Themes: The Consequences of Deception
Disguise and deception abound throughout Twelfth Night. The characters who disguise themselves and deceive others each have their own motives and designs, but the result is nearly always confusion.
Viola’s motives for disguising herself as Cesario remain unclear. Perhaps she feels safer in a strange country disguised as a young man, but her deception leads to a long line of confusion as Olivia actually falls in love with Viola—or, rather, she falls in love with Viola’s disguise. Viola herself has feelings for the Duke but cannot express them. When Sebastian arrives in Illyria, the bewilderment deepens as several characters mistake Sebastian for Cesario. This error even leads to injury when Sir Andrew challenges Viola (as Cesario) but actually strikes Sebastian, who fights back without hesitation. Olivia, too, thinks that Sebastian is Cesario and goes through a betrothal ceremony with the wrong person. Even Antonio feels the sting of Viola’s deception when he mistakes Cesario for Sebastian and believes that his friend has betrayed him.
Olivia carries on her own deception when she sends her ring after Cesario at their first meeting, claiming that she is returning it to him. Her motive is to draw him back, because she is attracted to him, yet she does not realize that she is being caught up in Viola’s deception and fooled by her disguise.
Even Feste disguises himself as the priest Sir Topas when he participates in the prank on Malvolio. As Sir Topas, Feste tries to convince Malvolio that he is indeed mad or even possessed and that he is not in a dark house but in a bright room filled with windows. The deception here is cruel, and Feste violates the limits of propriety by pretending to be a priest, for a priest’s role is to care for a person’s spiritual needs, not try to drive him insane. Only Malvolio’s stubborn perseverance saves him from descending from confusion into true madness.
Throughout the play, these various forms of deception result in layers of confusion. While these confusions are often experienced by the characters as causes for alarm, they drive the play’s comedic arc and amuse the audience, who can appreciate the dramatic irony that underlies much of the action.
Expert Q&A
What are three types of deception in Twelfth Night?
Three types of deception in Twelfth Night are Viola posing as Cesario, Maria's letter to Malvolio, and the duel. Viola's disguise leads to romantic complications. Maria's letter tricks Malvolio into thinking Olivia loves him, resulting in his humiliation. The duel, orchestrated by Sir Toby and Fabian, pits Sir Andrew against Cesario (Viola), creating further chaos and confusion.
The role of mistaken identity in Twelfth Night
Mistaken identity plays a central role in Twelfth Night, driving the plot and creating comedic situations. Viola disguises herself as Cesario, leading to romantic misunderstandings and confusion among characters. This theme explores issues of gender, identity, and love, ultimately resolving in multiple revelations and reconciliations, highlighting the fluidity and complexity of human relationships.
The contrast between appearances and reality and its contribution to the comedy in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night
In Twelfth Night, the contrast between appearances and reality contributes to the comedy through mistaken identities and disguises. Characters like Viola, who disguises herself as a man, create humorous situations and misunderstandings. This duality drives much of the play's plot and humor, as characters navigate through their misconceptions and the eventual revelation of true identities.
Mistaken Identities and Comedy in Twelfth Night
Mistaken identities and comedic conflicts play a crucial role in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, contributing to its success as a comedy. The use of dramatic irony, cross-dressing, and romantic entanglements creates humor and intrigue. While the play fulfills the comedic requirement of romantic resolutions with couples like Sebastian and Olivia, and Viola and Orsino, some characters, like Malvolio and Antonio, remain outside the "happy ending," highlighting unresolved conflicts and adding complexity to the comedic narrative.
The theme of self-deception in Twelfth Night
The theme of self-deception in Twelfth Night is prevalent as characters often deceive themselves about their own identities and desires. Viola disguises herself as a man, leading to a series of mistaken identities and romantic entanglements. Malvolio convinces himself that Olivia loves him, showcasing his delusions. These deceptions drive the plot and highlight the folly and complexity of human nature.
The significance and utilization of disguise and false communication in Twelfth Night
In Twelfth Night, disguise and false communication play crucial roles in advancing the plot and exploring themes of identity and love. Characters like Viola disguise themselves, leading to mistaken identities and comedic situations. These elements also highlight the fluidity of gender and social roles, ultimately revealing deeper truths about the characters and their relationships.
What similarities make Sir Andrew Aguecheek and Malvolio easy to trick in Twelfth Night?
Sir Andrew Aguecheek and Malvolio are easy to trick in "Twelfth Night" due to their distinct forms of gullibility. Malvolio's arrogance leads him to believe in his own superiority, making him susceptible to the notion that Olivia loves him. In contrast, Sir Andrew's gullibility stems from his lack of intelligence and naivety, as he is humble and overly trusting of his friends. These traits make both characters prime targets for deception.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
