Themes: Moral Complexity
Over the course of the novel, Scout and Jem come to understand that people cannot be easily categorized as good or evil. Initially, Scout and Jem naively assume that most of the people in Maycomb are objectively “good.” This assumption is soon challenged, however, by the racism and hypocrisy they witness during Tom Robinson’s trial. With Atticus's help, Scout and Jem come to learn that while the people around them aren't perfectly moral, it does not then follow that these people are irredeemably “evil.” Mrs. Dubose, “the meanest old woman who ever lived,” regularly yells abuse at Jem and Scout as they walk by her house. It is only after her death that they learn that she was struggling to overcome a morphine addiction, determined to die on her own terms. The revelation of Mrs. Dubose’s unexpected bravery leaves Jem and Scout more empathetic and slower to judge those around them.
From the very beginning, Atticus works to convince Scout of the potential for good in people—despite their “blind spots.” His optimism proves correct when Scout is able to successfully dispel a lynch mob by making innocent small talk with its leader. These teachings ultimately shape Scout’s perspective, allowing her to adopt a more nuanced view of those around her. This personal transformation is evident in Scout's observations of Mayella Ewell at the trial. Though she believes that Mayella’s actions are reprehensible, Scout is also able to recognize that Mayella Ewell has lived a hard, sad life: “Mayella Ewell must have been the loneliest person in the world.” Scout’s heightened empathy allows her to see flawed individuals like Mayella as complex people who are worthy of human dignity and understanding despite having done terrible things. By the end of the novel, it's clear that Atticus’s teachings have successfully prepared Scout and Jem to confront the evils of mankind without losing their faith in the goodness of humanity.
Expert Q&A
Mr. Underwood's Editorial and Its Connection to the Title
Mr. Underwood's editorial in To Kill a Mockingbird connects Tom Robinson's unjust death to the novel's title by comparing it to the senseless killing of songbirds. He emphasizes it is a sin to kill innocents, like cripples or mockingbirds, highlighting Tom as a symbolic mockingbird—harmless and undeserving of his fate. This reflects the broader theme of racial prejudice, where Tom, a black man, was unfairly convicted and killed due to societal biases.
Dill's Reaction to Tom Robinson's Trial in To Kill a Mockingbird
In To Kill a Mockingbird, Dill's reaction to Tom Robinson's trial reveals his sensitivity and moral integrity. During the trial, Dill becomes physically sick and cries due to Mr. Gilmer's disrespectful and racist treatment of Tom, which contrasts with Atticus's respectful questioning. Dill's emotional response underscores his innocence and empathy, highlighting the injustice of racial prejudice. His reaction not only impacts the plot by deepening the themes of racial injustice and loss of innocence but also influences Jem and Scout's perspectives on morality and justice.
What is the irony in the statement, "You are a fortunate girl. You live in a Christian home with Christian folks in a Christian town" in To Kill a Mockingbird?
The irony in Mrs. Merriweather's statement is that Maycomb does not embody Christian values. Despite identifying as Christians, the community openly discriminates against African Americans, as evidenced by the unjust verdict against Tom Robinson. True Christian principles, such as equality and love, are ignored, making Mrs. Merriweather's comment hypocritical and highlighting the town's racial injustice and prejudice.
Which thesis statement for a paper on To Kill A Mockingbird is better and how can it be improved?
1. "Encounters with injustice shape beliefs of morality by exposing its true wickedness."
2. "Justice is behavior or treatment that is morally right or fair. Encounters with injustice shape beliefs of morality by exposing its true wickedness. When we see something happen that we know and can feel just isn't right, we have to do something about it."
The first thesis statement is too vague, while the second is too wordy. A strong thesis should be clear, precise, and concise. Improving the first thesis by relating it to specific characters, such as Scout and Jem, can enhance clarity and relevance to To Kill a Mockingbird. A revised thesis could be: "By showing the injustice done to Tom Robinson through the eyes of Scout and Jem, the novel illustrates how injustice shapes a young person's morality."
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.