Tooth and Claw
In ten novels and six previous collections of short fiction, T. Coraghessan Boyle has established himself as one of America’s most imaginative and entertaining writers. He is especially noted for his breezy colloquial style, his satire of American fads and movements, and his dark sense of humor. His most enduring character type is the young, white, American male, a kind of loose cannon who speaks in his own voice, reveals his various shortcomings (which usually involve alcohol, drugs, or sex), and as often as not becomes his own worst enemy. Boyle’s women characters, in contrast, tend to be intrepid and resourceful, showing few signs of ever having been repressed. These trademark attractions continue in Tooth and Claw, and Other Stories, Boyle’s seventh collection of short stories, all of which have been previously published in leading magazines. Some of these fourteen stories push the imaginative horizon far afield, ranging to other continents or centuries, examining relationships with other creatures, or taking dark humor to the verge of tragedy.
The collection gets off to an appropriate start with “When I Woke Up This Morning, Everything I Had Was Gone,” which has a generic quality about it. The story, like two or three of the others, is set in a bar, specifically the bar at Jimmy’s Steak House. The unnamed male narrator meets another man at the bar who seems to have been drinking nonstop for weeks or months. They introduce themselves, the other man consulting a sign for the bar and saying, “Just call me Jimmy.” “Jimmy” then tells the narrator a horrific story that explains why he is drinking like a fish: His college-age son died in a fraternity hazing incident, forced to consume too much alcohol and then choking on his own vomit. The next week, the narrator meets another man in the same bar who he thinks is Jimmy’s brother. The other man has another sad story to relate, this one about an alcoholic old woman, a family friend, who froze to death outside his front door. The narrator is a good listener to these twin tales of woe, but meanwhile he is nursing his own wounds. Despite its different strands, the story holds together remarkably well, the parallels, the generic name Jimmy, and the unifying elements of drink and the bar suggesting a common suffering humanity, even if, ironically, somewhat self-pitying and maudlin.
Other stories provide variations on these motifs. A number of stories feature sad sacks, men who have been around for a while but seem not to have gained much wisdom from their years. For example, another man who ends up crying in his scotch is Robbie Baikie, a big, hulking Unst Islander in “Swept Away”: “The light of the westering sun . . . laid the glowing cross of our Saviour in the precise spot where Robbie’s shoulder blades conjoined. He heaved a sigh thena roaring, single-malt, tobacco-inflected groan it was, actuallyand finally those massive shoulders began to quake and heave.” Robbie’s crucifixion comes from falling in love with a visiting American woman, an eager ornithologist who has near-perfect legs, face, and figure. He is saved from being swept away with her in a storm but not from the storm of remembrance that racks him daily as he “sits even now over his pint and his drop of whisky in the back nook at Magnuson’s.”
Robbie, the Shetland sheepman, is not as simple as some of the sad sacks in the other stories. In “The Kind Assassin,” Boomer, a struggling disc jockey at KFUN, lets himself be talked into an on-air publicity stunt even...
(This entire section contains 1632 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
sillier than his radio personatrying to break the world’s sleep-deprivation record. When he sets a new record, he cannot understand that the quest was only hype and, like Franz Kafka’s hunger artist, wants to keep going. The biggest believer in hype, however, is Jackson Peters Reilly, a divorced snowbird who, in “Jubilation,” buys property in an expensive central Florida housing development allied with a theme park. To market itself, the housing development draws on typical theme-park fantasies, using cartoon characters such as Gulpy Gator and Chowchy and giving its home models names such as Casual Contempos, Little Adobes, and Courteous Coastals. Jackson not only adopts the development’s terminology but soon is trying to enforce its code restrictions on his neighbors. Reality, nonetheless, has a way of asserting itself, here in the form of mosquitoes, hurricanes, and other hazards of nature.
Still another group of stories centers on young men who are even dumber and hence dangerous to themselves and others. In the final story, “Up Against the Wall,” recent college graduate John Gaddis moves back in with his parents (always a comedown). He finally finds a job in a miserable ghetto school teaching eighth-grade English but, to forget his daily battle, also gets involved with drugs and a bad crowd. When his mother saves him by confronting him with incriminating tape recordings, he feels trapped like his father, his life over. He could have ended up like Raymond, the homeless young man in “Here Comes” who is a slave to alcohol, who sees his homeless friends brutally murdered, and who crawls back to beg his disgusted girlfriend, who threw him out, to take him in again.
