The Thorn Birds Analysis
by Colleen McCullough

Start Your Free Trial

The Thorn Birds

(Literary Masterpieces, Volume 18)

Download The Thorn Birds Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Drogheda, a 250,000-acre sheep station in the Australian Outback, dominates Colleen McCullough’s The Thorn Birds, giving the novel a center and a resting place. Although its numerous characters, most of them members of the clannish Cleary family, leave Drogheda for various reasons—to travel, to marry, to go to school or work or war—they all return to the sprawling ranch with its numerous water tanks (enough, it is said, to keep its lawns green through a ten-year drought), its yellow sandstone house, and its abundance of wisteria, bougainvillea, and roses. Constantly subjected to natural disasters, including monsoonal rains, droughts, fires, and too many rabbits, Drogheda’s resources and its vitality are apparently unlimited. So are Meggie Cleary’s. Meggie is celebrating her fourth birthday when the novel opens; when it closes, she is in her fifties. Beautiful, intelligent, and stubborn, she illustrates the theme suggested by the novel’s title. According to Celtic legend, a particular bird intentionally impales itself on a thorn and, in the process of dying, sings a beautiful song. McCullough makes it all too clear that the legend’s central idea is also that of her book: “the best is only bought at the cost of great pain,” but human beings repeatedly choose both the best and the pain. As Meggie puts it, “We create our own thorn, and never stop to count the cost.” While there is nothing intrinsically lamentable about this theme, McCullough’s handling of it is annoyingly explicit. Not only does she announce her main idea before her story begins; she returns to it repeatedly at crucial points in the action. In the concluding paragraph she makes Meggie reflect, “I did it all to myself, I have no one else to blame. . . . We, when we put the thorns in our breasts, we know. . . . And still we do it.”

But even this explicitness does not keep us from becoming interested in McCullough’s characters, and especially in Meggie herself. Despite repetitious references to the heroine’s “lambent” gray eyes and her “goldy” hair—one soon begins to imagine her on the cover of a Harlequin romance—we sympathize with her immediately. In the novel’s first pages, the Clearys are living in New Zealand. Meggie, the only girl among six children, receives for her birthday a new doll, which she must defend against the irreverent curiosity of her older brothers. Soon thereafter she starts school, where she must endure not only unfair canings by her teacher, but also the horror of catching lice from her best friend and the resulting humiliation of having her long “goldy” curls cut off and her head shaved. These early incidents firmly establish Meggie’s character: she is loving, loyal, and stubbornly brave, and she must surely suffer.

When the Clearys leave New Zealand to go and live at Drogheda, the sheep station owned by Meggie’s Aunt Mary, the child’s prospects appear to improve. Drogheda offers security, steady work for her father and brothers, and the friendship of the tall, elegantly handsome parish priest, Father Ralph de Bricassart. Father Ralph is attracted at once by Meggie’s beauty, although when they meet she is only nine years old; from that moment he is her friend and protector. At the same time, as Ralph observes Meggie’s responses to an emotionally turbulent confrontation between her father and her favorite older brother, to the death of her baby brother, and to the deepening indifference of her stoical mother, he sees in her a maternal strength and a profound capacity to endure suffering, and these qualities too he finds fascinating. Until Meggie reaches adolescence, Father Ralph can successfully ignore the implications of his feelings for her; but when, at seventeen, she asks him whether he would marry her were he not a priest and then kisses him passionately, he realizes the danger he is in.

By now, however, we already know that Ralph de Bricassart is far too ambitious to let his love for...

(The entire section is 3,182 words.)