illustration of the backside of a soldier in full military gear

The Things They Carried

by Tim O’Brien

Start Free Trial

Themes: Storytelling: Fact or Fiction

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Similar to other Vietnam War literature, "The Things They Carried" is heavily shaped by the author's own combat experiences. Nonetheless, O'Brien emphasizes that the book's fictional elements should not be confused with actual accounts. In an interview with Michael Coffey of Publishers Weekly shortly after the book's release, O'Brien states: "My own experience has virtually nothing to do with the content of the book." The title page clearly identifies it as "a work of fiction." Despite this, the book is dedicated "to the men of Alpha Company, and in particular to Jimmy Cross, Norman Bowker, Rat Kiley, Mitchell Sanders, Henry Dobbins, and Kiowa." O'Brien himself served as an infantryman in Alpha Company and was stationed in Quang Ngai province from 1969 to 1970. When asked about this during an interview with Martin Narparsteck in Contemporary Literature, O'Brien explains: "What I'm saying is that even with that nonfiction-sounding element in the story, everything in the story is fiction, beginning to end. To classify different elements of the story as fact or fiction seems to me artificial. Literature should be looked at not for its literal truth but for its emotional qualities. What matters in literature, I think, are the pretty simple things—whether it moves me or not. Whether it feels true. The actual literal truth should be superfluous."

O'Brien clearly invites readers to explore the boundary between fact and fiction. What is essential to him, as he explained at a conference on Vietnam War literature, is the "power of stories, whether they're true, or embellished, and exaggerated, or utterly made up. A good story has a power... that transcends the question of factuality or actuality." At the beginning of the final story in The Things They Carried, O'Brien reveals why he shares these narratives: "Sometimes stories can save us." Offering further insight in an interview with Publishers Weekly, O'Brien remarks, "If there is a theme to the whole book it has to do with the fact that stories can save our lives."

Expert Q&A

What is the effect of "Notes" in The Things They Carried? Which parts are true and which parts are the author's own invention?

In "Notes," Tim O'Brien blurs the line between fact and fiction, emphasizing the subjective nature of truth in war stories. While "Notes" appears to clarify "Speaking of Courage," it instead complicates the narrative, highlighting the unreliability of memory and storytelling. O'Brien admits to inventing much of Bowker's story, including his guilt over Kiowa's death. Ultimately, the only certainties are the ambush and Kiowa's death, with Bowker's feelings of guilt remaining genuine but unexplained.

How do multiple accounts of Kiowa's death in The Things They Carried relate to themes of memory, truth, and storytelling?

Multiple accounts of Kiowa's death in The Things They Carried highlight themes of memory, truth, and storytelling by illustrating how different perspectives shape personal truths and memories. Each soldier's narrative reflects their own emotional response and sense of responsibility, showing truth as subjective and memory as malleable. Storytelling becomes a way to process events and emotions, revealing the complexities of war and the personal burdens soldiers carry, while questioning the notion of a single, objective truth.

Why does O'Brien lie to his daughter in The Things They Carried?

In the story "Ambush" from The Things They Carried, it appears that Tim O'Brien lies to his daughter to protect her from the realities of war. Later in the book, however, it seems that he does so because the truth about what happened in Vietnam is impossible to communicate.

Why does O'Brien include the story about Linda in The Things They Carried?

Tim O'Brien writes about Linda in "The Lives of the Dead," the last story in The Things They Carried, to draw a parallel between the way he dreamt about Linda in order to keep her alive and the way he writes about his fellow soldiers who died in the Vietnam War.

Why does O'Brien include the story about Linda in The Things They Carried?

O'Brien includes the story about Linda to illustrate how humans cope with death, extending the theme beyond the battlefield. Linda's story, found in "The Lives of the Dead," shows that the deceased remain part of the living's memories, providing comfort and insight. Through Linda, O'Brien emphasizes that stories hold the power to help us endure loss, reflecting that everyone battles something, not just soldiers in war.

What does Tim O'Brien mean by "[I]t’s not a game. It’s a form" in "The Things They Carried"?

Tim O'Brien, in "The Things They Carried," uses the phrase "it's not a game. It's a form" to explain his approach to storytelling. He fictionalizes his war experiences not for amusement but as a means to process his memories and guilt without reliving them too precisely. This narrative form allows him to convey the complex realities of war while protecting himself and others from the harshness of absolute truth.

How can you discern the truth in the short stories of "The Things They Carried"?

To discern truth in the stories of "The Things They Carried," focus on emotional rather than factual truth. Author Tim O'Brien emphasizes the emotional experiences of war, such as love, horror, and pain, over objective facts. Postmodern theory suggests factual truth is subjective and difficult to establish. O'Brien's reshaping of facts aims to convey more powerful emotional truths, reflecting the complex realities of war as experienced by different individuals.

What is the effect of O'Brien's shift between story and commentary in The Things They Carried?

O'Brien's shift between story and commentary in The Things They Carried creates a metafictional narrative that explores the relationship between experience and truth. This technique helps readers distinguish between literal truth and perceived reality, emphasizing how soldiers' perceptions shape their experiences of war. By blending narrative with interpretive guidance, O'Brien challenges conventional views of war stories, suggesting they are not moral or instructional but rather reflections of the soldiers' subjective realities.

What are the benefits of stories according to O’Brien?

Tim O'Brien highlights the benefits of stories as a means of coping with trauma and preserving memories. He suggests that stories, particularly war stories, are not moral or instructive but serve to make sense of experiences and emotions that are otherwise difficult to confront. In "The Lives of the Dead," O'Brien reflects on how stories "can save us" by reviving memories and keeping the deceased alive for the living, offering a form of emotional salvation and continuity.

What purpose does the ambiguity serve in "The Man I Killed" from The Things They Carried?

In Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried, the author retains ambiguity about whether he actually killed anyone in Vietnam as the narrator does in the story "The Man I Killed." This ambiguity reflects and explores the ambiguity inherent in the war itself and in the soldiers' experiences.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: The Individual and the Collective

Next

Themes: Illusion vs. Reality

Loading...