Themes

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Death

Death is a central theme in "The Wall." When Pablo is sentenced to death, he begins to view life from a completely new perspective. Those who once held great importance in his life no longer matter to him. He sees his remaining hours as the beginning of his end. Pablo even comes to believe that death is unnatural, pointing out that people live under the delusion that they will continue to exist. As he puts it, people maintain "the illusion of being eternal."

While confined in his cell, Pablo contemplates how others confront the certainty of death. He contrasts the reactions of Tom and Juan to their impending executions: Juan is frightened by the prospect of dying and the pain it might involve; Tom attempts to imagine what it would be like to be shot but cannot, as he envisions himself as an observer of his own death.

When Pablo is brought before the Falangist officers again in the morning, he finds their attempts to intimidate him ridiculous. They do not grasp that their considerable power is overshadowed by the ultimate power of death; they pose no threat to a man who is already doomed to die.

Alienation

Philosophers G. W. F. Hegel and Karl Marx theorized alienation as a condition where individuals feel disconnected from their true nature. Pablo experiences this alienation after discovering his death sentence. The first indication of his altered perception is when he notices that, instead of feeling the chill of the drafty cell, he is actually sweating. Running his fingers through his hair, he is surprised to find it stiff with sweat, realizing he must have been sweating for hours without noticing.

Over time, Pablo starts perceiving his body as if it belongs to someone else, thinking, ‘‘it was no longer I.’’ As time passes, he also becomes detached from his own consciousness, including the people and ideals that once meant everything to him. He finds that nothing holds significance anymore—not the anarchist movement, not freedom, not even his girlfriend. Pablo increasingly feels ‘‘inhuman,’’ highlighting his estrangement from those around him, from society, and from his former self.

War

War serves as another pivotal theme in ‘‘The Wall.’’ The narrative unfolds during Spain's harsh civil war, where Spanish forces supporting a republican government clash with the fascist Falangists. Although the story does not directly portray the combat, it highlights some critical elements of living in a war-ravaged area.

For instance, during wartime, courts often impose harsh and arbitrary sentences. While some detainees, such as those facing trial with Pablo, are charged with tangible offenses like sabotaging munitions, others, like Juan, seem to be convicted simply because of their connections to friends or family. The baker Garcia aptly describes this scenario when he remarks after his arrest, apparently for no wrongdoing: "They arrest everybody who doesn’t think the way they do."

Existentialism

Having a foundational understanding of existentialism—a complex philosophical concept thoroughly explored by Sartre in Being and Nothingness—is crucial for interpreting "The Wall." Sartre coined the term existentialism to encapsulate his perspective on human existence. His particular approach, called atheistic existentialism, posits that individuals exist in a universe without a divine presence, where the core human experience is marked by suffering and isolation.

Sartre argued that humans have an inherent desire for completeness and significance; in the absence of these, they endure feelings of anguish and pointlessness. However, existentialism does not suggest that hope is entirely lost for humanity. In a world without predetermined values, individuals have the freedom to shape their identities and characters through their choices and actions. Essentially, people can create...

(This entire section contains 365 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

their own set of values. By taking decisive actions, a person can find meaning in life and become self-defining.

Pablo, Juan, and Tom each exhibit characteristics of men experiencing an existential crisis, but they respond in distinct ways. Juan rejects the inevitability of his fate and refuses to walk to his execution, compelling the guards to carry him, thus passively giving control of his destiny to others. Tom attempts to confront his death with honesty and dignity. Pablo's feeling of alienation from his cellmates and himself reflects his struggle to forge his own path in life.

At the story's end, Pablo asserts his existence by sending the soldiers on what he perceives as a pointless search for Ramon Gris. Ironically, he correctly reveals Ramon's location, inadvertently becoming the cause of his friend Ramon's death due to his inability to live truthfully.

From Sartre's viewpoint, Pablo bears responsibility for Ramon's demise. As critic Kevin W. Sweeney comments in Mosaic, "Pablo believes that it is within his power to extend or retract his responsibility. . . . he thinks that he can rebuild the 'foundation' of his being, to choose what he will be responsible for."

When faced with the decision between Ramon's life and his own, Pablo does not genuinely make a choice. Instead, he concocts an alternate perspective on the situation, one that enables him to evade choosing between his life and Ramon's. However, as the situation unfolds, this proves to be unattainable.

Existentialism and the Wall

Nearly half a decade before Jean-Paul Sartre's existentialist philosophy fully formed, "The Wall" emerged as a compelling narrative that vividly illustrates the core themes of existentialism. By transforming abstract philosophical concepts into a gripping story, it offers a concrete portrayal of existential ideas.

The titular "wall" initially represents the prison courtyard barrier where prisoners await execution, but it transcends its literal meaning. It symbolizes the demarcation between life and death, encapsulating the existential transition from "being" to "nothingness." This metaphorical wall becomes central to the experience of Pablo Ibbieta, the story's protagonist. Though he physically survives to narrate his tale, he symbolically dies the moment he comprehends the looming prospect of his "nothingness." In this instant, the vibrancy of human attributes such as love, friendship, and political engagement withers away, leaving him spiritually barren. It's as if Pablo has crossed to the other side of the wall, leaving behind a life once filled with connectedness and purpose.

Reflection on Life and Death

In the shadow of impending execution, Pablo finds himself in the early morning hours reflecting on a life that suddenly appears incomplete and curiously unfulfilled. He muses, “I wondered how I’d been able to walk, to laugh with the girls: I wouldn’t have moved so much as my little finger if I had only imagined I would die like this." His life, once seemingly full of potential, now feels final and closed, a container of unfinished ambitions and incomplete actions. This introspection reveals a profound realization: many of his intentions and dreams will perish alongside him, leaving scant evidence of his existence for future generations.

Despite this grim reflection, Pablo remains steadfast in his principles. He clings to a personal code of honor, stands by his commitment to the liberal cause, and resolves to face death "cleanly" and "well." His resolve distinguishes him from his fellow prisoners, who perhaps lack such determination. In Sartre's view, this steadfastness underscores a fundamental existential truth—there is no afterlife, no lingering imprint of one's journey on earth beyond the tangible sum of one's deeds. This narrative offers a sobering meditation on the tenuous nature of life and the inexorable passage of time, compelling a confrontation with the stark reality that defines human existence.

Previous

Summary

Next

Characters

Loading...