Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

The Tin Flute is Gabrielle Roy’s first and best-known novel. Considered by many critics to be one of the greatest works of French Canadian literature, it won numerous prizes, including Canada’s prestigious Governor-General’s Award and France’s distinguished Prix Femina. Roy began her writing career as a journalist. Her meticulous description of the St. Henri slum in Montreal is based on her observations for a series of journal articles she wrote about the social and economic crises generated by the city’s growing industrialization.

Roy’s novel is especially important in the development of French Canadian fiction because it marks a turning point in the depiction of the province of Quebec, which had been portrayed by earlier writers as rural, traditional, and inward-looking. By contrast, The Tin Flute, whose English title is taken from the name of a child’s toy—symbolizing the repressed longings of deprived people—presents a grittily realistic panorama of urban life with the dilemmas that threaten to overwhelm French Canadians at a transformative time—when Canada was emerging from the economic hardships of the Great Depression and plunging into the global turmoil of World War II. Critics of the work have especially praised Roy for her capturing of the stark contrast between the poor, decaying environment of Montreal’s French Canadian slum and the orderly, manicured world of the city’s Westmount district—a district inhabited by the affluent Anglophone bankers and industrialists who helped to build the socioeconomic system that has oppressed Quebec’s working classes.

The power of Roy’s storytelling in The Tin Flute springs chiefly from the direct narrative style used to portray the characters and their environment. The sights, sounds, and smells of the places where the protagonists play out their emotional lives—neighborhood streets, restaurants, stores, bars, houses, and churches—are portrayed with near-clinical detail and with striking, evocative imagery. The narrative follows a conventional linear plot structure that traces the stories of individuals in a chronological...

(The entire section is 881 words.)