If This Is a Man

by Primo Levi

Start Free Trial

Student Question

In If This Is a Man, how do Steinlauf and Alberto resist surrendering their identity?

Quick answer:

Steinlauf and Alberto resist surrendering their identity by embracing transcendent values amidst the dehumanizing conditions of the Holocaust. Steinlauf believes survival serves as a transformative force, representing the atrocities committed, thus maintaining his identity for a greater cause. Similarly, Alberto's selflessness and care for others, demonstrated through sharing rations, uphold his identity. Both characters rely on universal beliefs to withstand the oppressive environment, refusing to succumb to despair.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

For Levi, Steinlauf and Lorenzo represent the essence of not capitulating to conditions that immerse the individual.  Levi writes about them with a considerable praise because they embrace the transcendent in a world of the contingent.  They resist any surrender of their identity because of this transcendence, something that they believe will not wither even in the harshest of treatment by the Nazis.  Steinlauf makes this clear in his assertion to Levi that the purpose of survival is to represent a force of transformation, to serve as a record of what is being done.  Steinlauf is operating on a level of personal awareness being transformed to social good, something that causes him to resist any surrender of his identity because of his commitment to a cause that is elevate.  In much the same way, Lorenzo refuses to surrender his identity because he is driven to care for others.  When he shares his rations with Levi, it becomes evident that his mistreatment at the hands of the Nazis will not trade off with his belief in sacrificing for others or helping others out.  His selflessness and sense of honoring the bonds with other people enables him to use this as a type of shield to deny the surrender of his identity.  In both characters, it is the belief in the transcendent, in something universal, that prevents them from succumbing to the contingent and base that dominates life during the Holocaust.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial