Illustration of a bird perched on a scale of justice

To Kill a Mockingbird

by Harper Lee

Start Free Trial

Chapter 17 Summary and Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Heck Tate's testimony starts with him being questioned by Mr. Gilmer, the prosecutor. He relates the events of the day in question: Bob Ewell came to find him on November 21st of the previous year and brought him back to the house, where Mayella had been beaten up. She said it was Tom who beat her, so Heck went to arrest him. When Atticus cross examines him, more details come out: Heck didn't call a doctor, despite the severity of Mayella's injuries; Mayella had a black eye on her right side; and there were finger marks around her throat where she'd been choked. This is the end of Heck Tate's testimony.

Next, Bob Ewell takes the stand, looking to Scout like "a little bantam cock of a man" ("bantam" meaning chicken). Scout takes the time to explain that the Ewells live in a ramshackle little home down by the dump, with a fence made out of random bits of things they've pulled from the dump while looking for food. Their house isn't as nice, in Scout's opinion, as the cabins that the African American citizens live in, though these are also situated right next to the dump. It's understood in this chapter that Bob Ewell's drinking is the cause of his family's poverty and that he's not a man worth respecting, but that they're all listening to his testimony because he's white and is accusing a Black man of rape.

Once Mr. Gilmer starts questioning him, Ewell goes into a sensationalized account of the rape he says he saw. This is, of course, a lie, which Atticus will prove later, but it's dramatic enough that the audience erupts and Judge Taylor has to bang his gavel for five minutes to call them down. In an effort to keep them quiet without having to close the courtroom off to spectators, he threatens all of them with contempt charges. The trial continues, with Judge Taylor and Mr. Gilmer asking some clarifying questions. Then Atticus cross examines him, beginning again with questions that focus on Mayella's injuries. He then has Ewell write his name to show that he is left-handed, and, therefore, capable of having given Mayella a black eye on her right side. Jem thinks that this will be enough to prove Tom innocent. Scout isn't so sure.

Conflict

Atticus vs. Bob Ewell. It's safe to say that Bob Ewell has conflicts with everyone: his daughter, Atticus, Tom, and just about everyone else in the courtroom. His behavior on the stand makes a mockery of the court, and his obvious lies bring him into conflict with Atticus, who has no respect for him. One could argue that Bob Ewell's conflicts all stem from the fact that he thinks he deserves to be respected when he doesn't.

Metaphor. One example of this would be Scout saying that Ewell is "a little bantam cock of a man," where the word "bantam" means a certain breed of chicken.

Motifs

Flowers. When Ewell writes out his name, Scout says Judge Taylor looks at him as if he were a "gardenia in bloom." This picks up on the flower imagery established through Miss Maudie's character and neatly (if briefly) dehumanizes Mr. Ewell, whose behavior has been pompous or "flowery" in the sense that it has been flamboyant. Note that Mayella Ewell is also said to have grown several red geraniums in jars, a fact that is meant to endear her to the reader.

Repetition

One example of this would be the repetition of the word no in the passage that reads: "No truant officers could keep their numerous offspring in school; no public health officer could free them from congenital defects…"

Simile

One example of this is Scout saying that Mr. Gilmer can make a "rape case as dry as a sermon," where "dry" means boring.

Themes

Boredom. Unlike the boredom Scout and the children have experienced in previous chapters where they ran out of games to play during the summer, the boredom in this chapter comes as a result of the trial not being as exciting as the spectators originally expected it to be. They want to be entertained by the trial, and when it isn't immediately thrilling, they get restless. This boredom wanes at the end of the chapter when Ewell starts putting on a show.

Law. When Atticus starts questioning Ewell, Ewell accuses Atticus of trying to trick him. His outburst doesn't reflect well on him, but isn't entirely off the mark: as Scout points out, Atticus is adept at asking questions to get the answers he wants and avoiding the ones he doesn't. The law, though a righteous and formidable thing with the capacity to do great good in the world, is also something that can be manipulated or used to manipulate, as when it's used unfairly against Tom Robinson.

Violence. The violence in this chapter is indirect, related to us on the witness stand rather than in scene. We learn from Heck Tate's testimony that Mayella Ewell has accused Tom of raping her and that Bob Ewell claims to have witnessed this act of violence. Though we'll soon find that Tom never raped Mayella, the sensational nature of the case and the presence of the spectators makes the violence seem especially lurid.

Expert Q&A

In Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, what do we indirectly learn about the Ewell family's home life?

