Thomas Hardy

Start Free Trial

AI Fact-Check

In light of the Victorian conflict between religion and science, especially Darwinism and diminishing faith, critically analyze Thomas Hardy's "Nature’s Questioning." Support your analysis with direct quotes from the poem.

AI Generated Answer

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Thomas Hardy’s poem "Nature's Questioning" touches upon several themes that reflect the Victorian era's anxieties about religion, science, and the evolving understanding of human existence in the face of scientific advancements, particularly Darwinism. The poem is a meditation on the natural world and its seemingly indifferent or even hostile disposition towards human concerns and aspirations, which resonates deeply with Hardy's often bleak and questioning view of the universe.

Context of Victorian Era and Religion-Science Conflict: During the Victorian period, the publication of Charles Darwin’s "On the Origin of Species" in 1859 significantly challenged traditional religious beliefs. Darwin’s theory of natural selection suggested that species evolve over time through a process of random mutation and survival pressures, not by divine design. This posed a direct challenge to the biblical creation story and the idea of a benevolent, omnipotent God who created humans in His image.

Hardy and Loss of Faith: Thomas Hardy himself grappled with the decline of religious certainty. Raised with a Christian background, Hardy grew increasingly agnostic throughout his life. His writings frequently reflect his skepticism about the moral compass provided by religion and a preoccupation with the indifferent forces of nature that shape human destiny without any apparent moral oversight.

Analysis of "Nature's Questioning": The poem begins with a night-time scene where various natural elements – the moon, stars, and wind – engage in a sort of cosmic dialogue. These natural forces are personified, questioning their existence and purpose, much like humans do. The imagery Hardy uses is stark and somewhat unsettling, reflecting the Victorian anxiety about the place of humanity in a universe that is being increasingly understood in scientific rather than religious terms.

  1. Personification and Symbolism: Each element of nature in the poem questions its purpose and the larger design of the universe. This mirrors the Victorian existential crisis brought about by scientific discoveries that suggested a mechanical and indifferent universe, contrary to the comforting divine order promised by religion.

  2. Tone and Mood: The tone of the poem is contemplative and somber, reflecting Hardy’s characteristic pessimism. The questioning by natural elements underscores a sense of futility and existential dread, a common theme in Hardy’s work, where human life is often at the mercy of an impersonal and uncaring natural world.

  3. Philosophical Implications: The poem can be read as a reflection on the limitations of human understanding. The natural world, while majestic and awe-inspiring, does not yield easy answers to the fundamental questions of existence. This aligns with the disillusionment felt by many in the Victorian era as the comforting certainties provided by religion began to crumble under the weight of scientific discovery.

  4. Conclusion and the Human Condition: Ultimately, "Nature's Questioning" does not resolve the questions it raises. This unresolved tension is emblematic of Hardy’s view of the human condition: one of struggle against an uncaring universe, where the search for meaning often leads only to more questions. The poem subtly critiques the notion of a harmonious natural order, suggesting instead that chaos and randomness may be the true nature of the universe.

In summary, Thomas Hardy’s "Nature's Questioning" serves as a poignant reflection of the Victorian struggle to reconcile the discoveries of science with the teachings of religion. It captures the era's growing awareness of humanity’s potentially insignificant place in the universe, an idea that was both terrifying and liberating as it forced a reevaluation of moral and existential certainties.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The response generated is correct. In the poem, Hardy questions Man's existence and struggle for survival. The Enlightenment had thrown religious certainty into turmoil and with Darwinism espousing survival of the fittest, the tension between religious beliefs of a caring G-d were eroded even further. Moreover, the Victorian period saw dramatic and rapidly occurring changes such as industrialization, rising urbanization and enhanced mobility with construction of roads and railways lead to social upheaval and societal shifts that influenced literature. In the  poem, it is the anthropomorphized natural elements that question their existence:

Field, flock, and lonely tree,
All seem to look at me
Like chastened children sitting silent in a school;

These 'children' question the master's or creator's ways and their very existence,

"We wonder, ever wonder, why we find us here!

"Has some Vast Imbecility,
Mighty to build and blend,
But impotent to tend,
Framed us in jest, and left us now to hazardry?

They wonder whether a creator gave them life but then, unlike the benevolent G-d of the bible, left them alone to deal with the hazards of the natural world. This view is consistent with Hardy's other works, which show the influence of the bleak northern landscape. In Far From The Madding Crowd, nature, including the shepherd dog, drives Farmer Oak's flock over the cliff, ruining his social status in minutes. Violent storms and fires threaten Bathsheba's farm and her status. Hardy's view of nature takes on the Darwinian view as both these characters adapt and survive. Other less fit characters in the book are not as fortunate. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Reviewed by eNotes Editorial on