The Story of Edgar Sawtelle Literary Criticism and Significance
by David Wroblewski

Start Your Free Trial

Download The Story of Edgar Sawtelle Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Literary Criticism and Significance

Wroblewski’s The Story of Edgar Sawtelle (2008) received public acclaim, as well as the honor of being placed on the reading list of the Oprah Winfrey’s Book Club. This popular novel was the Wroblewski’s first, and it remained on the New York Times bestseller list for several months. Literary critics, however, gave the book mixed reviews.

The novel was called a “literary thriller with commercial legs” by an anonymous reviewer for Publishers Weekly, which fairly well sums up what most critics thought of it. The book was written in a literary style (loosely based on Shakespeare’s Hamlet), had the story momentum to keep readers turning the pages, and would appeal to a wide audience.Thus is was deemed a potential money-maker for the publisher. Ian Chipman, writing for Booklist, stressed Wroblewski’s literary talent.Chipman found that the author’s prose was “assured” and the novel contained “broad swatches of carefully rendered imagery.” Christopher Hawtree also praised Wroblewski’s novel. Writing a review for the New Yorker, Hawtree stated that the author had created a “coherent, captivating fictional world,” with this novel.

But not all reviewers were so impressed. Some found fault with the abrupt ending that did not completely answer readers’ curiosity about several characters and did not tie up many loose ends in the plot line.Critics who found fault with Wroblewski’s novel included Algis Valiunas, writing for Commentary. Valiunas stated that since a major part of The Story of Edgar Sawtelle  dealt with dogs, one needed to compare it with another literary writer who focused some of his...

(The entire section is 401 words.)