Discussion Topic

Tuck and Winnie's Concerns About Home in Tuck Everlasting

Summary:

In Tuck Everlasting, the Tuck family is concerned about taking Winnie home because she knows their secret of immortality and the spring's location. They fear she might reveal this or be tempted to drink from it herself. Winnie ultimately decides to stay home, realizing she values the security and protection it offers. The Tucks’ immortality is seen as both a burden and a curse, influencing Winnie's decision to reject eternal life.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why is Tuck concerned about taking Winnie home in Tuck Everlasting?

It isn't only Angus Tuck that is concerned about taking Winnie home.  The entire Tuck family is concerned about taking her home.  The reason that they are concerned about taking her home is that Winnie has discovered their secret.  She knows that the Tuck family is immortal, and she knows how they became immortal, and she knows the location of the spring that gave them their immortality.  The Tucks are concerned about what Winnie might do with such knowledge.  They don't want their secret to get out, because they understand that creating a world full of people that can't die is ultimately a bad decision.  They also don't want Winnie being tempted to drink from the spring herself.  The Tucks absolutely want her to know the dangers that the spring represents before letting her go back to her life. 

"We got to take you home with us. That's the plan. Tuck—he'll want to talk it out, make sure you see why you can't tell no one. But we'll bring you back tomorrow. All right?" And all three of them looked at her hopefully.

[...]

"I'll take you home. I promised I would, soon's we've explained a bit as to why you got to promise you'll never tell about the spring. That's the only reason we brung you here. We got to make you see why."

[...]

"Hush," Tuck interrupted. "Everyone hush. I'll take Winnie rowing on the pond. There's a good deal to be said and I think we better hurry up and say it. I got a feeling there ain't a whole lot of time."

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What makes Winnie decide to stay home in Tuck Everlasting?

Winnie realizes that, in actuality, "there's nowhere else (she) really (wants) to be" other than home. When it comes right down to it, she is afraid to go off on her own. She thinks,

"It's one thing to talk about being by yourself, doing important things, but quite another when the opportunity arises."

Through the characters that she reads about in books, and because of the constant warnings of her family, Winnie knows that the world is a dangerous place. She just feels that she "would not be able to manage without (the) protection" and security of home and those she loves. Although

"no one ever said precisely what it was that she would not be able to manage...she did not need to ask. Her own imagination supplied the horrors."

In essence, running away sounded really good to Winnie the day before, when she was so frustrated and angry at being an only child and the sole focus of her parents' and grandmother's constant nagging, but when she finally had an opportunity to make good on her resolve to run away and live life on her own terms, she found that she could not, because she was afraid.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why is Tuck concerned about taking Winnie home?

Jessie understands that at times his immortality is both a blessing and a curse.

Immortality comes with a great burden: those who are mortal die eventually, and Winnie would have to leave her family behind as well.  She would be frozen at her present age, like the Tucks always worried that they would be recognized and found out.  They need to protect their secret and protect themselves, so Winnie realizes that she does not want the life that Jessie offers.

"But ultimately the Tucks are terminally bored and perhaps a bit boring. They have forever, but because each of their days is essentially identical to the last, they, in effect, have nothing. Although Jesse does attempt to convince Winnie to join him in eternal life, his parents make it clear that their situation is far more of a burden than a blessing."

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial