Thomas H. Ince Criticism
Thomas H. Ince, a pivotal figure in early American cinema, revolutionized the motion picture industry with his systematic approach to filmmaking. Acknowledged as a pioneer, Ince streamlined the creation of films by introducing comprehensive, written "continuities," which evolved into today’s shooting scripts. This innovation enhanced both the efficiency and quality of productions in Hollywood, marking a significant shift in the studio system. As observed by Janet Staiger, Ince’s methods reflected a broader adoption of scientific management and the division of labor in filmmaking.
Ince’s influence extends beyond technical innovations; he is credited with elevating the Western genre to an art form through his productions like The Aryan and War on the Plains. His acclaimed antiwar film, Civilization, is considered his magnum opus, showcasing his ability to blend grand spectacle with profound thematic content. As noted in The Challenge for the Motion Picture Producer, Ince pursued clarity, continuity, intensity, and realism in his films.
Born in Newport, Rhode Island, in 1882, Ince transitioned from stage acting to film, initially directing for Carl Laemmle's IMP Company. His career evolved as he joined the New York Motion Picture Company, where he focused on Westerns, eventually creating his first feature-length film, The Battle of Gettysburg. By 1915, he co-founded Triangle Film Corporation and later established his own studio in Culver City, furthering his influence in the industry. George Mitchell highlights Ince’s role in shaping the modern studio system through his systematic production techniques.
While American scholars often emphasize Ince's business savvy and organization skills, European critics, led by Jean Mitry, argue for his artistic significance, likening his influence to that of D.W. Griffith. Mitry describes Ince as the "first dramaturgist" of cinema, whose innovations went beyond mere technical advancements to include the expression of original themes and ideas. Ince’s legacy remains a subject of debate, illustrating the complexity and impact of his contributions to early cinema.
Contents
- *Principal Works
-
Essays
-
Motion Picture Directing: The Facts and Theories of the Newest Art
(summary)
In the following excerpt, Milne describes Ince's strict film production process and lists several studio directors who successfully used his methods.
-
The Challenge for the Motion Picture Producer
(summary)
In the following essay, originally published in 1925, Ince expresses his desire for clarity, continuity, intensity, and above all realism in motion pictures.
-
Thomas H. Ince Was the Pioneer Producer Who Systematized the Making of a Movie
(summary)
In the following essay, Mitchell details Ince's life and career as a film director-producer.
-
Thomas H. Ince: His Esthetic, His Films, His Legacy
(summary)
In the following essay, which was first published in 1965, Mitry evaluates Ince as an artist rather than as a businessman or technical innovator.
-
Dividing Labor for Production Control: Thomas Ince and the Rise of the Studio System
(summary)
In the following essay, Staiger argues that although Ince may be seen as an innovator in the film industry his improvements generally reflect the adoption of scientific management and the division of labor to the process of filmmaking.
-
Motion Picture Directing: The Facts and Theories of the Newest Art
(summary)
- Further Reading