Religious Themes
In an era marked by increasing secularism at the dawn of the twentieth century, William James sought to explore the psychological underpinnings of religious experience, particularly within the context of Christianity. He proposed that the neurological and physiological conditions of individuals should not be seen as relevant when assessing their religious experiences. Just as these aspects do not determine the validity of a scientist’s hypothesis, they should not be the basis for evaluating spiritual encounters. Instead, James suggested that religious experiences should be judged on their philosophical soundness and moral utility.
James posited that a person's psychological makeup significantly shapes their unique religious experiences, leading to the diverse spiritual narratives across different cultures and individuals. By examining various accounts of religious experiences, he identified three core beliefs often shared among them. First, there is a notion that the physical world is part of a larger, more spiritual universe, from which it derives its meaning. Second, achieving a union or harmonious relationship with this higher spiritual realm is considered the ultimate purpose of human existence. Finally, prayer or spiritual communion is viewed as a method through which the energy of the spirit influences the material world.
Alongside these foundational beliefs, James noted two prevalent psychological characteristics in those who have profound religious experiences. Individuals often experience a new enthusiasm for life, akin to a newfound gift, and an overwhelming sense of safety and peace. This inner transformation extends outwardly, manifesting as increased affection and love towards others.
The variations in religious beliefs, according to James, lie in the "over-beliefs"—the ways in which these broader spiritual beliefs are specified and related to the cosmos. Despite the inherently individual nature of religious experiences, James argued that they address realities in the fullest sense. These experiences focus not only on personal feelings and destinies but also connect individuals to a broader spiritual narrative, enriching both their inner lives and relationships with the world around them.
Religion
Before delving into the realm of religious experience, James embarks on a quest to define the elusive term religion. He swiftly clarifies that the heart of his lectures pulses not with the institutional framework of religion, but with the intimate, personal experience of it. His gaze is set firmly upon the psychological dimensions of religion, a journey that takes him deep into the psyche of the individual.
In this quest, James emphasizes that his interest is not piqued by the rules and rituals that often shroud religious experience. Instead, he seeks to unravel the tapestry of religious feelings and emotions that reside within the soul. To illuminate this path, he draws upon vibrant stories of acquaintances and the enriching narratives found within literature and autobiography.
James articulates a clear intention to avoid examples from those who merely adhere to the conventional "observances" of their society or comply with the rigid dictates of their church. He is captivated by those who possess what he terms 'original experiences'—the kind of religion that burns not as a monotonous ritual but blazes like an acute fever. With this foundational definition in place, James embarks on an exploration of every facet of personal religious experiences.
Belief
Religious experiences often evoke a profound awareness of an enigmatic force or reality that lingers just beyond the veil of the visible world. This mysterious sensation forms the very foundation of faith. Though it eludes the eye, it instills within the believer a conviction of a hidden, mystical symmetry woven into the fabric of existence. As James eloquently describes, these spiritual encounters ignite a yearning to harmonize with this elusive power, the fountainhead of ultimate goodness...
(This entire section contains 197 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
where all creation finds its balance. According to James, this longing and conviction embody the "religious attitude of the soul." In a broader sense, belief, James asserts, acts as a declaration of "as if." Drawing from the philosophy of Immanuel Kant, he concludes that belief involves embracing certain ideas as though they exist, despite the absence of tangible proof. This very belief is the heart and soul of all religious experiences.
Throughout the examples James presents in his work, his subjects recount spiritual or religious moments that defy logical explanation, yet these experiences resonate with undeniable reality for those who encounter them. Bereft of belief, the edifice of religion would crumble, for it is belief that breathes life into its essence.
Happiness and Depression
Emerging from the shadows of years-long depression, James reflects on this harrowing mental state and its bright counterpart, happiness, through the lens of a profound spiritual awakening. He lauds the famed poet Walt Whitman as the epitome of healthymindedness—a state of harmonious acceptance of life that begets true happiness. For James, this isn’t just about laughter or indulgence. It’s about cultivating a consistently joyful existence, an inner happiness that radiates from within. Whitman encapsulated this in his poetry, conveying a deep-seated love for life. James marvels at how Whitman’s verses brim with a "passionate and mystic ontological emotion" that ultimately convinces "the reader that men and women, life and death, and all things are divinely good."
Nonetheless, James warns of a pitfall in the unwavering optimism of the healthy-minded if they deny the presence of evil. Such excessive positivity blinds them to reality. Those who are overly optimistic dismiss the notion of evil because merely contemplating it is perceived as wrongdoing.
On the opposite end lies the concept of the sick soul, a person who amplifies the presence of evil. James contends that the looming specter of evil and its attendant sorrow cannot be ignored, as even the happiest among us must face mortality. This raises the question of evil’s origin. Is it the handiwork of God, the all-good creator, or does it exist as an immutable part of the whole? Could it be a separate force that humanity can strive to erase? A true healthy-minded person, James argues, hopes for the latter—that evil is not integral to the system and can be eradicated.
For those who perceive evil as an intrinsic part of existence, its influence varies in severity. James notes, "There are people for whom evil means only a mal-adjustment with things," a mere misalignment between one’s life and their surroundings, which is relatively fixable. But for others, the issue is profound. They face "a wrongness or vice in his essential nature, which no alteration of the environment, or any superficial rearrangement of the inner self, can cure, and which requires a supernatural remedy."
Spiritual Enthusiasm
James passionately asserts that a profound sense of joy or exhilaration often accompanies religious experiences. This vibrant excitement acts as a powerful catalyst, enabling the individual to shake off the shackles of depression and melancholy. Life bursts forth with restored meaning and vitality. A profound piety takes root, nurturing a deep-seated desire to be charitable and giving. Confidence surges, bolstering compassion for others, while one’s focus sharpens, allowing earnest pursuit of personal ambitions. Inhibitions crumble away, and the temptations that once strayed one from a saintly path are extinguished, replaced by overwhelming feelings of freedom and bliss.
James gauges religious experience through these intense emotions, or rather, through the lens of the observer experiencing such feelings. He emphasizes that it is not merely the proclamations of finding religion that signify a true religious awakening, but the individual's being, invigorated by powerful emotions, that exemplifies an authentic religious journey.
Pragmatism
The word 'pragmatism' often conjures up notions of practicality and straightforward common sense in everyday language. Yet, the pragmatism that William James introduced transcends this simplistic understanding. James, in fact, crafted this term to elucidate a distinct facet of philosophical inquiry. He envisioned pragmatism as a bridge, using scientific methods to explore the intricacies of thought. In an insightful piece for American Heritage, Louis Menand explains that James proposed a simple yet profound question: "What practical consequences arise from adopting one belief over another?" Through this lens, James aspired to inject a glimmer of faith in God into an era he perceived as dominated by excessive materialism and scientific rationality.
Within the pages of The Varieties of Religious Experience, James skillfully applies the tenets of pragmatism to the question of God's existence. He finds solace in stripping away the abstract philosophical characteristics often ascribed to God, retaining only those attributes that resonate with personal significance. To James, the notions of God's indivisibility, simplicity, superiority, and self-felicity seemed devoid of practical relevance. He pondered aloud, "What meaningful difference does it make to one's faith if these traits are true or not, when they bear no discernible impact on life's tangible experiences?"
