasso Sea,’’ Critica, Vol. 2, No. 2, Fall 1990, pp. 97-112.

Emery, Mary Lou, ‘‘Modernist Crosscurrents,’’ in her Jean Rhys at World's End: Novels of Colonial and Sexual Exile, University of Texas Press, 1990, pp. 7-20.

Erwin, Lee, '''Like in a Looking Glass': History and Narrative in Wide Sargasso Sea,’’ Novel, Vol. 22, No. 2, Winter 1989, pp. 143-58.

Frickey, Pierette M., "Introduction," in Critical Perspectives on Jean Rhys, edited by Pierrette M. Frickey, Three Continents Press, 1990, pp. 1-13.

Nunez-Harrell, Elizabeth, ‘‘The Paradoxes of Belonging: The White West Indian Woman in Fiction,’’ in Modern Fiction Studies, Vol. 31, No. 2, Summer 1985, pp. 281-93.

Raiskin, Judith L., "Notes," in her Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, by Jean Rhys, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. 20, 149.

Raiskin, Judith L., "Preface," in her Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, by Jean Rhys, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. ix-xii.

Ramchand, Kenneth, An Introduction to the Study of West Indian Literature, Thomas Nelson and Sons, 1976, pp. 91-107.

Rhys, Jean, ‘‘The Bible Is Modern,’’ in Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. 148-49.

Rhys, Jean, ‘‘Black Exercise Book,’’ in Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. 155-56.

Rhys, Jean, ‘‘Selected Letters,’’ in Wide Sargasso Sea: Backgrounds, Criticisms, edited by Judith L. Raiskin, W. W. Norton and Company, 1999, pp. 132-45.

Rhys, Jean, Smile Please: An Unfinished Autobiography, Harper and Row, 1979.

Sternlicht, Sanford, ‘‘Wide Sargasso Sea,’’ in his Jean Rhys, Twayne, 1997.

Thorpe, Michael, '‘’The Other Side': Wide Sargasso Sea and Jane Eyre,’’ in Ariel, Vol. 8, No. 3, July 1977, pp. 99-110.

Williams, Eric, ''The Slaves and Slavery," in his Capitalism and Slavery, The University of North Carolina Press, 1994, pp. 197-208.

Further Reading:

Ramchand, Kenneth, ‘‘Wide Sargasso Sea,’’ in Critical Perspectives on Jean Rhys, edited by Pierrette M. Frickey, Three Continents Press, 1990.
Ramchand asserts that Wide Sargasso Sea is fundamentally a West Indian novel. Nonetheless, he emphasizes that calling a novel West Indian does not exclude its accessibility to non-West Indian readers, nor does it invalidate their interpretations.
Sternlicht, Sanford, Jean Rhys, Twayne, 1997.
This critical biography of Jean Rhys offers insights into Rhys's life along with an analysis of each of her works. The chapter on Wide Sargasso Sea delves into the novel's primary themes.
Thomas, Sue, The Worlding of Jean Rhys, Greenwood Press, 1999.
In this book, Thomas expresses her aim to ‘‘begin to understand Rhys's locations, the way she positions her authorial and narrative voices politically and ethically in relation to the worlds of her fiction and autobiographical writing.’’

Previous

Critical Essays

Next

Teaching Guide

Loading...