Troilus and Criseyde Critical Essays

Troilus and Criseyde, the only long work completed by Geoffrey Chaucer, is based on the legend of the Trojan War. The characters, however, behave in the best tradition of the medieval romance. Chaucer, an incomparable teller of tales and a great poet, combined his two talents to create this perfectly constructed narrative poem. The effective depiction of character and its development in this work forecasts the shrewd observations of human nature Chaucer would make in the prologue to The Canterbury Tales (1387-1400).

Troilus and Criseyde is a paradox of artistic creation. At once both medieval and modern, it holds vast problems of interpretation yet pleases with its wit, style, comedy, and humanity. The work cannot be dated with complete certainty, but certainly by that point in his career, Chaucer—diplomat, man of letters, public official, and onetime prisoner of war—already had a literary reputation, which the appearance of Troilus and Criseyde did nothing to diminish. Chaucer’s contemporary reputation, in fact, probably rested with this poem at least as much as with the later and much-loved Canterbury Tales. It was certainly Chaucer’s Troilus and Criseyde, more than any other poems that addressed the same subject matter, that later poets used as a source for their own works. The fifteenth century Scottish poet Robert Henryson, for example, wrote of Criseyde’s ignoble end in The Testament of Cresseid (1532), and William Shakespeare tried his hand at the story with Troilus and Cressida (pr. 1601-1602, pb. 1609).

Chaucer himself found the story in Giovanni Boccaccio’s Il filostrato (c. 1335; The Filostrato, 1873); possibly Chaucer was working from an intermediate source—Le Roman de troyle et de creseida by Beauvau. The story itself derives from the Trojan legend, but Troilus and Criseyde are such minor figures in Homer’s story (and never meet there) that it is apparent that Chaucer had more in mind than the simple retelling of a classical tale.

Much of the discussion in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries about Chaucer’s purpose in writing the poem focused on the palinode, that is, the concluding section of about one hundred lines, in which the narrator repudiates the courtly love that has governed the action of the lovers for more than eight thousand lines. Subsequent criticism has focused on Chaucer’s attitude toward love in general, on...