Thomas Hardy

Start Free Trial

Student Question

Do you agree that "Death is a common theme in Hardy's Poetry"?

Quick answer:

Death is indeed a prevalent theme in Thomas Hardy's poetry, reflecting his often pessimistic outlook. While his works like "Drummer Hodge" and poems about his late wife, Emma, focus on death, they also explore broader themes such as the passage of time, loss, and the indifference of nature. Hardy's poetry frequently grapples with humanity's insignificance against universal forces, resulting in a pervasive sense of alienation and pessimism.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

With regard to the statement, "Death is a common theme in Hardy's poetry," I would have to agree .

One source cites:

[Hardy's] works are often deeply pessimistic and full of bitter irony, in sharp contrast to the prevalent Victorian optimism.

As a Victorian author confronting the changes promised...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

by England's Industrial Revolution (which would precede America's by about one hundred years), one might imagine that some of his work could be pessimistic to begin with, but he started writing novels long before he began working with poetry.

There are exceptions. "The Darkling Thrush" is a poem full of hope. "I Said To Life" speaks of a loss of love in general. And there are other poems that do not fall into the category of "death." However...

...in 1870...Hardy met and fell in love with Emma Lavinia Gifford, whom he married...Although he later became estranged from his wife...her death had a traumatic effect on him...His Poems 1912–13 reflect upon her passing...preoccupied with his...wife's death, [he] tried to overcome his remorse by writing poetry.

And while not all of Hardy's poems are about his wife, Hardy wrote many other poems that were also about death. For example, "Drummer Hodge" was about a drummer who died and was buried in Africa during the the first of the two Boer Wars in which the British were involved.

Based upon the article from Wikipedia.com, Hardy started writing poems to help him cope with losing his wife (even though they were no longer together when she died). Because of Hardy's motivation for writing these poetry in the first place, it is safe to assume that he was preoccupied with loss and death.

Therefore, death is a common theme in Hardy's poems.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Do you agree with the statement: "Death is a common theme in Hardy's poetry"?

I must admit, I would want to widen the statement to refer generally to Hardy's sense of pessimism in his poetry. Death of course is just one aspect that he touches upon, but you will also want to pay attention to and analyse his preoccupation with the passing of time, the loss of loved ones, failed hopes and the decline of religious faith. Certainly the passage of time is a central theme in Hardy's poetry. At times it is as if he believed it was the fount of all unhappiness. Linked with this of course is his view of nature as being utterly indifferent to the short lives of human beings. Hardy's personal philosophy of life was that he considered humanity to be utterly swamped by the forces of the universe, which resulted in deep feelings of alienation and struggles with his own personal significance.

Thus we can see that so many of his poems, such as "At Castle Boterel" and "During Wind and Rain" feature a massive conflict as the speaker struggles against the sense of meaninglessness of space and time, and attempts to reassert what is essentially human against the forces of the universe. Likewise we can thus see the importance of acts of memory, where the speaker attempts to reclaim the past. And yet those poems that do try to do so, like "The Voice" and "At Castle Boterel," end in inevitable failure and a return to the pessimistic tone that dominates.

Therefore, whilst death is definitely a focus of Hardy's poetry, I think you would find it more fruitful to examine his pessimism as a whole, of which the theme of death is one undeniable part.

Approved by eNotes Editorial