Student Question
Compare the growth and pros and cons of roads, river transportation, and railroads through 1860.
Quick answer:
By 1860, roads, river transportation, and railroads each had distinct growth patterns and advantages. Roads allowed state-to-state travel but were often muddy in winter and required upkeep funding. River transportation, enhanced by steamboats, was cheap but limited by canals and prone to flooding and boiler explosions. Railroads offered the fastest travel but were dangerous, affected by weather, and lacked a unified gauge system, limiting connectivity. Each mode had significant pros and cons affecting their development.
National roads and turnpikes were a popular way to send goods and mail from state to state before the Civil War. They could be traveled on foot or by wagon. They were often impassable in winter as they became too muddy for wagons. It also cost money for their upkeep; it was a hotly contested issue as to who would supply this money, as some believed it to be the responsibility of states while others believed it to be the job of the federal government. Others believed that road users should be responsible for upkeep through paying tolls.
River transportation was reliable only downriver until the creation of the steamboat—which did not depend on river currents. Steamboats could be dangerous however, as boilers exploded, scalding passengers and crew. Without canals, one was limited as to where one could travel using rivers. Rivers also flooded and had to be constantly dredged to remove debris which may snag a vessel. River travel was quite cheap, and if one was using a flatboat, one could not only sell the ship's cargo but the ship as well upon reaching one's destination.
Railroads were the fastest form of travel. Railroads could go wherever track was laid. Rail travel was dangerous, as trains often jumped the tracks or locomotives exploded. Tracks could also become impassable in winter due to snow and ice. Rail gauges varied from line to line, meaning that a train was limited as to where it could go—there was no nationwide network.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.