True at First Light

by Ernest Hemingway

Start Free Trial

Literary Techniques

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The Intricacies of "True at First Light"

Embarking on a discussion of the techniques within True at First Light requires an immediate note of caution: this is a narrative sculpted from an unfinished manuscript, its boundaries reshaped posthumously and its essence compacted without the author’s guiding hand. Any insights into Hemingway's methodologies may require reevaluation once another rendition of this work emerges, as plans for a more complete edition are underway. Yet, one can still delve into the intricacies of Hemingway's point of view, particularly how he navigates the fragile terrain between autobiography and fiction, or reality and invention. Critical engagement must stem from the acknowledgment that this is not merely a "journal," an unadorned chronicle of past events. Nor should it be hastily branded a "fictionalized memoir," despite previous labels. Perhaps the most fitting description comes from the editor, who deemed it "a fiction," emphasizing the nuanced interplay of truth and imagination that pulses at the core of this memoir—a characteristic arguably inherent in all memoirs.

Recognizing Hemingway's Signature Techniques

Those acquainted with Hemingway's prior masterpieces, such as In Our Time and The Sun Also Rises, will undoubtedly recognize his hallmark craftsmanship: modernist allusions, landscapes imbued with symbolism, and the art of understatement—a testament to his "iceberg theory" and his commitment to omission. His adept use of repetition, dualities, and rhythmic modulation harkens more to the realm of poetry than conventional prose. Hemingway's work, True at First Light, is a treasure trove of literary allusions, inviting readers to engage deeply to uncover veiled references and explore the rich tapestry woven from echoes of Dante, D. H. and T. E. Lawrence, Orwell, and Virgil. The landscapes he paints, or paysage moralise, carry historical and spiritual significance, layered with meaning that beckons readers into the profound depths of the narrative. Set in the formidable shadow of Kilimanjaro, the Deus Loci, or Spirit of Place, permeates the entire book, as readers are reminded of its potent symbolism in "The Snows of Kilimanjaro," recognized as the "House of God," the ultimate journey of the soul.

Evolution of Hemingway's Narrative Style

While Hemingway's signature techniques and stylistic choices remain a constant throughout his oeuvre, some readers might perceive in True at First Light a subtle relaxation of his typically stringent narrative economy. He ventures into territories once merely hinted at, discussing themes like religion with newfound candor and expansiveness. Such openness could lead some to surmise that Hemingway has set aside his "iceberg theory," opting instead to bring all elements to the narrative forefront, rather than letting them resonate unseen below the surface. Yet, it remains plausible that this work is firmly rooted in Hemingway's enduring principle of omitting pivotal truths; notably, the book subtly foreshadows the infamous plane crashes that nearly claimed his life shortly after the events depicted. These near-death encounters, though unspoken, cast a long shadow over the novel, influencing every moment within its pages.

Ideas for Group Discussions

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Embark on insightful discussions by intertwining comparisons of works that share similar threads: memoirs or fiction rooted in reality. Delve into the challenges faced by a 'foreigner' or 'outsider' embracing a foreign culture with love, celebrating it despite not being native-born. Explore themes of pursuit and adventure, religious undertones aspiring for inclusivity, the enduring shadows of colonialism, and the essence of solidarity within diverse societies.

Understanding "Fiction" in True at First Light

1. How does one perceive True at First Light as "fiction" when real characters dwell within its pages and actual events unfold? Where does the spark of creative imagination ignite within this process?

Literary Influences and Comparisons

2. Engage in background...

(This entire section contains 389 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

reading and discussion surrounding works that inspired Hemingway's African narratives (see Literary Precedents). Contrast how other authors depicted similar themes: the African wilderness, colonial legacies, and interracial dynamics.

Hemingway’s African Experience

3. Contrast Hemingway's portrayal of Africa and its inhabitants across his various African-themed works (see Related Titles).

4. What stirs Hemingway’s admiration for Pop (Philip Percival)? Enumerate Pop's qualities and the values he represents, perhaps juxtaposing with his earlier depiction in Green Hills of Africa.

Exemplars and Ethical Codes

5. Identify at least four exemplars in True at First Light. Do they uphold the same virtues and ethics? What insights does this "code" offer regarding conduct and life choices?

The Quest for the Lion

6. Examine Miss Mary's pursuit of the lion and her particular approach. Reflect on the broader reasons for hunting presented in the novel. In light of these discussions, argue for or against the prohibition of hunting.

Hemingway's "New Religion"

7. Dissect the principles of Hemingway's "new religion." Evaluate his seriousness about this concept and his views on Protestantism, Catholicism, and Islam.

Sense of Place and Landscape

8. Contemplate Hemingway's portrayal of the landscape and his profound connection to Africa. Why is he so deeply moved by the African terrain, particularly Mount Kilimanjaro?

Style and Technique

9. Explore Hemingway's stylistic nuances: a) identify quotations within the text; b) discover the authors and works he alludes to and how these references deepen passage interpretations; c) analyze elements like syntax, rhythm, repetition, metaphors, and dialogue, noting their impact.