In Chapter 17, we indirectly learn that the Ewell family lives in extreme poverty and squalor, with their home located by the town dump and held together by scavenged materials. The family lacks education and a stable structure, with suggestions of incest and abuse. However, Mayella Ewell's care for her geraniums indicates a desire for beauty amidst their grim living conditions.

Why does Atticus ask if a doctor was called for Mayella in chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird?

In chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus repeatedly asks Mr. Tate and Mr. Ewell if they called a doctor for Mayella to show that no medical evidence exists to prove she was raped, which supports his argument that Tom never committed the crime. Additionally, Atticus reveals that Mr. Tate did not believe Mayella was internally injured. As sheriff, Mr. Tate's analysis and decision hold weight. Atticus's questions also portray Bob Ewell in a negative light as an unconcerned, dismissive father.

In chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, what does Scout mean by "I thought Jem was counting his chickens"?

In chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, when Scout says "I thought Jem was counting his chickens," she means Jem is being overly confident about Atticus's success in proving Tom Robinson's innocence. Jem believes Atticus's argument about the attacker being left-handed is irrefutable, while Scout remains cautious, recognizing that Tom could still be found guilty despite the evidence.

Which literary device does the author use in Chapter 17 of "To Kill a Mockingbird" to describe Bob Ewell?

In Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, the author uses a metaphor to describe Bob Ewell as a bantam rooster. This comparison highlights Ewell's small physical size but feisty and combative demeanor, creating strong imagery of his false bravado and aggressive posturing.

What is ironic about Bob Ewell's comment about black families in Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird?

The irony in Bob Ewell's comment about black families devaluing property is that his own home is adjacent to a garbage dump, making it one of the least valuable properties in Maycomb. Additionally, the Ewells are notorious for their poor hygiene, antisocial behavior, and overall way of living, which devalues the community far more than the presence of black families ever could.

What are three characteristics of the Ewells in Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird?

In Chapter 17, the Ewells are depicted as impoverished, living on welfare near the town dump, scavenging for necessities. Their home is filthy, reflecting their dire conditions, with children suffering from diseases due to poverty. Bob Ewell is abusive, forcing Mayella to accuse Tom Robinson falsely, and is described as arrogant, embodying the "white trash" stereotype in Maycomb. The children are neglected and uneducated, as illustrated by their lack of school attendance.

In Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, why does Atticus repeatedly ask Heck Tate to clarify his court testimony?

Atticus Finch repeatedly asks Heck Tate to clarify his testimony to ensure accuracy regarding Mayella Ewell's injuries. He emphasizes whether the injuries were on the left or right side of her face, which is crucial for his defense strategy. Atticus wants the court record to reflect that Mayella's right side was bruised, a detail that becomes significant in later chapters when questioning Bob Ewell and Tom Robinson about the assault.

In To Kill A Mockingbird, chapter 17, why does Atticus ask Bob Ewell if he can write and what is he trying to prove?

Atticus asks Bob Ewell if he can write to demonstrate that Bob is left-handed, suggesting he could have inflicted Mayella's injuries. Mayella's bruises were on the right side of her face, indicating a left-handed attacker. This evidence challenges the accusation against Tom Robinson, who is unable to use his left hand due to an injury. Atticus aims to cast doubt on the Ewells' testimony, highlighting the racial bias in the jury's eventual guilty verdict.

In chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird, why does Reverend Sykes ask Jem to take Dill and Scout home from the trial?

Reverend Sykes asks Jem to take Scout and Dill home from the trial due to the mature and inappropriate content being discussed. The trial involves graphic and disrespectful language, particularly from Bob Ewell, who uses crude terms to describe the alleged crime. Reverend Sykes aims to protect the children's innocence and shield them from hearing such degrading language, as it is not suitable for their age.

What impression does Tate give in Chapter 17 of To Kill a Mockingbird through his recounting and Atticus's cross-examination?

Tate's testimony in Chapter 17 is pivotal as it inadvertently supports Atticus's defense strategy by highlighting that Mayella was beaten on the right side of her face, suggesting a left-handed assailant. This information casts doubt on Tom Robinson's guilt, given his disability. Tate's recounting helps Atticus demonstrate that others in the courtroom, like Tate, also possess moral integrity. This testimony implicates Bob Ewell, potentially positioning him as Mayella's true attacker.

Show another question (3 questions hidden)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Chapter 16 Summary and Analysis

Next

Chapter 18 Summary and Analysis

Loading...