Analysis
The works of Thomas Bernhard form a profound exploration of existential themes and philosophical inquiries, often mirroring his own tumultuous life experiences. His novels delve into the futility of language, the inevitability of death, and the struggle for unattainable perfection, encapsulated in a unique narrative style that critiques the human condition. By dissecting his recurring themes, biographical influences, and philosophical engagements, we gain a deeper understanding of how Bernhard's personal and intellectual life permeates his literary output.
Recurring Themes in Bernhard's Work
Thomas Bernhard's literary landscape is threaded with themes of existential despair and autobiographical introspection. Critics frequently highlight the negative yet intensely personal nature of his novels, which echo the pain of his own experiences. Bernhard likens writing to a Sisyphean battle against despair, describing it as performing futile operations on himself, akin to removing recurring cancerous growths. This metaphor poignantly reflects the existential hopelessness also found in the works of Kafka.
At the core of Bernhard's narratives is a recurring motif where a character, often a man, faces a life-altering "shock"—a personal catastrophe or existential realization—that leaves him emotionally shattered. This scenario serves as an allegory for the universal human condition, underscored by the inevitability of death and life's absurdity. Bernhard’s protagonists, paralyzed by this awareness, struggle with the inadequacy of language, which leads to deep introspection on madness, governance, and mortality.
Language and Isolation
Bernhard's critique of language situates him within an Austrian tradition influenced by luminaries like Hugo von Hofmannsthal and Ludwig Wittgenstein. Hofmannsthal’s early 20th-century work "Ein Brief" articulated a crisis of language that resonates profoundly in Bernhard’s writings. Similarly, the philosophical investigations of Wittgenstein into language's limits deeply impacted Bernhard, creating a literary paradox where he communicates profound meaning while simultaneously questioning its possibility. This ongoing language interrogation accentuates individual isolation, suggesting that language only serves to underscore separation from others and the world.
Exploring Bernhard's Novels
Frost
Bernhard's debut novel, Frost (1963), unveiled his themes of sickness and death through a bildungsroman in reverse. The protagonist, a medical student, is tasked with observing Strauch, a painter teetering on the edge of mental collapse. As Strauch's delusions infect the student, the narrative delves into themes of decay, with Strauch envisioning a frost embodying absolute cold and lifelessness. The student's transformation into a mirror of the deranged Strauch leaves readers questioning the narrative's reliability.
Gargoyles
In Gargoyles (1967), Bernhard extends his existential themes. The plot follows a doctor and his son visiting patients in varying decay stages, culminating in Prince Saurau's monologue on decay, violence, and familial destruction. Saurau’s perspective blurs reality's lines, leaving readers to ponder the fantasies of a sick mind. The novel's abrupt mid-sentence ending underscores the isolation and disconnection pervasive in Bernhard’s work.
The Lime Works
With The Lime Works (1970), Bernhard earned acclaim using a distanced narrative and taut plot. The novel follows Konrad, isolated and estranged, trying to write a study on human hearing. Konrad's failure to commit thoughts to paper reflects Bernhard's theme of linguistic inadequacy. The narrative's aggression mirrors Konrad's mental unraveling, climaxing in his wife's murder, highlighting Bernhard's obsession with language, isolation, and the destructive pursuit of perfection.
Correction
Considered Bernhard's masterpiece, Correction (1975) revolves around Roithamer, a scientist whose posthumous papers reveal his obsessive quest to construct a conical house for his sister—a project leading to her death and his suicide. The narrative intertwines Bernhard’s life with Wittgenstein's philosophy, exploring language and thought limits. Roithamer's endless corrections signify the futility of achieving perfection, a theme Bernhard explores deeply.
Concrete
Concrete (1982) presents a more accessible tone with humor. Rudolph, a would-be musicologist, blames his sister...
(This entire section contains 1773 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
and external factors for his procrastination on a Mendelssohn study. The narrative climaxes with Rudolph’s encounter with Anna Härdtl's tragic story, buried in concrete, contrasting Rudolph’s theoretical anguish with Anna’s reality. The novel illustrates Bernhard's themes through a more engaging narrative style.