Life Influencing Fiction

10. Unearth details of Hemingway's life, particularly his African experiences. Compare and contrast his real life with the book narrator's portrayal. What conclusions emerge about the interplay between autobiography and fiction?

Social Concerns

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The "African Book" and Its Foundations

This intriguing work, whether you classify it as a novel, a fictional memoir, or a nonfiction narrative, emerges from the careful posthumous curation of an unfinished manuscript penned by Ernest Hemingway in the mid-1950s. Left incomplete and unpublished upon Hemingway's passing in 1961, the manuscript, often referred to by scholars as the "African Book," was later shaped and titled True at First Light by the author's son, Patrick Hemingway. Published as a resounding finale to the year-long Hemingway Centennial in 1999, it stands as a poignant exploration of pressing social themes, despite its incomplete nature and posthumous revisions. These themes include the intricate dynamics of race and tribal identity amid the gradual decline of colonialism in Africa; humanity's interplay with nature, addressing environmental dilemmas and the moral quandaries of hunting; the complexities of marriage within social and tribal frameworks; and the examination of various ethical, moral, and religious codes through the book's often lighthearted yet occasionally solemn "new religion" theme.

A Journey Through Africanization

Ernest Hemingway himself takes center stage as both narrator and protagonist. From his unique vantage point as an acting game warden in the heart of Kenya, he extends an invitation to readers to delve into what has been termed the "Africanization of Hemingway." This journey encourages a departure from simplistic racial labels, urging an authentic embrace of Africa's tribal intricacies. Throughout this transformative process, the narrator critically examines colonialism while acknowledging the honor and dignity of select British colonials. He humorously critiques affluent European and American tourists, whose conventional safaris starkly contrast with his own big-game pursuits. Furthermore, he vividly portrays the racial and religious diversity of Kenyan Africa, navigating the complex web of tribal and religious identities, including Masai, Kamba, Kikuyu, Mau Mau, Christian, Moslem, Sikh, Animist, and more, alongside the roles of Americans, Asians, and Europeans in Africa.

Rooted in Love and Identity

Hemingway's embrace of Africa is deeply rooted in his love for a specific corner of the continent—Kenya, with its awe-inspiring proximity to the Mountain-God Kilimanjaro. His integration into local tribal life unfolds as he becomes a hunter, friend, comrade, and a partner in both revelry and the "new religion" he establishes with his tribal companions. His tender courtship of his tribal fiancée, Debba, underscores his profound attachment to this land he is reluctant to leave. Hemingway's reflections on race dismiss it as a mere abstract classification, emphasizing instead the value of tribal camaraderie based on shared place and behavior. As Miss Mary, Hemingway's fourth wife and a key character, insightfully remarks, "One of the basic points of the faith as I gather it is that neither Papa nor I are white." Hemingway's identity transcends traditional racial boundaries, embracing an American Indian and African Kamba persona. Toward the book's conclusion, when Ngui, one of his tribal brothers and fellow "new religion" adherents, inquires about his prayers, Hemingway responds with: "Africa for Africans. Kwisha Mau Mau. Kwisha all sickness. Rain good everywhere. Happy Hunting Grounds." Here, "kwisha" signifies "it is finished." Hemingway's heartfelt prayer calls for the cessation of colonialism and violence, a desire for health and prosperity for all, and a longing to remain in the Africa he cherishes.

Ecological Reflection and Responsibility

Hemingway's narrative also delves into his unique brand of environmentalism, addressing the role of hunting and the conservation of both wildlife and land. His reflections on the appropriate relationship between humans and animals, as well as between human settlements and the untamed wilderness, echo throughout the novel. Early in the story, Hemingway, who refrained from hunting elephants and detested the practice, contemplates these matters in his capacity as acting game warden:

I was always depressed by this part of the forest. The elephants had to eat something and it was proper that they should eat trees rather than destroy the native farms. But the destruction was so great in proportion to the amount they ate from the trees they pulled down that it was depressing to see it. Elephants were the only animal that were increasing steadily throughout their present range in Africa. They increased until they became such a problem to the natives that they had to be slaughtered. Then they were killed off indiscriminately. .. . There had to be some sort of elephant control. But seeing this damage to the forest and the way the trees were pulled down and stripped and knowing what they could do in a native Shamba in a night, I started to think about the problems of control.

The Lion's Hunt and Ethical Considerations

The quest for Miss Mary's lion propels much of the book's plot and action. As game warden, Hemingway assumes the responsibility to eliminate any marauding lion that threatens livestock and human settlements. This contemplation leads him to ponder the "difference between a wild lion and a marauding lion and the type of lion tourists take pictures of in the National Parks. ... Picture lions that are accustomed to being fed and photographed," lions that when they wander from protected areas where they have "learned not to fear human beings are easily killed by alleged sportsmen and their wives. But our problem," Hemingway concludes, "was not to criticize how other people had killed lions ... [but to] find and kill an intelligent, destructive and much hunted lion in a way that had been defined if not by our religion [then] by certain ethical standards."

