Voltaire Mystery & Detective Fiction Analysis - Essay

Voltaire Mystery & Detective Fiction Analysis

(Masterpieces of Fiction, Detective and Mystery Edition)

A first reading of Zadig may suggest that it is inappropriate to consider this “philosophical tale” an early detective novel. Like most of Voltaire’s major works, however, Zadig can be interpreted from several different perspectives, and each critical approach enriches the understanding of Voltaire’s artistry. Readers who favor sociocriticism have analyzed Voltaire’s effective denunciation in Zadig of social exploitation, religious hypocrisy, and intolerance. Although Voltaire called Zadig an “Oriental story” whose action takes place in fifteenth century Babylon, in it, he discusses the social problems of his own era, not those of medieval Babylon, about which he and his contemporaries knew very little. In eighteenth century France, true censorship existed; Voltaire himself had been imprisoned twice in the 1720’s because of his criticism. The pseudo-Babylonian elements in Zadig made it easier for Voltaire to avoid problems with the French police.


The many levels of irony and the refined style in Zadig have attracted much critical attention since the eighteenth century, and several scholars have noted that Voltaire’s style combines formal eloquence with subtle wit. His arguments are presented in such an aesthetically pleasing and yet unpretentious manner that it seems inappropriate to question his sincerity. His very style creates a favorable impression on his readers. In addition, his consistent understatement and the aesthetic distance that he maintains between his third-person narrative and his fictional characters make his philosophical tale appear objective and thus worthy of serious attention. Moreover, his well-balanced sentences permit and even encourage diverse interpretations. Readers of Zadig conclude that Voltaire respects all intellectual freedom; this interpretation leads them to respond favorably to Voltaire’s perception of reality.

In the development of the detective genre, Zadig is important not because of its well-constructed plot and refined style but rather because it illustrates appropriate ways of explaining perplexing situations. In his influential work Les Pensées (1670; Monsieur Pascal’s Thoughts, Meditations, and Prayers, 1688), Blaise Pascal argued that there existed two major ways of perceiving the world. Those who use purely deductive and logical reasoning practice “l’esprit de géométrie” (the spirit of geometry), whereas those who discover truth intuitively practice “l’esprit de finesse” (the spirit of finesse). Voltaire frequently referred to Pascal’s...

(The entire section is 1085 words.)