Biographical Influences and Literary Tradition
Bernhard’s life heavily informs his work. Born illegitimately, with familial tensions and chronic health issues, Bernhard’s personal pain mirrors his protagonists' struggles. His exposure to Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and negative experiences with Austrian institutions further shape his characters' nihilism. Beyond biography, Bernhard's work is rooted in a broader tradition, drawing from philosophers like Heidegger and Wittgenstein, as well as existentialist thinkers and writers like Dostoevski and Beckett, enriching his novels and creating a dialogue with past intellectual discourses.
Philosophical and Cultural Critique
Bernhard’s novels serve as existential inquiries and cultural critiques. His dissatisfaction with Austria’s political and cultural state, especially its reluctance to confront its fascist history and support contemporary art, is a recurring theme. His characters express contempt for bourgeois society, echoing Bernhard’s critique of Austrian institutions. Despite initial resistance, Bernhard’s innovative prose and deep themes have secured his place as a leading 20th-century literary figure, influencing future German and Austrian novelists.
Biographical Influences and Traditions
Bernhard's syntactically challenging prose becomes more approachable when considering his life, especially his formative years, as detailed in his memoirs Gathering Evidence. Born out of wedlock, with a complex family life and enduring health struggles, Bernhard’s bleak worldview is reflected in his protagonists. His early encounter with Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, and his negative experiences with Catholicism and the Austrian healthcare system, offer insight into the curmudgeonly characters in his novels.
While a biographical perspective offers insights into Bernhard's work, it’s limited. His prose emerges from a rich literary tradition, simultaneously rejecting and refining it. Bernhard’s novels illustrate personal debates with artists and philosophers, past and present. Besides Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, intertextual references to Heidegger, Wittgenstein, Dostoevski, Beckett, and French existentialists show Bernhard as less of a self-created genius than he claimed.
The Influence of Music
Music transcends verbal communication limitations for Bernhard. Critics note that his novels, especially The Loser, aren't traditionally structured but follow contrapuntal musical compositions, like the fugue. Johann Sebastian Bach’s Goldberg Variations serve as the formal basis for The Loser, about pianist Glenn Gould.
This structural principle of repetition and variation permeates Bernhard's mature novels. An eccentric loner, often high-standing, educated, but afflicted by real or imagined disease, engages in a project for perfection. Each project, whether literary or musical, is unachievable due to environmental hindrances, often involving an intrusive sister. Subconsciously, they know their project won’t match their perfectionist ideals. This dilemma leads some to suicide, while others find meaning in striving for unattainable perfection, even if doomed.
Existential Anguish and Cultural Critique
Beyond existential anguish, Bernhard’s novels critique Austria's cultural and political landscape. He never missed a chance to critique Austria for avoiding its fascist past and clinging to outdated models. His narrators become critics of Austrian politics and culture, at times prompting legal action against him.
Despite initial reluctance, Bernhard gained recognition as a leading 20th-century prose writer. Although complex, his novels found a wide European readership. English-speaking audiences were slower to accept him, but increasing critical acclaim and translations expanded his readership. His compatriot, Elfriede Jelinek, a Nobel Prize winner, asserts that future German and Austrian novelists must measure up to Bernhard’s high standards.
Concrete
Concrete, first published in 1982, offers a continuous interior monologue, forming one long paragraph. The narrative, a manuscript by the protagonist Rudolph, is perused by an anonymous narrator. Rudolph, a musicologist, attempts to write a study on Mendelssohn but repeatedly fails, blaming interruptions by his sister and various external factors.
At the novel’s outset, Rudolph is determined to start writing, convinced he has limited time left due to sarcoidosis. He blames his sister's interference, the adverse Austrian cultural climate, and his health for his procrastination. However, completing his project would deprive him of purpose, equating his life’s work with his life’s end.
After a lengthy monologue on these obstacles, Rudolph visits Mallorca, recalling a past encounter with Anna Härdtl, whose husband died there under mysterious circumstances. Rudolph had helped Anna find her husband’s grave—a concrete bunker shared with a stranger. Two years later, he discovers Anna, having committed suicide, is now buried there too. This revelation leaves him in extreme anxiety.
The novel’s title alludes to Anna’s concrete grave, entrenching Bernhard’s themes of self-absorbed intellectualism, doubt, and inaction. Despite his contempt for practical individuals, Rudolph envies those who take control of their lives, even through suicide. Readers ponder whether Rudolph’s epiphany will spark decisive action or perpetuate excuses and procrastination.
