Analysis
W. Somerset Maugham, a playwright and novelist by trade, found his most enduring legacy in his short stories. These works, characterized by their exotic settings and straightforward prose, captivated global audiences during the 1920s and 1930s. Maugham's stories, often set in the South Seas and populated with vivid characters, remain a testament to his storytelling prowess and his capacity to infuse realism into romanticized backdrops.
Exploring the South Seas
Maugham's immersion into short-story writing was almost serendipitous. After recovering from an illness while in the British Secret Service during World War I, he traveled to Samoa and Hawaii, inspired by the allure of the South Seas depicted in the works of Herman Melville, Pierre Loti, and Robert Louis Stevenson. However, Maugham's experiences diverged from these romanticized accounts. His collection, The Trembling of a Leaf: Little Stories of the South Sea Islands, solidified his reputation as a short-story writer, featuring stories that eschewed romantic frills for stark realism.
In writing these tales, Maugham acknowledged an indebtedness to Rudyard Kipling for introducing the notion of exploring the cultural and psychological impact of colonial life on the British expatriate. However, unlike Kipling, Maugham sought to strip away the "romantic glamour," focusing instead on the raw realities of colonial existence.
"Red" - A Story of Romantic Illusion
The story "Red" is emblematic of Maugham's approach, where romanticized notions are dismantled to reveal the harsher truths beneath. In this tale, Neilson, a character who has settled on a Samoan island after contracting tuberculosis, is haunted by the memory of Red, a young man who had lived a seemingly idyllic life with Neilson's wife, Sally. Maugham contrasts Neilson's life of disillusionment and cultural estrangement with his romanticized vision of Red's existence, revealing the latter as an unattainable ideal.
The irony deepens when it is revealed that the skipper, who anchors off the island and becomes part of the narrative, is in fact Red himself. Neilson’s reverie crumbles as he recognizes the futility of his romantic illusions. Sally and Red's failure to recognize each other underscores the gap between reality and the myth Neilson had constructed over the years.
Realism and Irony in Maugham's Work
Maugham's stories are known for their realism and sharp irony, often placing characters in situations where their deepest flaws are revealed. In "The Pool," for instance, a Scotsman named Lawson, whose adherence to British norms blinds him to cultural differences, meets a tragic end. Maugham employs irony to highlight the cultural myopia of his characters and the consequences of their attempts to impose their values on alien environments.
"Rain" - The Unpredictability of Human Nature
"Rain," perhaps Maugham’s most famous short story, exemplifies his mastery over themes of cultural conflict and human complexity. The story unfolds on the rainy island of Pago Pago and revolves around Mr. Davidson, a missionary, and Sadie Thompson, a prostitute. Davidson's attempt to reform Sadie is an exercise in futility, as his repressed desires ultimately lead to his own downfall. Maugham's refusal to depict the climactic scenes grants the story a dramatic power, emphasizing the unpredictable and often contradictory facets of human nature.
Maugham's fascination with the unpredictability of human behavior is further explored in the collection Six Stories Written in the First Person Singular. These stories display an innovative narrative technique, where the narrator—often a version of Maugham himself—witnesses the ironies and complexities of life. This framework allows readers to navigate the stories with an understanding yet detached perspective, reflecting Maugham’s own narrative stance.
Art and Life: A Symbiotic Relationship
Maugham's stories often blurred the lines between life and art, particularly evident in "The...
(This entire section contains 871 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
Human Element." Here, the protagonist's interactions with others reveal life's potential for narrative and art’s capacity to illuminate life’s inherent complexities. This interplay becomes a recurring motif in Maugham's oeuvre, where the raw material of life is transformed into art through the prism of narrative.
His approach to storytelling, rooted in personal experience and observed reality, has often been criticized for lacking depth or poetic flourish. Yet, Maugham's detachment and moral tolerance are precisely what afford his narratives their telling power, offering an objective examination of life's paradoxes and absurdities.
Life Reflected in Fiction
Despite his self-characterization as a mere entertainer, Maugham’s work is rich with insights into human nature and the artist's role in society. His own life, marked by its share of personal contradictions and societal judgments, informs much of his fiction. Of Human Bondage, for instance, is an autobiographical exploration of the protagonist Philip Carey's quest for meaning amidst life's inherent compromises and disappointments.
In his later works, Maugham continued to explore the artist's struggle for identity and purpose. The Moon and Sixpence and The Razor's Edge delve into the sacrifices artists make in pursuit of their visions, echoing Maugham's own experiences and internal conflicts. These narratives underscore the tension between societal expectations and personal desire, a theme that resonates throughout Maugham’s literary canon.
Maugham’s literary journey is marked by a keen observation of human behavior, an unflinching realism, and a narrative style that sought to engage rather than instruct. His stories continue to captivate readers with their unadorned truths, reflecting the complexities of life with both empathy and irony.