Themes: Justice
In Trifles, the theme of justice is explored through the lens of gender roles and societal expectations. The play examines the concept of justice not only as a legal principle but also as a moral and ethical one. The women in the play, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters, grapple with the idea of justice as they uncover evidence of Minnie Wright's motive for killing her husband. Their decision to conceal this evidence highlights the conflict between legal duty and personal empathy, raising questions about what true justice entails.
The play is set against the backdrop of a patriarchal society where women's roles are confined to domestic spheres. The men in the play, including the County Attorney and the Sheriff, dismiss the women's world as insignificant, referring to their concerns as "trifles." This dismissive attitude is evident when the County Attorney says, "I guess before we're through she may have something more serious than preserves to worry about," and Hale adds, "Well, women are used to worrying over trifles." This belittlement underscores the men's inability to see the importance of the domestic sphere, where the evidence of Minnie's motive is found.
The women's discovery of the dead bird, a symbol of Minnie's lost happiness and freedom, becomes a pivotal moment. The men overlook this crucial evidence, focusing instead on finding a motive through more conventional means. The women's empathy for Minnie and their understanding of her plight lead them to protect her by hiding the evidence. Mrs. Peters initially adheres to the law, stating, "the law has got to punish crime," but her perspective shifts as she empathizes with Minnie's situation. She realizes that the legal system, dominated by men, may not deliver true justice for Minnie.
The play ultimately questions the nature of justice. Is it merely the enforcement of laws, or does it encompass a deeper understanding of individual circumstances? Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters' decision to conceal the evidence reflects their belief that the legal system would not provide Minnie with a fair trial. They recognize the normalization of male violence and the lack of empathy within the legal system. By the end of the play, their actions suggest that justice, in this context, is about protecting Minnie from further injustice rather than adhering to the letter of the law.
Expert Q&A
Motivations and Ethics Behind Concealing Evidence in Trifles
In Susan Glaspell's play, "Trifles," Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters conceal evidence of Minnie Wright's motive for murdering her husband due to their empathy for her plight and recognition of her abusive marriage. They find a dead canary, indicative of her husband's cruelty, and choose not to reveal it, understanding it would be dismissed by the male authorities as a mere "trifle." Ethically, their actions can be debated, but they reflect a critique of gender roles and societal failure to protect women from domestic abuse.
In Trifles, do individuals have the right to follow their moral beliefs in conflict with state law?
The play Trifles presents the moral dilemma of whether Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale should have turned over the evidence they found against Mrs. Wright. The play does not, however, solve the dilemma. Some readers might decide that it is right for the women to follow their consciences. Others might determine that the law should take priority.
In Trifles, what does the phrase "the law has got to punish crime" signify?
The phrase "the law has got to punish crime" reflects Mrs. Peters' initial belief in a strict, binary view of justice where the law rectifies wrongdoing. Initially, she resists tampering with evidence, emphasizing adherence to legal norms. However, as she learns about Minnie's hardships, her perspective shifts, recognizing the inadequacy of the law in addressing deeper issues of justice. Mrs. Peters' journey highlights the complexities of justice beyond legal confines.
In Susan Glaspell's "Trifles," was Mr. Wright's murder resolved?
In "Trifles," Mr. Wright's murder remains unresolved within the play. The women, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters, discover crucial evidence suggesting Minnie Wright killed her husband, likely in response to his oppressive behavior. They find a strangled bird, indicating a motive linked to Minnie's isolation and loss. However, they choose not to reveal their findings to the men, who dismissively overlook the women's insights as mere "trifles." Thus, the murder mystery stays unsolved officially.
How does Susan Glaspell justify the final decision in Trifles?
Susan Glaspell justifies the final decision in "Trifles" by portraying Minnie Wright as a victim of her husband's oppression, gaining audience sympathy for her. Through Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale, the play reveals Minnie's transformation from a vibrant woman to one oppressed by John Wright, likened to a caged bird. This metaphor, highlighted by the discovery of a dead bird, compels the audience to empathize with Minnie, validating the women's choice to hide evidence of her motive.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
