Student Question

What makes Liesel's relationship with the mayor's wife complicated in "The Book Thief"? Why does her brother stop visiting her dreams after she returns a plate?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Ilsa Hermann (the mayor's wife) lost her son Johann during World War I. Her pain and grief have shattered her world completely, making it hard for her to function normally both in her own life and when interacting with other people—hence the complicated nature of her initial relationship with Liesel. She wears her bathrobe all the time and seems disconnected from life.

Liesel first perceives Ilsa as a cold, cruel woman, but the relationship between Liesel and Ilsa becomes more friendly over time because both characters are united in their grief for loved ones. Liesel is still hurting over her little brother's death and has nightmares about it. She too is scarred and in need of healing.

Ilsa sees Liesel steal a book from the Nazi book burning, but she does not report her to the authorities. Rather, she allows Liesel to take some of her books and even leaves treats for her. In a way, Liesel becomes a surrogate child for Ilsa, giving her a reason to reconnect to another human being after the loss of her son.

Liesel is immensely grateful for this. The books are her greatest treasures, so she too warms up to Ilsa. In a way, both characters comfort one another and help one another to grow. Ilsa is able to recover from the death of her son by having someone to love, and much the same happens with Liesel regarding her brother. Their shared love of reading and their compassion for one another give them new connections, allowing the past to heal.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial