Summary
The play "What the Butler Saw" is a farcical comedy that unfolds in a chaotic sequence of misunderstandings and mistaken identities, all centered around a psychiatric clinic. The narrative delves into the complexities of human relationships, societal norms, and the absurdities inherent in both, all while maintaining a comedic tone. Through a series of outrageous events, the play examines themes of power dynamics, sexuality, and deception.
Act I
The curtain rises on a scene inside a psychiatric clinic, where Dr. Prentice, a psychiatrist, begins an interview with Geraldine Barclay for a secretarial role. Geraldine enters, clutching a small box, and places it on the floor. As their conversation progresses, she divulges that her father is unknown to her, and she hasn't seen her mother, who worked as a chambermaid, in years. Raised by her late stepmother, Mrs. Barclay, Geraldine's life was disrupted by an accident involving a gas explosion that also demolished a statue of Sir Winston Churchill. Eerily, fragments of the statue were discovered in Mrs. Barclay's body.
Pretending to conduct a medical assessment essential for the job, Dr. Prentice lures Geraldine into undressing. Misreading her innocent compliance, he places her dress on a chair while she reclines on a couch obscured by curtains. His wife, Mrs. Prentice, unexpectedly enters, followed by a hotel page named Nick. The chaotic scene intensifies as Nick and Mrs. Prentice, who share a clandestine past, conspire over photographs that could jeopardize her marriage unless she secures Nick a position at the clinic.
Amidst the ensuing confusion, Dr. Rance, a government psychiatrist, arrives, misinterpreting the situation and assuming Geraldine is a patient undergoing treatment. Providing her with a hospital gown and sedative, Dr. Rance's intervention further complicates matters. Mrs. Prentice, seeking Geraldine, discovers her clothing but not Geraldine herself, leading to further speculations about her husband's fidelity.
As Dr. Prentice futilely attempts to restore order, he unwittingly implicates Geraldine in a scandal fabricated by Dr. Rance. The latter's insistence that Geraldine is a victim of paternal abuse spirals into absurdity as Mrs. Prentice confronts her husband about his erratic behavior. When a police sergeant named Match appears, further complications arise as identities continue to blur. Nick, now dressed in Mrs. Prentice’s attire, is embroiled in a farcical masquerade intended to deceive the authorities.
Act II
The chaos resumes shortly after, with Sergeant Match inadvertently caught in Dr. Prentice's web of deception. Geraldine, mistakenly identified as Nick, accuses Dr. Prentice of misconduct, only to be met with disbelief and the threat of an examination. Rance, in his skewed logic, prepares to conduct a further examination, while Mrs. Prentice and Nick, still in disguise, add to the confusion. Dr. Prentice’s efforts to conceal his actions lead to his dismissal by Rance, who deems him mentally unfit for duty.
The tangled web of mistaken identities unravels as Nick and Geraldine acknowledge the switch in their clothing, while Nick plots to masquerade as Sergeant Match. Upon the sergeant's entrance, Dr. Prentice administers a concoction, leading to Sergeant Match's drugged state and eventual undress. Meanwhile, Dr. Rance, oblivious to the truth, concocts a far-fetched psychiatric narrative to explain the perplexing events, dreaming of turning it into a profitable novel.
As the subplot thickens, the disappearance of a box of pills leads Rance to suspect either suicide or foul play involving Geraldine. Dr. Prentice, now cornered, admits to improper conduct with Geraldine, while Mrs. Prentice hints at deeper secrets. Violence ensues as Dr. Prentice forcibly removes Mrs. Prentice's dress, exacerbating the farce when Dr. Rance returns and receives an exaggerated account of the altercation.
The comedic pandemonium crescendos with Nick,...
(This entire section contains 850 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
clothed in Sergeant Match's uniform, claiming to have arrested himself. Amidst accusations of murder and mistaken identities, Nick reveals the truth about posing as a woman at Dr. Prentice’s behest. Dr. Rance's escalating paranoia leads to attempts to subdue Dr. Prentice with a straitjacket, interrupted by further mishaps involving gunshots and mistaken identities.
The climax reaches a fevered pitch as Mrs. Prentice wields a firearm, discharging it in a series of wild shots directed at Nick. Geraldine, exposed amidst the chaos, finds herself restrained, while Dr. Prentice wrestles control of the situation, only to have the tables turned once again. In a final twist, Dr. Rance gains control of a weapon, threatening Dr. Prentice as sirens echo and barriers enclose the room.
In the denouement, Dr. Prentice reveals the truth about the intertwined identities of Nick and Geraldine, resulting in a shocking familial revelation. When a piece of jewelry emerges, Nick and Mrs. Prentice recognize it as a fragmented brooch from their shared past. The twins, separated at birth and identified by their matching charms, learn their true parentage, with Dr. Prentice as their father.
The play concludes with a surreal escape as a skylight opens and a ladder descends. As characters scramble to retrieve their clothing and the elusive piece of the Churchill statue, the ensemble ascends into the light, leaving the pandemonium behind. This absurd finale encapsulates the play's themes of mistaken identity, the absurdity of societal norms, and the enduring chaos of human relationships.