India was still a colony under the British Empire when Tagore wrote this poem. It can be read as a list of prayers expressing the Nobel laureate’s vision of free India.
Among many other wishes, he prays to the Almighty to awaken his countrymen in a world that “has not...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
been broken up into fragments / By narrow domestic walls.”
“Domestic walls” is a complex symbol that can be interpreted in a number of ways. India has always accommodated diverse cultures, languages and kingdoms in its vast territory. It’s a land of diversities. The poet doesn't want these differences to divide his countrymen as separate individuals, or into clustered communities or groups.
The "domestic walls" could stand for the prominent regional differences caused primarily because of the varying topographical features.
It might represent walls created by different religions. Besides the major religions of Hinduism and Islam, other religions including Buddhism, Jainism and Christianity had had huge followers in India. The poet feared the possibility of religious fanatics antagonizing one community against the others.
Besides, “domestic walls” may also refer to the barriers caused by the hundreds of regional languages spoken across the country. Not only this, the culture and tradition, too, varied with distance.
Though, as an Indian, Tagore was proud of his country for being so diverse, accommodative and tolerant, he was afraid, at the same time, that these differences might antagonize one group against the other and the dream of a free and united India might not be possible.
So, he prays to the almighty to awaken his countrymen to a country that “has not been broken up into fragments / By narrow domestic walls”
It must be noted that Tagore never uses the word "India" anywhere in this poem. So, this poem can also be interpreted as the wish of a sage who hopes to see the whole world get united as one unified body. The "domestic walls," thus, could mean the physical boundaries or borders by drawing which men has sliced the earth that God had created as a single entity.
Further Reading
In Rabindranath Tagore's "Where The Mind Is Without Fear," explain 'narrow' domestic walls and how they have broken the world into fragments.
The "narrow domestic walls" refer to Tagore's Bengal, which at the turn of the 20th century was presided over by Lord Curzon, the viceroy-general of India. Lord Curzon was fiercely imperialist in his outlook; he saw India (and by extension, Bengal) as subject to the whims of British paternalistic hegemony. To that end, Curzon ruled India with autocratic ruthlessness; no dissent was brooked or entertained; any demonstration of Bengali nationalism was not tolerated.
During the early 1900s, both Bengali Hindus and Muslims were at the forefront of the Indian nationalist movement. They had lost all patience with the "narrow domestic walls" the English had unequivocally confined Bengal to. Bengalis longed to thrive in a unified country, one in which "the world has not been broken up into fragments." Tagore wrote his poem at the turn of the 20th century. By this time, Lord Curzon was already planning to sow seeds of discord between Bengali Hindus and Muslims; he feared that the two powerful groups were quickly marshaling their forces for a confrontation of sorts. For his part, Lord Curzon privately developed the idea of partition and quietly made plans to bring it to fruition in 1903.
To Lord Curzon's frustration, however, his plans were discovered, and a huge outcry erupted among Bengali Hindus and Muslims. This national furor convinced Lord Curzon that the Bengali people had to be reined in. Partition was resolutely announced in 1905 and brought to fruition on October 16th that same year. East Bengal now came to be dominated by Muslims, making Hindus a minority in that region. The ensuing discord and dissatisfaction from the Hindus were palpable.
Thus, the Partition of 1905 rendered Bengal no longer a united country; it had been "fragmented" within the "narrow domestic walls" that circumscribed the will of the Bengali people.
In Rabindranath Tagore's "Where The Mind Is Without Fear," explain 'narrow' domestic walls and how they have broken the world into fragments.
In Mind Without Fear by Rabindranath Tagore, Tagore uses a poetic form to make his plea to his people (India) and to his "Father," God. The title of the original poem means "prayer" in Bengali and was translated into English by Tagore himself. There is more of the spirit of independence in his original version. He wants his people ("my country") to believe that freedom is within their grasp but the first obstacle which will prevent "ever widening thought" is fear.
This poem was written at a time when India was part of the British Empire and Tagore recognizes that India only has a chance at independence if its people are inspired and united. In the poem he speaks of that place in his mind where freedom exists and which can become a reality; a place "Where the world has not been broken up into fragments / By narrow domestic walls."
The fragmented world to which he refers is all the divisions and sub-divisions created by western occupation and Imperialism and it also extends to India itself. The "narrow domestic walls" are those barriers which India has even apart from any outside influence and those issues threaten its independence. Even personal issues need to be overcome if Tagore's vision is to be realized.
In Rabindranath Tagore's "Where The Mind Is Without Fear," explain 'narrow' domestic walls and how they have broken the world into fragments.
In Rabindranath Tagore's poem "Mind Without Fear" (from his poetry book Gitanjali) the following lines appears:
Where the world has not been broken up
into fragments by narrow domestic walls.
Therefore, Tagore is saying that the narrow thoughts and words of people are responsible for fragmenting the world.
The way that the world is not fragmented is when a mind can exist without fear, a head is held high, words only come from the "depth[s] of truth," clear reason has not been lost, and the mind is led by God.
It is only when the mind exists with fear and the head has fallen because of it that the world will be broken by the narrowness of "domestic walls."
For Tagore, domestic walls are those which bring about fear, lies are told, clear reason has been lost, and the mind is not led by God.