Style, Form, and Literary Elements

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Style and Technique

Amy Tan's literary work is deeply influenced by her immersion in both Chinese and American cultural narratives. Drawing inspiration from Maxine Hong Kingston’s memoir, The Woman Warrior, and Louise Erdrich’s novel, Love Medicine, Tan crafts stories that intricately weave together personal and cultural histories. Her narratives explore the interplay of memory and identity, showcasing how the past and present are inextricably linked.

Memoir and Memory

In "The Joy Luck Club," Amy Tan presents a mosaic of interrelated stories, each resonating with distinct voices and perspectives. The story "Two Kinds" stands out as a microcosm within this collection, employing a narrative style that seamlessly transitions between childhood innocence and adult reflection. This dual perspective enriches the narrative, allowing readers to delve into the complexities of memory and its influence on current perceptions.

The oscillation between a child's naive curiosity and an adult's reflective insight invites readers to engage with the evolving mother-daughter relationship at the heart of "Two Kinds." This technique not only captures the fluid nature of memory but also encourages readers to derive their own interpretations of the events unfolding in the story. Tan deftly illustrates that memories are not static records; they are dynamic constructs crafted through the act of storytelling, which in turn shapes our understanding of identity and personal experience.

Literary critic Ben Xu provides further insight into this narrative approach, suggesting that memory functions as a complex narrative construct. Xu argues, "images," "pictures," and "views" coalesce into stories that define our sense of self. These stories go beyond mere reflections of past events, transforming them into experiences imbued with deeper meaning. "Memory," according to Xu, "serves as an experiential relation between the past and the present, projecting a future as well.” Thus, narrative form becomes an essential tool for interpreting the intricacies of human life.

The Art of Talk Story

In contrast, the Chinese mothers in Tan’s stories express their experiences through the traditional "talk story" method. This narrative approach, deeply rooted in Chinese folklore, serves as a vital link between their cultural heritage and their present-day realities. It allows the mothers to articulate their life experiences and convey cultural wisdom to their daughters.

According to E. D. Huntley, talk story is "a narrative strategy for those characters whose ties to Chinese tradition remain strong.” This method enables characters to employ traditional oral forms, embedding their narratives with cultural significance and urgency. Through talk stories, life events are reframed in culturally resonant ways, turning personal struggles into folk tales, warnings into wise aphorisms, and life experiences into mythic expressions.

For characters like Jing-mei’s mother, talk story is not merely a stylistic choice but a necessary form of communication shaped by cultural and societal constraints. Her stories are public narratives, articulated in a manner that adheres to socially acceptable norms. This approach highlights the cultural and generational divide between the mothers and daughters, often resulting in moments of tension and revelation when unvarnished truths are revealed, such as Jing-mei’s blunt confrontation with her mother's past. The talk story thus becomes a vital narrative device, bridging cultural gaps and preserving the richness of heritage while navigating the complexities of modern identity.

Expert Q&A

What is the tone of the opening paragraph of "Two Kinds"? How should the second paragraph be interpreted? What insight does the third paragraph provide into Jing-mei's mother's faith in America?

In “Two Kinds,” the opening paragraph has a mixed tone of hope, naiveté, and greed. The first paragraph suggests that the reader interpret the second paragraph with this prior understanding of Jing-mei’s mother's perception of the American Dream. While the mother seems to hold blind (and greedy) faith in America, the third paragraph provides insight into her tragic past. The reader then understands why the mother carries these beliefs and ambitions for Jing-mei.

What effect does the mother's broken English and Chinese expressions have in "Two Kinds" dialogue?

The mother's broken English and use of Chinese expressions in "Two Kinds" highlight her immigrant background and cultural disconnect with American society. Her speech creates a realistic and vivid character portrayal, emphasizing the generational and cultural gap with her American-born daughter. It also adds humor through her directness and determination, underscoring her resolve to succeed in America despite language barriers.

What is the tone of the story "Two Kinds"?

The tone of "Two Kinds" changes from excited and hopeful to bitter and contemptuous.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Analysis

Next

Historical and Social Context

Loading...