Chapter 16 Summary and Analysis
This chapter marks the beginning of Tom Robinson's trial, which will be the primary focus of the narrative for the next five chapters. The action picks up where it left off in Chapter 15, with Jem, Scout, and Atticus heading home and then having a somber breakfast the next morning. It seems like the entire town is on the way to the courthouse to watch the trial. Some overzealous Baptists passing by Miss Maudie's house criticize her flowers for being sinful, but Miss Maudie criticizes the zealots right back. In town, Dill sees Dolphus Raymond (a white man) drinking from a paper bag and sitting with the African Americans, and Jem explains that this is just Dolphus's way. We will see more from him later.
The kids refrain from going to watch the trial until after lunch. Atticus had spent the morning in voir dire, or jury selection, so when they finally arrive the trial is just starting. The courthouse is so packed that they end up sitting in the balcony with Reverend Sykes and the African American community that has come to support Tom. On the way to their seats, Scout overhears that Atticus has been appointed by the court to defend Tom, meaning that he's required to (a fact he neglected to tell the kids, though that would've made it easier for them to defend him to his detractors). For this reason, many of the people in the courthouse don't begrudge his defending Tom, though they worry that Atticus is actually going to try to prove Tom's innocence. This seems inappropriate to them. Any other lawyer would've let Tom go to the chair.
Scout spends some time describing the courthouse's architecture (eclectic and disjointed) before moving on to describing the jury and the spectators. Judge Taylor, who sits as the bench looking like a shark with his pilot fish (stenographer) writing around him. She tells an amusing little tale about Judge Taylor throwing out a frivolous lawsuit pitting the Cunninghams vs the Coninghams (their nominally different relations), then adds that Judge Taylor had a way of chewing dry cigars down to nothing. Then Heck Tate takes the stand, and the trial truly begins.
Allusions
Ecclesiastes 6:4. In the King James Version of the Bible, the full verse reads: "For he cometh in with vanity, and departeth in darkness, and his name shall be covered with darkness." Those zealots who drive by Miss Maudie's house allude to this verse to suggest that Miss Maudie's is letting her vanity about being a great gardener get in the way of her faith and her piety. She snaps right back at them with another Bible verse that drives them away.
Proverbs 15:13. In the King James Version of the Bible, the entire verse reads: "A merry heart maketh a cheerful countenance: but by sorrow of the heart the spirit is broken." Miss Maudie quotes the first half of this verse to the zealots who criticize her gardening and, in so doing, effectively tells them not to look so sour and judgmental.
William Jennings Bryan (1860 - 1925). An American statesman from Nebraska famed for his skill as an orator. He's perhaps best known for his "Cross of Gold" speech, in which he argued that the gold standard was halting progress in America and preventing the economy from growing. Miss Stephanie Crawford alludes to him to suggest that the crowd heading to Tom's trial is disproportionately large, given that Tom is not as famous or important as someone like William Jennings Bryan.
Motifs
Fire. In Chapter 8, when Miss Maudie's house burned to the ground, "fire" was a menacing image and threatened to destroy all of the houses on her block. Since then, fire has become associated with Miss Maudie and her garden, which is "ablaze with summer flowers." Fire in this instance is not an image of destruction but rather one of beauty, energy, and vitality. Even though the fire burned down Miss Maudie's house, she was able to rebuild it as she liked, making it more beautiful than before. Thus, the fire motif is both about destruction and renewal.
Swimming. In keeping with Scout's description of Atticus appearing to move like an underwater swimmer in Chapter 10, here she described Judge Taylor as an old, sleepy shark with his pilot fish swimming around him. This characterizes him as a big, lumbering, powerful man and emphasizes how slow his movements are (though, as we'll soon find, his mind is actually very quick).
Puns
Scout may be making a pun when she describes Judge Taylor as "a sleepy old shark," where the word "shark" is often used pejoratively to refer to lawyers.
Simile
One example of this would be Scout saying Judge Taylor looks "like a sleepy old shark."
Themes
Racism. This is most obvious in the fact that the African Americans are segregated to the balcony and not allowed to sit on the main floor of the courthouse along with the white people. It's also clear, just from the conversation that Scout overhears, that Atticus is the only reason Tom's getting a decent defense. If not for him, he'd be shafted and have no chance in court. It's implied through this that African Americans don't have the same legal protections that white people do and that racism has been systematized in Alabama to the point where any African American on trial is assumed to be guilty before the trial even begins.
Expert Q&A
Why doesn't Miss Maudie go to court in chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird and what is Atticus's role in the trial?
Miss Maudie does not attend the trial because she finds it morbid to watch Tom Robinson fight for his life and views the event as a disturbing spectacle. She is a compassionate person who supports Atticus Finch's defense of Tom. Atticus's role in the trial is to valiantly defend Tom Robinson, despite knowing the racial prejudices of the jury make a fair trial unlikely. His efforts highlight the racial injustice in Maycomb.
