The Holocaust and Its Literature
The Holocaust refers to the systematic mass murder of European Jews and other groups by the Nazis during World War II. The main character in "This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen" is a prisoner at Auschwitz, one of the infamous death camps where these horrific acts were carried out. Around six million Jews died in the Holocaust, along with at least three million people from other ethnic backgrounds. The Nazis executed this mass extermination with brutal efficiency; by the end of the day described in the story, 15,000 people have been sent to their deaths with almost no effort.
"This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen" is one of several stories by Borowski about Auschwitz and belongs to a wider genre known as Holocaust literature. Writers like Primo Levi and Elie Wiesel have provided some of the most renowned accounts of survival. This genre often explores how individuals withstood the horrors of concentration camps. Survivors have different interpretations of their experiences. Viktor Frankl suggested that, despite the dire conditions, prisoners found life inherently meaningful, even amidst suffering. On the other hand, some survivors argue that surviving the camps required abandoning all notions of the "normal world" and typical human behavior; Borowski's work aligns with this latter viewpoint.
Death and Survival
In "This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen," the themes of mortality and survival are closely connected. To stay alive, the narrator and other prisoners must engage in the camp's operations, which primarily involve the extermination of Jews and other deemed "undesirables." The narrator's responsibilities, such as unloading Jews from the transports, directly contribute to this extermination process, reflecting Borowski's real-life experiences. The prisoners' physical survival relies on the death of others; they receive vital supplies like clothing and food from those condemned to die. At the beginning of the story, the prisoners are struggling due to a recent lack of incoming transports. Henri notes that if the camp "runs out of people" to kill, the prisoners will face starvation. "All of us live on what they bring," he states, emphasizing the connection between death and survival. When the narrator leaves the barracks to help with the transport for the first time, he feels grateful. By participating in the deaths of others, he secures his own survival.
Morality
Within the confines of the camp, traditional notions of morality lose their significance. The narrator and his fellow prisoners rely on the deaths of others to stay alive, inadvertently implicating themselves in the murder of Jews. Even more unsettling is the fact that the inmates are forced to participate in these heinous acts; refusing to do their assigned tasks would lead to their own executions. To survive under such dire circumstances, the narrator must emotionally and mentally detach from his actions. He refers to the arrival of cattle cars as the camp's "usual diversion," equating the mass deaths of innocent people to a form of entertainment. He casually mentions allowing a praying rabbi to continue "raving," knowing that this would lead the Nazis to "take him to the oven that much sooner." The only gesture of kindness the prisoners offer to those headed for the gas chambers is by misleading them about their fate, telling the Jews they do not know where they are being taken.
The narrator explores moral dilemmas on the ramp when he asks Henri if they are good people. Instead of feeling empathy for the doomed Jews, he feels anger towards them, believing that their presence forces him to endure the horrors of Auschwitz. Despite these feelings, the narrator shows physical signs of his moral struggle. He experiences nausea...
(This entire section contains 269 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
and, after unloading several transports, ultimately loses control and vomits. As he sits down, he suddenly perceives "the camp as a haven of peace," highlighting how disconnected he has become from normalcy; in the twisted reality of Auschwitz, the death camp has ironically become a sanctuary.
The Holocaust
This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen falls into the genre of Holocaust literature. In his collection of short stories, Borowski presents an alternative viewpoint on this atrocious historical event by narrating from the perspective of a privileged, non-Jewish prisoner. Like many works of Holocaust literature, Borowski’s short stories are inspired by his personal experiences as a prisoner at Auschwitz. Borowski uses an understated, documentarian style of prose that allows the horrific images of camp life—such as prisoners scraping crushed infant skulls off of the floors of train cars, eating raw human brains, and watching three thousand people be put to death between two throw-ins at a prison soccer match—to speak for themselves.
Desensitization to Violence
The prisoners at Auschwitz witness and endure endless violence at camp. Even in seemingly mundane scenes of camp life, instances and threats of violence are always present. In “The People Who Walked On,” the prisoners play soccer as thousands of Jews march past them on their way to the gas chambers. Instead of reacting or feeling upset, Tadek and the other prisoners try to normalize the experience by refusing to humanize the people walking to the gas chambers. Borowski’s idea that all of the members of the concentration camp community held some responsibility for the atrocities that took place during the Holocaust was initially met with disdain. After the book’s first publication in Poland, the Communist Party criticized the book as amoral and Americanized, and the Catholic Church criticized Borowski’s nihilistic perspective.
Survival and Morality
In order to survive, Tadek becomes largely desensitized to the violence surrounding him and focuses on making it through the war alive in order to be reunited with his fiancé. But there are still moments when his humanity takes over, and these are the times when he becomes most vulnerable. When he sees a young blonde woman as an individual person rather than simply part of a mass of prisoners walking to their deaths, Tadek becomes unable to perform his job and puts his life in danger. When he gives Becker his bowl of soup, he angers his Kapo, who later reminds Tadek that he has the power to have him killed. Any act of kindness or humanity between prisoners that is witnessed by the guards is met with suspicion or, in some cases, death. At Harmenz, Andrei shows kindness to two Greek prisoners by trying to teach them to march. When the Unterscharfuhrer sees this, he tells Andrei to kill them, and Andrei must beat them to death with a stick.
These moments demonstrate how little our usual notions of morality meant at Auschwitz. The Unterscharfuhrer is the one who orders the deaths of the Greeks, but their blood is also on Andrei’s hands. Furthermore, if Andrei had not been kind to the Greeks, the Unterscharfuhrer would not have ordered their deaths. But, if Andrei had behaved morally and refused to kill the Greeks, the SS guard would have shot all three of them.
Apathy
Prisoner apathy is touched on in all of Borowski’s stories and is a prevalent theme in Holocaust literature. Even though the prisoners greatly outnumber the guards, instances of revolt are relatively rare. In “The Death of Schillinger,” Borowski includes one of these exceptions, but in the rest of the stories, thousands of prisoners submit to the SS guards without resistance. Borowski attributes this to something innate about human nature, which he explores more in-depth in “The Man with the Package.” Even after the prisoners have been selected for the gas chambers, they cannot accept that they will actually be killed. When the Schreiber is selected for the gas chamber, he insists on bringing his package with him, even though he knows that the SS men will take it from him. Tadek discusses the matter with a doctor and says that the Schreiber should have given the package to someone who could actually use it. The doctor disagrees and says that he does not know how he would react in that situation.
Depression and Disconnection from the World
In the last few stories of the collection, Borowski describes the difficulties of life after liberation. Tadek struggles to regain his sense of humanity and “feel” things the way he did before the war. He becomes consumed with memories of the people he knew and saw at Auschwitz. In the summer, he walks through the poorest sections of the city and feels unmoved by the world.
Depression was very common for Holocaust survivors. Many survivors made it through the war only to find that returning to the post-war “normal” world was extremely difficult. Borowski ends the final story, “The World of Stone,” with Tadek planning to write “a great, immortal epic.” In 1951, Borowski committed suicide by inhaling gas from a gas stove.