In evaluating who is a worse husband between Luke O'Neill from The Thorn Birds by Colleen McCullough and Jalil Khan from A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini, we must consider their actions and the context of their relationships.
Luke O'Neill in The Thorn Birds is portrayed as a pragmatic and often selfish character. He marries Meggie Cleary not out of love but for convenience and economic benefit. Luke is primarily interested in amassing wealth and is indifferent to Meggie’s needs and desires. He leaves her in a difficult situation while he works elsewhere, showing little concern for her emotional well-being. His lack of emotional support and neglect make him a poor husband.
Jalil Khan in A Thousand Splendid Suns is not a husband in the traditional sense in the novel, but he is a father whose actions deeply affect his daughter Mariam. Jalil is a wealthy man who initially appears loving but ultimately places social appearances over his daughter's well-being. When Mariam seeks him out, he rejects her, leading to a series of events that drastically shape her life. Although Jalil later expresses regret, his failure to stand by Mariam causes significant trauma.
When comparing the two, Luke O'Neill's neglect and self-centeredness in his marital relationship with Meggie make him a worse husband in the traditional sense. Jalil Khan's role is more about his failure as a father, which indirectly affects marital dynamics later in the story. Both characters exhibit significant flaws, but Luke's direct actions as a husband are more detrimental to his spouse's immediate well-being.
The AI-generated response tries to compare these two men as husbands, but the role of Jalil Khan in A Thousand Splendid Suns is that of a father to Mariam. The appropriate comparison of husbands would be between Luke O'Neill and Rasheed.
We know little about Khan as a husband other than he lives a polygamous lifestyle and takes advice from his wives regarding how he should treat his daughter Mariam.
Here is my answer, which compares the two main husbands of these novels, Luke O'Neill and Rasheed.
The question contains a premise error, as it asks to compare Luke O'Neill from "The Thorn Birds" with Jalil Khan from "A Thousand Splendid Suns" as husbands. However, Jalil Khan is not primarily depicted as a husband in Hosseini's novel - he is Mariam's father. The main husband character in "A Thousand Splendid Suns" is Rasheed, who marries both Mariam and later Laila.
If the question intends to compare Luke O'Neill with a husband character from "A Thousand Splendid Suns," the appropriate comparison would be with Rasheed.
Luke O'Neill in "The Thorn Birds"
Luke marries Meggie Cleary primarily for economic gain. He:
- Marries Meggie for her inheritance and labor value
- Consistently prioritizes his desires for wealth over her needs
- Neglects her emotionally and physically, leaving her isolated on a sugarcane plantation while he works elsewhere
- Denies her sexual fulfillment
- Shows little interest in their daughter Justine
- Treats Meggie essentially as property rather than a partner
Rasheed in "A Thousand Splendid Suns"
Rasheed is depicted as:
- Physically and emotionally abusive to both his wives
- Controlling and restricting their movements and interactions
- Violent when his expectations aren't met
- Cruel and demeaning, particularly after Mariam's miscarriages
- Willing to starve his wives as punishment
- Eventually, he attempts to kill Laila, which leads to his death
Comparative Assessment
Both men are terrible husbands, but they represent different types of marital cruelty:
- Luke's abuse is primarily negligence, exploitation, and emotional abandonment
- Rasheed's abuse is direct, violent, and deliberately controlling
Rasheed would generally be considered the worst husband due to the extreme physical violence and control he exerts, culminating in attempted murder. Luke's neglect and exploitation are deeply harmful, but not as immediately life-threatening as Rasheed's brutality.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References