In To Kill a Mockingbird, chapter 16, what do the Idlers' Club members' views reveal about the town's values compared to Atticus'?
The Idlers' Club members' views in Chapter 16 highlight the contrasting values between Maycomb's townspeople and Atticus Finch. While the town generally disapproves of Atticus's commitment to defending Tom Robinson, believing he should not put much effort into defending an African American, Atticus is determined to provide a strong defense. This reveals Maycomb's racial prejudice and reluctance to challenge the status quo, contrasting with Atticus's principles of justice and equality.
What quote from Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird represents "conflict as an opportunity for change"?
In Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird, Dolphus Raymond's story illustrates "conflict as an opportunity for change." After his bride committed suicide due to his interracial relationship, Dolphus became estranged from Maycomb's white community. This conflict led him to embrace his relationship with his African American mistress and their "mixed" children, challenging societal norms. His change is further highlighted when he sympathizes with Dill, recognizing the injustice faced by black people, as shown in his later quote about racial inequality.
Explain the paragraph about the Coninghams and Cunninghams in chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird.
The paragraph about the Coninghams and Cunninghams in chapter 16 is meant to be humorous and confusing. It describes a perplexing court case involving two poor, intermarried families from Old Sarum. The confusion over land ownership arose from misspelled names, leading Judge Taylor to dismiss the case as "champertous connivance," implying the families were absurdly collaborating for personal gain.
Why was Mr. Underwood prepared to defend Atticus with a rifle in Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird despite his prejudice?
Mr. Underwood, despite his prejudice, is prepared to defend Atticus with a rifle because he values justice and the rule of law. Although he despises African Americans, he believes in a fair trial and opposes the lynch mob's attempt to bypass the legal process. Underwood's commitment to truth and justice, as demonstrated by his later editorial lamenting Tom Robinson's death, underscores his moral obligation to report honestly to the community.
What does "struck" mean in the context of describing the jury in chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird?
In chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird, "struck" refers to the process where a lawyer removes a juror deemed unable to be fair and unbiased. This reflects the social dynamics of Maycomb, where townspeople, often white and educated, are struck from jury duty, leaving mostly farmers. This selection process hints at systemic biases, as lawyers may prefer jurors more susceptible to prejudice, reflecting broader themes of racism and injustice in the novel.
What is the meaning of this excerpt from Chapter 16 of To Kill A Mockingbird?
"Aunt Alexandra sipped coffee and radiated waves of disapproval. Children who slipped out at night were a disgrace to the family. Atticus said he was right glad his disgraces had come along, but Aunty said, 'Nonsense, Mr Underwood was there all the time.'"
This excerpt highlights a familial disagreement about the children's actions the previous night. Aunt Alexandra disapproves of Jem, Scout, and Dill sneaking out, considering it disgraceful. Atticus, however, appreciates their presence, as it helped diffuse a potentially violent situation with a mob outside the jail. Aunt Alexandra counters that Mr. Underwood was already watching over Atticus, suggesting their presence was unnecessary. This exchange underscores differing views on family conduct and bravery.
What does "out to the Quarters" mean in Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird?
"I don't think it's a good habit, Atticus. It encourages them. You know how they talk among themselves. Everything that happens in this town's out to the Quarters before sundown."
The phrase "out to the Quarters" refers to information spreading to the Black community's residential area, possibly former slave quarters, outside Maycomb. Aunt Alexandra expresses concern about discussing racial matters in front of Calpurnia, fearing gossip. She embodies the town's hypocritical racism by wanting to maintain appearances. Atticus, however, trusts Calpurnia and is aware that the Black community already knows about Underwood's racism, highlighting his irritation with Alexandra's prejudices.
What is the allusion to Tensaw Jones in Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird?
The allusion to Tensaw Jones in Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird refers to his staunch support for the Prohibition Party, indicating his strict temperance beliefs. This detail, shared by Jem during the trial's crowd scene, highlights the diverse and eccentric characters of Maycomb, including Jones, Miss Emily Davis, Mr. X Billups, and Dolphus Raymond.
In Chapter 16 of To Kill a Mockingbird, what's ironic about Scout’s observation of the "little man on the witness stand"?
Scout's observation of Bob Ewell in Chapter 16 is ironic because she notes that the only thing making him "better" than his Black neighbors is his white skin, despite his dirtiness. This is ironic because, despite societal beliefs that white skin signifies superiority, Ewell's moral character is deeply flawed. His actions, including abuse and false accusations against Tom Robinson, reveal that he is not better than his neighbors, underscoring the hypocrisy of racial prejudice.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.