Summary
"When the Lamp Is Shattered" is an evocative poem by Percy Bysshe Shelley, encapsulating the emotional turmoil that ensues from the loss of a beloved woman's affections. Written in Pisa, Italy, during a period when Shelley enjoyed a brief respite from his tumultuous life, the poem intertwines personal grief with metaphorical imagery to portray the desolation of a lovelorn poet. Throughout the thirty-two lines, Shelley deftly explores themes of lost creativity, unrequited love, and the bitter aftermath of romantic disenchantment.
Shelley's Context and Inspirations
During the last year of his life, Shelley found a semblance of stability in Pisa amidst a circle of friends that included Edward Williams and Jane, Edward's wife, who was the object of Shelley's affections. The poem may have been inspired by this flirtation with Jane, though this remains speculative. Tragically, Edward Williams died alongside Shelley in a storm off the Leghorn coast in July 1822. This period marked a poignant intersection of creative fervor and personal loss, serving as a backdrop for the intense emotional landscape of the poem.
Imagery of Shattered Creativity
The poem commences with vivid imagery symbolizing the collapse of the speaker’s poetic creativity, akin to a lamp that once illuminated the poetry now lying dead in the dust. This imagery extends to a dispersal of clouds that once held a rainbow’s brilliance or a broken lute, which can no longer evoke memories of shared love songs. These metaphors paint a picture of a poet whose inspiration has been extinguished by unreciprocated affection.
The Decline of Poetic Inspiration
In the second stanza, Shelley expands on this motif by illustrating the loss of poetic vitality that accompanies romantic failure. The cessation of the lute and lamp symbolizes the end of inspiration for poetic sound and rhetorical brilliance, leaving the poet's heart desolate. The only echoes that remain are those of sorrow and death, likened to the mournful winds and crashing waves that herald a sailor’s demise, thus reinforcing the theme of creative barrenness.
Love's Frailty and the Poet's Lament
Transitioning to the third stanza, the poem personifies Love as an eagle, an image that encapsulates the fragile nature of human affections. Despite its majesty, Love settles in the heart of the poet, leaving him to ponder its capriciousness. Unlike the poet, the beloved woman remains unfettered by such emotional confines, highlighting the imbalance in their romantic attachment.
The Inhospitable Heart
In the concluding stanza, the personification of Love as an eagle continues, warning that the poet's heart will be a hostile environment for Love to dwell. His disillusionment acts as a storm, disrupting the eagle’s nest, while his intellect, like a winter sun, pierces through Love’s deceit. The once passionate heart becomes a decayed nest, exposed to the harshness of winter and the ridicule of disillusionment. This underscores the poet's acceptance of his embittered state and the futility of nurturing unreciprocated emotions.
Style and Technique
In "When the Lamp Is Shattered," Percy Bysshe Shelley crafts a poignant exploration of lost love through a rich tapestry of sound and imagery. The poem's intricate structure and its use of varied poetic devices effectively convey the themes of romantic desolation and the fading of poetic inspiration. While some critics may have found Shelley’s artistic style excessive, his lyrical mastery remains evident in the evocative language and emotional depth of the poem.
Poetic Structure
"When the Lamp Is Shattered" is composed of four stanzas, each containing eight lines with alternating end rhymes. Shelley employs two sets of quatrains per stanza, with feminine end rhymes woven throughout to mirror the transient nature of lost love. These rhymes,...
(This entire section contains 406 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
such as “shattered” and “scattered,” are emblematic of the poem’s delicate and ephemeral quality.
Metrical Variations
The poem’s rhythm oscillates between iambic tetrameter and iambic trimeter, punctuated by deliberate irregularities. This musical irregularity—highlighted by sudden stressed sounds disrupting the iambic flow—enhances the poem’s theme of romantic discord and heartache. Such disruptions, alongside the use of consonance and assonance, lend a haunting musicality to lines like “The light in the dust lies dead.”
Critical Reception
Shelley’s penchant for elaborate rhetorical style has occasionally drawn criticism, with some suggesting that his artistry teeters on the brink of incoherence. Desmond King-Hele, in his book Shelley: The Man and the Poet, dismissed "When the Lamp Is Shattered" as "trite and trivial," a sentiment echoed by F. R. Leavis’s critique of the poem’s diction. Despite such views, the poem stands as a sincere Romantic lyric, woven with Shelley’s characteristic exploration of love and poetic loss.
Imagery and Metaphor
Shelley’s use of metaphor and simile is central to the poem’s success in depicting the anguish of lost love and diminished creativity. In the first stanza, metaphors of a broken lamp, lute, and rainbow implicitly reflect the poet-speaker’s melancholic inspiration. The second stanza extends these images into similes, comparing his stifled imaginative powers to wrecked cells and somber, destructive waves.
Metaphorical Depth
A pivotal metaphor emerges in the poem’s latter half, where Love is likened to a nesting eagle. This image, alongside storm and sun similes in the final stanza, underscores the speaker’s emotional turmoil and the stark devastation of unfulfilled love. The poem concludes with a vivid portrayal of the poet-speaker’s embittered emotional landscape, deeply affected by romantic disappointment.
