Ilustration of Tess on hilly pink terrain with trees and clouds in the background

Tess of the d'Urbervilles

by Thomas Hardy

Start Free Trial

Student Question

What are the implications of capitalism in Tess of the D'Urbervilles?

Quick answer:

Capitalism's influence in "Tess of the D'Urbervilles" is evident through the socio-economic challenges Tess faces. Set in industrializing England, capitalism disrupts rural life, leading to Tess's exploitation and hardship. Her family's poverty and the inequitable wealth distribution highlight capitalism's harsh realities. Despite some benefits, like job opportunities at Talbothays Dairy, the novel ultimately critiques capitalism, showing how wealth equates to power, as seen in Tess's tragic fate and her eventual violent response to Alec's abuse.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Capitalism is undoubtedly an important background theme in Tess of the D'Urbervilles. This is not altogether surprising when one considers the wider cultural context in which the story was conceived. At the time Thomas Hardy wrote the book, England was a highly developed, industrialized nation. In turn, a rapid and sustained period of growth had had a knock-on effect upon the countryside. Increased mechanization, urbanization, and industrial development radically changed the dynamics of both the rural economy and the society it generated. But by the 1870s, when the story is set, Britain was in the grip of a worldwide economic depression that devastated both urban and rural economies alike.

The tragic struggles that Tess endures throughout the novel are related not just to the cultural norms and values of Victorian Christianity but also to the growing upheavals in the countryside created by a fundamentally disruptive economic system.

Increased mechanization...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

of agriculture has made farm work more efficient. Yet still agricultural laborers are expected to toil long hours in hard conditions. The old social bonds that bound farm workers to the land have been undermined by capitalism. Now the people of the countryside must work, and work hard, to satisfy the demands of the rapidly expanding urban populace. Even ancient agricultural practices must now conform to the dictates of a market economy. Milk, for example, needs to be watered down before being sold to the towns and cities as the people living there can no longer drink the full-fat variety.

In the figure of Tess we see an embodiment of the complexities of rural life under advanced capitalism and the conflicted social identities that it so often imposes. Tess's own social class is somewhat ambiguous. She believes herself to be descended from an old family of Norman aristocrats. In days gone by she might've been described as an artisan, but with the decline of feudalism and the subsequent advent of capitalism, that class of independent producers hardly exists. Now, she can be thought of as a reluctant member of a growing rural proletariat, or working class. Matters are complicated further by her attachment to aspects of bourgeois culture by virtue of an education that her parents never enjoyed.

Under capitalism, even human relationships are now just commodities like everything else, treated as things that no longer partake of a sense of the sacred. As members of the rural proletariat lose their connection to the soil, they lose connection with each other. This is what keeps them in a state of permanent subjection. Tess is now ripe for exploitation, both personal and economic. The symbolism of her rape at the hands of Alec is clear. The violation she suffers as a woman is paralleled by her being forced into a harsh, degrading life of toil at the behest of a cruel, unjust system.

Tess remains trapped. This is her ultimate tragedy. And this is also an oblique comment on capitalism as it stood at that particular time. On one hand, she has the natural intelligence and formal education to escape the increasing harshness of rural Wessex. Yet on the other, as not just a woman but a poor woman at that, she is prevented from doing so. Capitalism has created a large, impoverished proletariat in the countryside, and women like Tess are right at the bottom of it.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Tess of the D'Urbervilles, what are the implications of capitalism?

This is a very creative question because it asks you to take a concept from economics, capitalism, and apply it to a critical work in the English canon, Tess of the d'UrbervillesIt is also a timely question. Thomas Hardy wrote Tess of the d’Urbervilles in England at the end of the 1800s, when industrialization was on the rise and nations were having impassioned dialogues about the role of capitalism and the distribution of resources.

Capitalism refers to the way that goods and services are distributed in a society; in a capitalist society, goods and services are distributed according to the free market. In other words, private individuals own, trade, and manage the nation's wealth according to their needs and desires. In any capitalist society, accessing money is of the utmost import to both surviving daily life and achieving upward social mobility.

The implications of capitalism are paramount to Tess's experiences in Tess of the d'Urbervilles. Writing in the late 1800s, Thomas Hardy's story of Tess, a woman who was raped and then abandoned because of it, ran against Victorian social norms of the time. While the novel is commonly interpreted as an exposé of gender-based double standards, it also reveals how Tess was both disadvantaged and advantaged in the capitalist system.

The opening of the novel reveals the extent to which capitalism is at the heart of the complicating events of the narrative. Tess's father drives by her and her friends in their family’s old, shabby cart; there is great concern over whether or not the family beehives will make it to market; and Tess blames herself for the death of their family horse, Prince. The name of the horse, "Prince," is ripe itself with symbolism. A prince, by definition, is a man born into a royal family. The use of this term underscores Tess's poverty and her lack of a wealthy suitor. So, at the very outset of the novel, the social class of the Durbeyfield family is directly in the forefront. Their poverty is thrown into further relief by Tess's father's critical discovery that they are far-off descendants of the noble and rich d'Urberville family.

The contrast between the Durbeyfields' home and the d’Urbervilles' home underscores the inequitable economic distribution that is inherent in any capitalist society. The Durbeyfields are presented as wholesome and hardworking, yet they have little; meanwhile, Alec is well-groomed and wealthy yet cruel to both Angel and Tess through mockery and sexual abuse. This relationship reflects the inequitable and often unearned distribution of wealth in capitalist societies.

The explanation, if there can be one, for Alec's rape of Tess is complex. But, one can say that the economic disparity between the two is at least one factor. When Tess goes to the d'Urberville family, she is both asking for money and working as a servant. Remember, Tess is very aware that both her family's well-being and her father’s health rely on her ability to make money. As such, Alec is in a situation of power, as he can give Tess money or even marry her. Instead, he commits an act of sexual assault. And he does so with the security of knowing that Tess, a woman without money, has minimal ability to defend herself or bring him to justice.

Capitalism plays a more positive role in Phase the Third. Tess is able to leave the prying eyes of her hometown to find work at Talbothays Dairy. Tess's ability to change her circumstances, find work, make money, and build a better life are considered to be the hallmarks of capitalism. Angel Clare’s character similarly presents a positive view. Even though he came from a well-off background, he is not required to join the clergy like his brothers. Instead, he can do what makes him happy: farming. These advantages of capitalism—freedom and the pursuit of happiness—are why many individuals immigrated to capitalist countries over the course of the late 1800s and 1900s.

The novel’s culmination, however, reveals yet another aspect of capitalism. Believing Angel will never return to her, Tess returns to Alec. Consider the dramatic tension at the start of Phase the Seventh: Angel does not yet know of Tess's transformative new wealth, and the readers, though suspect of her choice to return to Alec, are as shocked as he is to find her so richly clothed. It is no coincidence that once she has access to wealth she is able to have greater agency in life, killing Alec for his crimes against her. This reveals yet another aspect of capitalism, the inevitable equation of money to power.

Approved by eNotes Editorial