Discussion Topic
The main theme of the poem "We Are Seven."
Summary:
The main theme of the poem "We Are Seven" is the innocence and perspective of childhood. The poem explores how a young girl perceives her deceased siblings as still being part of her family, highlighting the contrast between her innocent viewpoint and the adult's understanding of death and separation.
What is the main theme of the poem "We Are Seven?"
The main theme in "We Are Seven" is the subject of life and death. The speaker of the poem meets a rural child and asks her how many siblings she has. She claims, "Seven in all," implying that she is one of seven children. Then the child elaborates and explains that two of her siblings are dead. "Two of us in the churchyard lie," (21). This is where the theme of life and death gets more specific. The theme becomes more about the different ways children and adults interpret death.
The speaker challenges the young girl's interpretation:
If two are in the church-yard laid,
Then ye are only five. (35-36)
Here, the speaker tells the girl that, since two of her siblings are dead, she is one of only five children ("ye" refers to the girl and her living siblings). The girl counters the speaker's interpretation of death...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
by explaining how she knits, eats dinner, and sings songs beside her dead siblings' graves, which happen to be a mere 12 steps from the door to her house.
The adult speaker is insistent that the two siblings are in heaven and therefore, the girl is no longer one of seven. The girl is equally obstinate that those two have lived on in some way.
This discrepancy between the speaker's and the young girl's interpretations of death can be interpreted in a number of ways. One could argue that this poem presents a theory that children are unable to fully grasp what death means; that is, for adults, death represents a more distinct finality. One could also argue that the young girl expresses an idea that the deceased live on in the memories of the living; it's just that the girl conflates that "place" where the memory lies with the actual place (grave) where her siblings lie.
Given Wordsworth's praise of the rural life and the innocence of youth, it is logical to suppose that Wordsworth is that adult speaker in the poem and he wants to interpret death the way the young girl does. If this is the case, then the speaker is not frustrated with the girl's view that her two dead siblings are still alive in some way. Rather, the speaker is frustrated with his own jaded, maybe even morbid, overly rational view of death as a finality.
What is the main idea of the poem "We are Seven"?
The main idea of Wordsworth's poem "We are Seven"is that the dead still "count", even though they are no longer with us. In the poem, a man approaches an eight-year-old girl and asks her how many brothers and sisters she has. She answers that "we are seven" (meaning there are seven siblings total), and proceeds to explain that two of her siblings lie in the church yard. She further details how first her sister, Jane, and then her brother, John, fell ill and were laid to rest in the church graveyard, not far from her home.
The man counters the girl, stating that, as only five siblings are still alive, her count should be at five. He contrasts the siblings whose souls "are in heaven" with the girl, who has limbs that "are alive". She counters with tales of how she still interacts with her dead siblings, visiting their graves often, singing, etc. In the end, as the poet asserts, the "little maid has her will", as she will not be convinced that she has any less than a family of seven. This is one of those cases where children can be more knowing than adults, as most readers will find themselves siding with the girl.