‘They Cannot Kill Us All’

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on May 8, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 340

Richard Manning’s 1986 NEWSWEEK cover story on South Africa’s escalating civil war earned for him an expulsion order after he had been in the country less than a year. Nine months was long enough, however, for this energetic journalist to interview an amazing variety of individuals across the political spectrum;...

(The entire section contains 340 words.)

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this ‘They Cannot Kill Us All' study guide. You'll get access to all of the ‘They Cannot Kill Us All' content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

  • Summary
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

Richard Manning’s 1986 NEWSWEEK cover story on South Africa’s escalating civil war earned for him an expulsion order after he had been in the country less than a year. Nine months was long enough, however, for this energetic journalist to interview an amazing variety of individuals across the political spectrum; it was also long enough for Manning to fall hopelessly in love with the beautiful, maddening country that is South Africa.

South Africa is a sort of moral and political Rubik’s cube: Though solutions are frustratingly hard to find, the puzzle hooks one, draws one in. Manning’s treatment of the complexities of his subject is strongest when he maintains a degree of journalistic distance, letting facts speak for themselves. His simple recitation of statistics regarding Soweto is heartrending: “Tuberculosis occurs as frequently as the common cold in New York or Los Angeles.... In the Diepkloof section of Soweto, families sleep four to a house. Four families: one to each room.” There is real insight in the discussion of the guilt-ridden paralysis of upper-class Anglos (English-speaking whites). The short biography of Nelson Mandela shines, and Manning’s reflections on South Africa’s future and on United States policy are thought-provoking.

Several mannerisms of Manning’s style, however, are extremely annoying and distracting. For some reason, he interrupts even the most eloquent speeches of his interviewees with descriptions of their gestures: shrugging, nose-rubbing, eye-widening. It is hard to keep from visualizing the speakers as jerky marionettes.

The book is less than successful as a memoir. Manning and his colleagues seem to have had a penchant for undermining moments of deep emotion by responding with four-letter words. He seems to revel in the freedom to do in his book what he could not in the pages of NEWSWEEK: betray the feelings of admiration or contempt that he experienced toward his interviewees. Paradoxically, this frankness diminishes the emotional impact of his descriptions.

There is much here to instruct, even to inspire, if one is willing to endure the author’s self-indulgence.

Illustration of PDF document

Download ‘They Cannot Kill Us All' Study Guide

Subscribe Now