Student Question
What does the verbal irony in Crane's "War is Kind" suggest about his attitude toward war?
Quick answer:
The verbal irony in Stephen Crane's "War is Kind" suggests that he views war as cruel and unattractive. By presenting gut-wrenching images of loss and suffering, such as a maiden's lover dying helplessly and a child losing a father to mustard gas, Crane shatters the notion of glorious war and uses irony to emphasize its brutality and senselessness.
The use of verbal irony in Stephen Crane's "War is Kind" makes Crane's attitude toward war very clear. Stanzas one, three, and five present a maiden, a child, and a mother, respectively, who have all lost someone close to them through war. The descriptions of the losses are gut-wrenching. For example, in stanza one, Crane writes:
Do not weep, maiden, for war is kind.
Because your lover threw wild hands toward the sky
And the affrighted steed ran on alone,
Do not weep.
War is kind.
The image of the maiden's lover throwing "wild hands" upward while flailing
helplessly and falling from his "affrighted steed" that "ran on alone" shatters
the idea of glorious war and valiant death. While dying, the lover did not
charge ahead and boldly sacrifice himself to achieve a final glory; the steed
did not return to pick up its brave master. Instead, we are presented with the
reality of war, followed by the very ironic demand that the maiden "not weep"
because "war is kind." This is especially ironic because of the detailed
description of the lover's death.
Stanza three presents a similar pattern, focusing on a small child who has lost
a father. However, there is no mention of the father's brave final moments.
Instead the child is told "your father tumbled in the yellow trenches, / Raged
at his breast, gulped and died." He clearly died due to the effects of inhaling
mustard gas. Once again, Crane ends the stanza with the ironic "do not weep. /
War is kind."
While Crane presents what appear to be more typical, "glorious" images of war
in stanzas two and four, these stanzas also end with images of death,
suffering, and desolation. Crane employs verbal irony in these instances as
well, through lines such as "Great is the battle-god, great, and his kingdom— /
A field where a thousand corpses lie" and "Make plain . . . the excellence of
killing/ And a field where a thousand corpses lie." Clearly, there is nothing
great or excellent about a field littered with corpses.
In this poem, Crane does not glorify war. His poem makes it clear that war is cruel and unattractive.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.