Another problem with these young men is that they are out to prove themselves and impress people, especially young women. In “All the Wrecks I’ve Crawled Out Of,” which begins with the line “All I wanted, really, was to attain mythic status,” young Lester brags throughout about his “wrecks both literal and figurative, replete with flames, blood, crushed metal and broken hearts, a whole swath of destruction and self-immolation, my own personal skid marks etched into the road of my life and maybe yours too.”
In “The Swift Passage of the Animals,” young Zach sets off for a weekend getaway at a mountain lodge with Ontario, a young divorcé he met three weeks before. Zach, who fancies himself a risk-taker, decides to impress her by taking a winding back road during a blizzard. Unfortunately, he proves to be like one of those animals on which Ontario is an expert, who became extinct through their stupidity. For the survival of the species, she gets a separate room at the lodge.
Animal behavior is also the focus of the collection’s title story, “Tooth and Claw.” Again, the story begins in a bar, where James “Junior” Turner, to impress the onlookers and especially Daria the waitress, is drawn into a game of Horse for a wild cat, an African serval. He wins, to the delight of Daria, who accompanies him home. “So,” he thinks proudly, “I had a cat. And a girl.” The phrasing has an ominous symbolic equivalence that reverberates through the rest of the story. What the wild cat does to his bedroom, where they turn it loose, is pretty much what Daria does to him. He begins to think of her as “a prime mover” in his life, but she spends only a couple of nights with him, announces that she has a regular boyfriend away at college, and says goodbye. He is left with a ripped-up bedroom and a raging wild creature with whichat the story’s endhe comes to identify and tries to set free.
Animals play an important role in still other stories from the collection. Besides the ornithologist who is for the birds, a woman in “Dogology” is going to the dogs and entices a married neighbor, fittingly named Julian Fox, to accompany her. She is a graduate student whose thesis has been rejected by her committee, and she is determined to show them up with a groundbreaking study of dogs from the dogs’ perspective, running with the pack on all fours, howling at the moon, and helping protect the den. In separate sections of the story, her behavior is paralleled with that of wolf children from 1920’s India. Like Boyle’s epigraph from Charles Darwin and his title Tooth and Claw, the connections between humans and animals in these stories point to an underlying Darwinian nature of existence.
The ultimate Darwinian scenario is played out in “Chicxulub,” which describes the extinction of dinosaurs caused by an asteroid or comet striking the earth. This earth-shaking event is used in the story as a metaphor for parental loss of a child, but the literal fact that such cosmic events could happen at any time and wipe out civilization is a bit rattling. However, in “Blinded by the Light” Boyle takes a similar premise and uses it to comic effect. Here “the sky is falling” in the form of cancer-causing rays coming through a hole in the ozone layer at the South Pole, or so says American expert John Longworth, Ph.D. He is preaching to Patagonia, Chile, whose proximity to the South Pole puts it in imminent danger. When he messes with the daughter of a Patagonian sheep rancher who comes after him with a gun, the expert temporarily puts his campaign to save the world on hold. Boyle’s ability in these two stories to take a similar premise and argue it both ways is a measure of how he can stretch his imagination.
These two stories and others in the collection, such as “The Doubtfulness of Water: Madam Knight’s Journey to New York, 1702,” also show that Boyle does his research. The factual information in the stories, such as the big words Boyle sometimes slips in, rings true. His ability to insert himself and his readers into his settings, however remote, and to participate in the lives of his characters, however bizarre, shows that he can take almost any factual information and run with it the way a writer of fiction should.
Bibliography
Booklist 101, nos. 19/20 (June 1, 2005): 1711.
Entertainment Weekly, September 16, 2005, pp. 94-95.
Kirkus Reviews 73, no. 12 (June 15, 2005): 650-651.
Library Journal 130, no. 12 (July 1, 2005): 74.
The New York Times Book Review 154 (September 11, 2005): 8.
The New Yorker 79, no. 34 (November 10, 2003): 106-115.
Publishers Weekly 252, no. 26 (June 27, 2005): 37.