One Thursday, about eight o’clock in the evening, Candace Whitcomb receives a visit from all the members of the choir in which she has sung for forty years. They bring cake and oranges for what Candace thinks is a surprise party. After they leave, she finds a photograph album addressed to her from her many friends. Inside the album is a letter informing Candace that she has been dismissed from the choir.
Candace is angry at being discarded and at the way in which she was removed. The following spring Sunday is warm, so the little church at which Candace used to sing has opened all its windows. When Alma Way, the new soprano, begins her solo, Candace (whose cottage stands close to the church) begins playing loudly on her parlor organ and singing to drown out Alma’s voice. All the members of the choir rally around Alma after the service to express their anger at Candace and their sympathy for the new soprano. The choir director and minister are particularly solicitous about the new singer and critical of her predecessor.
Reverend Pollard visits Candace to try to prevent any recurrence of such a disturbance. He finds that she is using the photograph album as a footstool, and when he suggests that she inadvertently sang a bit too loud during the morning service, she replies that she did so intentionally. She further informs him that she intends to continue to sing against her rival every Sunday. During that afternoon’s service, Candace...
(The entire section is 511 words.)