Hunting and Duty

Indeed, the interplay of duty and ethics underpins much of the hunting depicted in the narrative. Here lies another illustration of Hemingway's nuanced tone regarding the notion of hunting as a solemn obligation:

On that particular afternoon, shortly after indulging in lunch, we embarked on the task of baboon management. Our mission was to curb the baboon population to safeguard the Shambas. In order to neither dishearten nor provoke those who adore these creatures, I shall refrain from sharing explicit details. As fortune would have it, by the time I reached them, the daunting creatures, with their menacing fangs, lay in eternal silence.

Hunting: A Matter of Necessity

Hemingway encapsulates his hunting experiences with this reflection: "The era of shooting animals for mere trophies was a thing of the past for me. My passion for shooting and executing a clean kill remained undiminished. Yet now, my shots were reserved for securing the sustenance we required, to support Miss Mary, and in defense against creatures condemned for valid reasons—be it for control of marauding animals, predators, or pests."

Moral Dilemmas of the Hunt

When the duties and ethics guiding a game warden's role are considered, the remainder of the hunt can be encapsulated under the theme of sustenance and enigma. "It's wicked to kill things," Mary remarks. "Yet how marvelous it is to have quality meat in camp. When did meat become so paramount to everyone?" Hemingway answers, "It always has been. It's among the most ancient and crucial elements. Africa is starving for it. However, if they hunted indiscriminately as the Dutch did in South Africa, none would remain." Beyond the necessity of meat lies a deeper enigma: "We were all born hunters, and it heralded the beginning of that magnificent pursuit, the hunt. There's a wealth of mystic nonsense penned about hunting, yet it likely predates religion itself. Some are born hunters, and some are not."

Marriage and Social Concerns

Among other societal issues is the exploration of marriage through Hemingway's depiction of his bond with his spouse Mary and his tribal betrothed, Debba. Perhaps if Hemingway had completed the book, the cross-cultural nuances of marriage might have been further elaborated upon. Nonetheless, even in its current form, the portrayal of Ernest and Mary's union—with its competition, cruelty, and jealousy—what the narrator describes as the "incalculable casualties of marriage"—balanced by their endeavors to love genuinely and profoundly, represents Hemingway's most intricate examination of matrimony. Finally, the overarching and profound social issue, encompassing all facets of behavior—social, ethical, moral, and religious—is embodied in Hemingway's "new religion" motif, most aptly addressed under the umbrella of themes.

Literary Precedents

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

A Tradition of African Narratives

The chronicles of Africa penned by American and European authors, whether unfolding as memoirs or fiction, boast a storied tradition. When asked about the literary influences that shaped this genre, Patrick Hemingway, son of the legendary writer, pointed to Olive Schreiner as a trailblazer. Schreiner, a 19th-century South African writer, gained acclaim with her celebrated work, The Story of an African Farm. A pioneer in her own right, Schreiner was the first colonial African author to gain widespread fame, revered for her vivid portrayals of the continent’s people and terrain, and her relentless advocacy for women's rights and the liberty of Africans under colonial rule.

Another luminary in this realm is Isak Dinesen, the literary guise of Denmark's Karen Blixen, who immortalized her Kenyan experiences in the highly praised Out of Africa (1937). Hemingway was acquainted with the Blixens, with her husband featuring in his writings, and he held Out of Africa in high esteem. Patrick Hemingway further highlights Doris Lessing, whose "so-called Martha Quest novels" are cited as influential on his father's work. Lessing's early novels intricately explore the dynamics of white-black relations and the shadows of colonialism on African soil. Hemingway was likely familiar with these influential works, including The Grass is Singing (1950) and the initial Martha Quest stories, Martha Quest (1952) and A Proper Marriage (1954). Patrick Hemingway affirms that these formidable women writers left an indelible mark on his father's own African endeavors, shaping a daunting literary landscape for him to contribute to.

Influences and Inspirations

In addition to these literary giants, readers should contemplate other significant works like Teddy Roosevelt's African Game Trails. From a young age, Hemingway admired Roosevelt, and undoubtedly, he was well-versed with African Game Trails. Notably, Hemingway's chief muse for his African narratives, Philip Percival, had once guided Roosevelt through Africa's wilderness. Another influential figure was Beryl Markham, whose 1942 memoir West With the Night Hemingway lauded as "really a bloody wonderful book." Intriguingly, one of Hemingway's close companions in True at first Light, Arap Meina, shares his name with the guide who escorted Markham on her hunting adventures in West With the Night. Thus, Hemingway was intimately familiar with his literary forebears in the domain of African storytelling.

Hemingway's works reflect his diligent scholarship and insatiable appetite for knowledge. Those who seek to truly appreciate his narratives must embark on their own journey of discovery, much like Hemingway himself did, to unlock the depth of his African stories.

Previous

Characters

Loading...