Themes: Wealth Versus Poverty
While illustrating his transition into primitive living, Thoreau admonishes the emphasis that society places on wealth as an indicator of success. In discussing what he views as necessities for survival—food, shelter, clothing, and fuel—Thoreau analyzes the distinction between the function and luxury of material goods. For example, in “Economy,” he chastises the wealthy for using their means to buy extravagant clothing and other nonessential goods. Thoreau argues,
Superfluous wealth can buy superfluities only. Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul.
In portraying the influence that materialism has on many human cultures, Thoreau stresses that wealth is an insufficient source of happiness and offers no help in achieving self-realization or intellectual growth. He therefore challenges the assumption that the affluent and privileged are intellectually superior to those with less; instead, he believes that excess wealth blinds the wealthy to intellectual and spiritual insight. Before pointing out that “the luxury of one class is counterbalanced by the indigence of another,” he asks the following question:
And if the civilized man’s pursuits are no worthier than the savage’s, if he is employed the greater part of his life in obtaining gross necessaries and comforts merely, why should he have a better dwelling than the former?
As Thoreau contemplates how this disparity between the “civilized man” and the “savage” operates according to a hierarchical system of entitlement, Thoreau is firm in his belief that self-sufficient and minimalist practices allow individuals to exist with authenticity and grow with purpose. He affirms that “there is another alternative than to obtain the superfluities” if one chooses to live simply and without luxuries. One must “adventure on life now” and resolve to explore and discover the true necessities in life—not just for survival, but also for spiritual well-being.
Expert Q&A
What does Thoreau mean by "most men live meanly" in Walden?
Thoreau uses the term "meanly" in Walden to describe living a narrow, miserly life focused on work and material accumulation rather than on meaningful experiences. He criticizes this lifestyle, comparing it to ants who labor continuously without enjoying life. Thoreau advocates for a simpler, less cluttered life, suggesting that true fulfillment comes from focusing on the essentials and reducing life's complexities.
In Walden, what does Thoreau imply by equating a farm to the county jail?
Thoreau equates owning a farm to being in jail to highlight the restrictive nature of both commitments. He suggests that owning property can imprison individuals by tying them to responsibilities, inhibiting true freedom and personal growth. In Walden, Thoreau emphasizes living freely and uncommitted to avoid "quiet desperation," advocating for a life focused on inner fulfillment rather than material possessions. This aligns with his broader theme of simplifying life to focus on what truly matters.
How do you interpret the following quote about different forms of servitude?
"I sometimes wonder that we can be so frivolous, I may almost say, as to attend to the gross but somewhat foreign form of servitude called Negro Slavery, there are so many keen and subtle masters that enslave both north and south. It is hard to have a southern overseer; it is worse to have a northern one; but worst of all when you are the slave-driver of yourself."
The quote suggests that while slavery is a visible form of servitude, there are subtler forms that also enslave individuals, such as societal expectations and personal ambitions. Thoreau argues that becoming a slave to societal norms or material pursuits, particularly through self-imposed pressures, is a more insidious form of bondage. The worst form of servitude is self-imposed, where individuals drive themselves to conform and pursue hollow goals, thus losing their true freedom.
What does Thoreau mean by "economy" in Walden?
In Walden, by "economy," Thoreau means the greatest possible simplicity in every aspect of life. Thoreau emphasizes the importance of not overcomplicating one's life with unnecessary items or pastimes, using an example of a doormat with which he has no space, no use for, nor time to clean. Though this example is an exaggeration, as a doormat is not so terribly burdensome, Thoreau argues that to accept the doormat would be to give in to "the beginnings of evil."
How does Thoreau's notion of "poverty" in Walden compare to the concept of "third-world poverty"?
Thoreau's notion of "poverty" in Walden refers to voluntary simplicity, contrasting sharply with "third-world poverty," which is involuntary and driven by necessity. Thoreau chose a simple life to explore philosophical truths, not out of necessity, and had the option to return to comfort. In contrast, third-world poverty involves severe deprivation of basic needs like food and shelter, often resulting in suffering and hardship. Thoreau's audience was primarily middle-class, urging them to embrace simplicity over excess.
What does Thoreau mean by his "wealth" in this quote from Walden, and how does he use it in relation to the workshop or school?
In the quote from Walden, Thoreau describes "wealth" as the spiritual and emotional richness gained from spending time in nature, rather than material wealth from work or school. He values experiences and introspection over societal norms of success and monetary gain. Thoreau believes that true wealth comes from independence, leisure, and harmony with nature, rather than conforming to societal expectations of work and materialism.
Thoreau's perspective on wealth and poverty in Walden
In Walden, Thoreau views wealth and poverty through a lens of simplicity and self-sufficiency. He believes true wealth comes from spiritual richness and a connection to nature, rather than material possessions. Thoreau advocates for a minimalist lifestyle, suggesting that reducing one's needs and desires leads to greater fulfillment and freedom.
Thoreau's insights on land ownership and property in "Economy" from Walden
In "Economy" from Walden, Thoreau critiques land ownership and property, arguing that they often burden individuals rather than bring true happiness. He believes that material possessions and property ownership can distract from the essential experiences of life and advocates for simplicity and self-sufficiency as paths to personal freedom and fulfillment.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