Correction
First published in 1975, Correction is hailed as Bernhard’s masterpiece. The novel follows an anonymous narrator sorting through Roithamer’s posthumous papers to understand his suicide. The novel, akin to a trilogy on striving for perfection, is divided into two sections: “Hoeller’s Garret” and “Sifting and Sorting.”
In "Hoeller’s Garret," the narrator, with a lung disease, moves into a friend’s house to handle Roithamer’s papers. Roithamer's note requested this task, focusing on versions of an essay explaining his failed utopian plan to build a cone-shaped house for his sister. The house led to her death, prompting Roithamer’s suicide.
The novel’s title arises from Roithamer’s essay corrections, efforts to clarify his concept of the conical house. In "Sifting and Sorting," the narrator’s voice fades, and Roithamer’s papers speak for themselves. The dead man’s reflections reveal the impossibility of perfect understanding, leading to his despair and suicide.
Critics note parallels between Roithamer and Wittgenstein, including sisterly attachments, eccentric houses, and language despair. The narrator sees their similarities and fears Roithamer’s fate. By letting Roithamer’s papers speak, he avoids a similar end. This lack of method becomes his salvation, acknowledging the futility of perfection.
The Loser
The Loser, published in 1983, mirrors Correction in form and theme, focusing on Glenn Gould’s mythologized quest for musical perfection. The novel follows a narrator reflecting on friendships with Wertheimer and Gould during piano studies, all afflicted by lung disease and self-doubt.
Wertheimer’s recent suicide, possibly linked to Gould’s death, prompts the narrator to sort Wertheimer’s papers. Both abandoned piano playing, unable to surpass Gould, with Wertheimer losing his identity in Gould’s shadow. Wertheimer’s "loss" stems from trying to become someone else, leading to his decline.
The narrator, unlike Wertheimer, shifts from emulating Gould to describing his genius—an impossible task that prevents despair. In The Loser, Bernhard's intellectual protagonist splits into three variations: Gould, who embraces recording technology for perfection; the narrator, who accepts limitations; and Wertheimer, who self-destructs in pursuit of an unattainable ideal.
Wertheimer’s final act involves destroying his papers before suicide, leaving the narrator speechless, listening to Gould’s Goldberg Variations.
Discussion Topics
Thomas Bernhard's protagonists often grapple with various afflictions, which raises intriguing questions. Do these portrayals mirror Bernhard's personal struggles with illness, or do they serve as metaphors for deeper existential concerns? The characters he crafts typically express themselves through interior monologues, presented in dense, unbroken paragraphs. These narrators, often eccentric in their disposition, compel readers to question their reliability. Is the world they describe shaped more by subjective experience than by objective truth? Such narrative techniques invite a critical examination of what we consider as fact within his literary universe.
Another dimension of Bernhard's work is the notable absence of female narrators, which has led some to label him a misogynist. However, a more nuanced exploration might reveal alternative explanations for this narrative choice. Could it be reflective of the specific social and cultural contexts he aims to critique, or is it an artistic decision aligned with the thematic focus of his work?
Meanwhile, Bernhard's portrayal of Austria starkly contrasts with the idyllic images many Americans conjure, influenced by the Hollywood rendition of The Sound of Music. While the film showcases a picturesque landscape, Bernhard's Austria is complex, often depicted with a critical eye that lays bare its societal and historical wounds. This juxtaposition invites readers to reconsider their preconceptions about Austria's cultural identity.
In his frequent allusions to renowned figures such as Glenn Gould and Ludwig Wittgenstein, Bernhard deliberately alters factual details. This intentional distortion may serve to blur the lines between reality and fiction, suggesting a commentary on the nature of truth and the limitations of biographical narratives. His approach prompts readers to engage with these figures not as historical entities but as symbols within his thematic explorations.
Despite the often somber tones of his narratives, some critics discern elements of comedy woven into Bernhard's prose. Identifying these moments requires a careful reading, as humor in his work often emerges subtly, through absurdity or irony. Such instances challenge the perception of his novels as exclusively bleak, revealing a layered complexity that encompasses both the tragic and the comedic.