Analysis
W. P. Kinsella emerged as a literary force later in life, carving a niche with his stories that explore the lives of western Canadian Cree Indians and the mystical allure of baseball. His work garnered critical acclaim and numerous awards, although he is perhaps best known for the film adaptation of his novel Shoeless Joe, released as Field of Dreams. Kinsella's distinctive voice and imaginative storytelling have left an indelible mark on North American literature.
Origins and Influences
Kinsella's narrative style is deeply rooted in an oral storytelling tradition, a skill he honed during his childhood exchanges of tales with his Yugoslavian grandmother. This background instilled in him the ability to captivate his audience, an attribute evident in his diverse body of work. Despite his claim of being a realist who does not believe in magic, Kinsella's stories often contain elements of fantasy and whimsy, striking a balance between the absurd and the profound.
The Cree Nation and Silas Ermineskin
Kinsella's first major literary success came with stories about a young Cree Indian named Silas Ermineskin. Silas serves as the narrator for many of Kinsella's works centered around the Ermineskin Reservation in western Canada. These stories, collected in volumes like Dance Me Outside and The Moccasin Telegraph, and Other Stories, focus on themes of tradition versus modernity, the endurance of native wisdom, and the humor woven into the fabric of Cree life. Kinsella's portrayal of the Cree people has been lauded for its authenticity, though not without its share of controversy.
Silas Ermineskin's World
In the Ermineskin stories, Kinsella employs a voice reminiscent of Mark Twain's Huck Finn, blending a colloquial tone with sharp wit. Silas narrates his tales in broken English, adding a layer of realism and charm. His stories often juxtapose the grim realities of reservation life with the absurdities of modern influences, as seen in the antics of characters like Fencepost Frank and Mad Etta. Through humor and clever storytelling, these narratives address issues such as racism and social injustice.
The Magic of Baseball
Kinsella's other primary focus is the enchanting world of baseball. In novels like Shoeless Joe and The Iowa Baseball Confederacy, he explores themes of faith, dreams, and communal bonds through the lens of America's pastime. Shoeless Joe, which inspired the film Field of Dreams, blends magical realism with a narrative that touches on the loss of innocence and the healing power of belief. His baseball tales often elevate the sport to a near-religious experience, creating a rich tapestry of human emotion and spiritual exploration.
Shoeless Joe
Published in 1982, Shoeless Joe is a novel about Ray Kinsella, an Iowa farmer who transforms his cornfield into a baseball diamond to connect with the ghost of Shoeless Joe Jackson. The story is a journey of faith and redemption, complete with fantastical elements that never overshadow its heartfelt themes. The book’s adaptation into the film Field of Dreams solidified its place in popular culture.
The Iowa Baseball Confederacy
In The Iowa Baseball Confederacy, Kinsella delves deeper into the mystical aspects of baseball. The protagonist, Gideon Clarke, embarks on a quest to uncover a mythical baseball game that challenges the boundaries of time and reality. The novel is a testament to Kinsella's ability to intertwine fantasy with human emotion, creating a narrative that is both whimsical and reflective.
Critique and Controversy
Kinsella's work, while celebrated, has not been without its critics. His baseball narratives, although cherished by fans, have been accused of sentimentality. Similarly, his portrayal of Cree life has faced criticism for perceived inaccuracies or over-sympathies. Despite these criticisms,...
(This entire section contains 965 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
Kinsella’s contributions to literature continue to spark discussion and admiration.
The Brautigans
In homage to writer Richard Brautigan, Kinsella penned a series of surreal stories he termed "Brautigans." These narratives, characterized by their whimsy and visual flair, explore themes of loneliness and societal quirks with a gentle touch. Stories like "Syzygy" and "The Book Buyers" showcase Kinsella’s aptitude for satire and his ability to find humor in the mundane.
“Evangeline’s Mother”
This story delves into themes of loneliness and class disparity. It follows Henry Vold, a man trapped by his own conservative ideals, as he embarks on a journey of self-discovery. Kinsella paints a poignant picture of a man torn between the stability of his well-ordered life and the allure of adventure.
“The Thrill of the Grass”
In this tale, Kinsella uses the backdrop of baseball to explore themes of nostalgia and grassroots activism. Set during a major league baseball strike, it follows a group of fans who restore a stadium's natural grass, symbolizing a return to purity and authenticity in the sport. The story is a testament to the magic and spirituality Kinsella attributes to baseball.
“The Last Pennant Before Armageddon”
This narrative intertwines baseball with apocalyptic imagery. It features Al Tiller, the beleaguered manager of the Chicago Cubs, who faces a divine prophecy about the team’s success. Through Al’s journey, Kinsella explores themes of love, faith, and the human desire to find meaning amidst chaos.
Brother Frank’s Gospel Hour, and Other Stories
In this collection, Kinsella returns to Silas Ermineskin and his comical sidekick, Frank Fencepost. Set against the backdrop of western Canada, these stories explore the duo’s mischief and adventures. Through tales like "Bull" and "Brother Frank’s Gospel Hour," Kinsella examines the intersection of Native Canadian culture and mainstream society with humor and insight.
Legacy of W. P. Kinsella
W. P. Kinsella's body of work remains a testament to his storytelling prowess and his ability to blend fantasy with realism. Whether through the humorous lens of reservation life or the magical world of baseball, Kinsella invites readers into realms filled with whimsy, philosophy, and humanity. His narratives continue to resonate, offering insights into the human condition through the art of storytelling.