Uncle Silas Critical Evaluation
by Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu

Start Your Free Trial

Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Download Uncle Silas Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Uncle Silas is more than a sentimental, nineteenth century story of the designing uncle and the lovely heir driven nearly insane by terror. It is a well-constructed novel, rambling in the Victorian fashion but highly effective in the mechanics of atmosphere and of suspense. In fact, Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu protested against his novels being labeled as examples of the sensational school of fiction popularized by Wilkie Collins and Charles Reade. In his view, his fiction was a continuation of the type of tragic romance exemplified in The Bride of Lammermoor (1819) and other novels by Sir Walter Scott. The fact remains that readers have never deserted Le Fanu, and this novel represents his fiction at its best. Most notable is his handling of character and scene as they are sometimes seen in old Dutch paintings, with certain figures prominently in the foreground, others in the middle distance, and still others in the background. All are clearly visualized, however, and busy with whatever happens to be at hand. Uncle Silas and Madame de la Rougierre are creatures of terror in the foreground, but equally relevant are Dudley Ruthyn, Dr. Bryerly, Lady Monica, Milly, and Meg Hawkes, figures successively removed from the center of the action but no less necessary for the atmosphere and plot.

Uncle Silas may well represent the supreme achievement in the development of the gothic novel of terror. In the leisurely pace of its early chapters, the careful, thorough delineation of the setting and the atmosphere, the ornate, sensuous prose style, the use of traditional gothic devices, and the creation of a sinister larger-than-life villain, Uncle Silas resembles the earlier masterpieces of “Monk” Lewis, Ann Radcliffe, and Charles Maturin. Nevertheless, the directness and the simplicity of the action; the sharpness, the subtlety, and the psychological accuracy of the characterizations; and the carefully controlled first-person point of view all point to the sophisticated, economical modern suspense or crime novel.

The heroine of the book, Maud Ruthyn, is not particularly sympathetic; she is intellectually unimpressive, emotionally erratic, frequently snobbish, and occasionally haughty. She is, however, an excellent narrator. The reader sees everything through her eyes, and her fears become the reader’s fears, but since her judgments are frequently inaccurate or incorrect, readers often see her danger and understand her mistakes long before she does. Like many gothic heroines, Maud realizes her precarious situation only after she misses the opportunity to escape from it. It is primarily through her growing sense of desperation and panic, accompanied by a gradual, belated understanding of her plight, that Le Fanu develops the reader’s own sense of impending doom.

As is often the case with gothic novels, the bad characters are more impressive than the good ones. The conspirators complement one another’s particular villainies. Even the minor scoundrels, Dudley Ruthyn and “Pegtop” Hawkes, are sharply defined individually, whereas the major villains, Madame de la Rougierre and Uncle Silas, are two of the most memorable characters in the entire genre.

From the start, the governess is a dominating, grotesque, and foreboding presence. While Silas remains in the background, Madame de la Rougierre hovers over Maud, “gobbling and cackling shrilly” with her exaggerated French manners, her crude physical gestures, her effusive expressions of concern, all performed in such an overwrought and clearly hypocritical fashion that even Maud detects the conspiracy behind her actions. Her sudden reappearance in the secret room at Bartram-Haugh is one of the novel’s greatest shocks.

It is, however, Silas Ruthyn who remains the novel’s most vivid image....

(The entire section is 910 words.)